Re:Cadavers in the ballroom: Drs practice their craft in Ame...
by DoreenMichele on Friday December 22, 2017 @11:56AM
(#15988889)
Germ carrying people have functioning immune systems. Cadavers do not. They are just laying there rotting, like a giant Petri dish with no lid in which a mix of multiple unnamed microbes have been bred and are now running wild.
Re:Cadavers in the ballroom: Drs practice their craft in Ame...
by phren0logy on Friday December 22, 2017 @01:49PM
(#15989862)
This is incorrect, they are heavily preserved.
Re:Cadavers in the ballroom: Drs practice their craft in Ame...
by DoreenMichele on Friday December 22, 2017 @02:15PM
(#15990091)
It isn't like that had not occurred to me.
But Superbugs keep adapting to antibiotics etc. I am skeptical of the idea that dunking dead bodies in chemicals is anywhere near as effective as a living immune system.
Living microbes seem to adapt if all they are faced with is poison of some sort. In fact, petrochemical spills can be remediated with an injection of microbes that eat petrochemicals.
Re:Cadavers in the ballroom: Drs practice their craft in Ame...
by bastawhiz on Friday December 22, 2017 @01:27PM
(#15989672)
If we don't know the risk of something, especially if there is the possibility of serious illness, then we should stop doing it until we do know the risk. After all, it's not like convention centers are the only place where these things can be held. Imagine the headlines: "Disney tourists contract _______ because doctors did not know the risks of bringing dead bodies into convention center"
Yes, the word "risk" is used. But the Osterholm quote is not a medical risk analysis. To decide what, if anything, should be done differently, it is necessary to both quantify the risk, and decide what level of risk the public finds tolerable for convention centers.
I would be surprised if the risk of infectious disease from cadavers in the convention center is as high as the risk of infectious disease when the convention center is packed to capacity with germ-carrying people there to watch power point presentations.