News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Opinion: How Apple could have prevented the iPhone-slowdo... by ComputerGuru on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:49AM (#15994927)
I don’t know if I’m just too old having lived through the old nickel-cadmium “memory effect” days, it everybody I know - techie or not - already knows and accepts that batteries “get old” and then “die faster” and “don’t charge right” as the device ages.

Lithium battery tech today is an incredible step forward, but simply acknowledging the still existent limitations of the battery and it’s lifespan seems like a much simpler and saner solution than building a house of cards trying to hide that reality.

Battery dying in 2 hours after a full charge? Time to get it replaced. If your device is still under warranty, it’s free. Otherwise it’s 80 bucks and you’re golden. What’s the big deal?

Instead we have this nonsense approach to pretend that batteries live forever at such a cost.

And then you have the people that pop up out of the woodworks in each and every single iPhone battery life thread to say "it's not that the battery dies faster, it's that the phone suddenly shuts off at 60% [or whatever]," which is an absolute load of BS. The iPhone 6S was the first device to have that problem (I went to the Apple store within a year of its release with my iPhone 6S and spent over 3 hours explaining to the tech what was going on despite what his fancy charts and on-chip reporting software saw until he relented and gave me a replacement phone well before Apple ever acknowledged the issue and initiated the limited recall) - and it's the equivalent of a bug in the hardware design.

As a battery ages, the "definition" of 100% slides (as the charge cycles go up the charge capacity goes down - although it's not that simple since li-ion batteries also retain some form of the old cadmium cell memory effect that doesn't scale in a directly linear fashion with the charge cycles, but not to an appreciable extent that would have a bearing on this particular matter), but there's no reason that a device should die at 60% of its _remaining_ battery life. Except that the iPhone 6S' hardware was designed in such a way that it demanded current that could only be supplied at a voltage in excess of what the reduced-capacity battery could supply, leading to the problem at hand.

This is just me guessing, but I'm fairly convinced of the truth here: Apple didn't implement CPU scaling to improve the end user experience nor to make money off of "planned obsolescence" but rather to avoid having to replace phones/batteries within and without the warranty period (as a recall was warranted due to the faulty design) and decided to implement a software _workaround_ (and decidedly _not_ a _fix_) to get all but the most susceptible phones to avoid the scenario that would trigger the brownout.

Re:Opinion: How Apple could have prevented the iPhone-slowdo... by xenadu02 on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:15PM (#15996543)
There is no such thing as "100%" or "60%" or any other battery meter number. They are all guesstimates based on the battery's history and cycle count.

Li-ion batteries don't have a simple voltage-charge relationship like lead-acid batteries do so you can't actually know the real charge state of the battery (and even those have a number of ways the battery chemistry can get messed up).

I'll also note that your specific battery history matters a lot. If you leave your phone on a hot car dash in the summer even once it will dramatically alter that battery's performance. It isn't as simple as saying it cuts the lifetime... the battery's ability to deliver peak current is affected.

Re:Opinion: How Apple could have prevented the iPhone-slowdo... by ComputerGuru on Saturday December 23, 2017 @06:25PM (#15996912)
(I’m sorry I wasn’t clearer, but I am not in any way insinuating that there isn’t a problem where iPhones shut down at > 10% as they age - the “BS” referred to are the claims that it’s an intrinsic problem with batteries that couldn’t be dealt with otherwise and not a symptom of bad design on Apple’s behalf that failed to properly handle limited power scenarios. I’ve posted a more detailed comment about what the right thing to do in this situation is earlier today, you can find it in my comment history. Additionally, there is no doubt that Apple has had this problem in their designs for some time and across a range of products but the iPhone 6S was by far the worst culprit.)
Re:Opinion: How Apple could have prevented the iPhone-slowdo... by dordoka on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:14PM (#15996038)
Same experience: 6S started shutting down at about 20% after less than a year. I recall searching for this problem and finding that Apple acknowledged that "it's a bug" and that they were working on a fix. The fix came out, but they didn't explain in what way: since then I have an underperforming 6S (50% of average geekbench score) and nobody told me why untill now. Totally agree with your guess of the reason: it was cheaper to do that in software than to replace a lot of batteries, also avoiding the PR nightmare.
Re:Opinion: How Apple could have prevented the iPhone-slowdo... by pronoiac on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:46PM (#15995267)
> And then you have the people that pop up out of the woodworks in each and every single iPhone battery life thread to say "it's not that the battery dies faster, it's that the phone suddenly shuts off at 60% [or whatever]," which is an absolute load of BS. The iPhone 6S was the first device to have that problem ...

Nope! I had an iPhone 3GS which would die at 30-40% if I turned on GPS.

Re:Opinion: How Apple could have prevented the iPhone-slowdo... by mthoms on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:14PM (#15995704)
I'll add my voice as well.

I had a 5s that shutdown randomly at around 30-40%.

On a hunch I replaced the battery and the problem was solved. I can't say if performance improved or not since I gifted it to someone.

Re:Opinion: How Apple could have prevented the iPhone-slowdo... by bluedino on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:10PM (#15995385)
>> The iPhone 6S was the first device to have that problem

My 4S and my 2009 MacBook Pro would both randomly shut off under 40% or so after they were 2 years old.