News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by extension on Thursday August 12, 2010 @06:11AM (#1597694)
Um, congrats on his success solving a big problem, but... it took him twenty years to figure out how to flick a switch from a mile away?

Has anybody shown him these things? http://www.electronicplus.com/images/products/TN811C.jpg

For that matter, is it so hard to run a mile of wire across a field?

 

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by chime on Thursday August 12, 2010 @06:31AM (#1597722)
> Has anybody shown him these things? http://www.electronicplus.com/images/products/TN811C.jpg

The article did mention a simple timer. I'm going to guess there is some additional complexity in turning on the water that a multi-mode timer cannot handle. Timer comes on at 2am and shuts off at 3am automatically but what happens when there is a power failure between 2.10am and 2.50am? That happens in India ALL the time. Now you missed 40 minutes of watering. A human might be able to take that into account by turning it off at 3.30am instead remotely.

> For that matter, is it so hard to run a mile of wire across a field?

Not hard, just expensive. The Indian farmers he's aiming to help are the ones making $1-$5/day. They might understand the long-term ROI on such an investment but they might not be able to afford it.

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by jacquesm on Thursday August 12, 2010 @08:13AM (#1597853)
If the power fails they'll come on at the wrong time.

Of course the pumps will not be able to run when there is no power but it might be less than ideal to run the pumps at the wrong time.

That said, you could solve that fairly easily by running the timer circuitry off a rechargeable battery and drive the pumps through a relay. When there's power the battery recharges from the grid, when the power has failed for a while the timer hasn't lost track of the time of day.

I wonder how much an SMS message costs an indian farmer (it also requires an extra cell phone), it might very well be a substantial part of the cost of operation. In the end it's a convenience thing (you don't have to walk) which is worth some $ or it would have to save money or create a better yield.

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by statictype on Thursday August 12, 2010 @08:53AM (#1597928)
I wonder how much an SMS message costs an indian farmer (it also requires an extra cell phone), it might very well be a substantial part of the cost of operation. In the end it's a convenience thing (you don't have to walk) which is worth some $ or it would have to save money or create a better yield.

Indian mobile networks are fairly well connected. And sending local SMS messages are, for all practical purposes, free. Cell phones can be had for US$30. Possibly less.

If you want to build technology-related services that are accessible to the largest possible part of the Indian population, using SMS as a protocol is probably the right way to go.

(Edit: But from what I understood, this device involves phoning a number and using a keypad to issue commands. )

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by chime on Thursday August 12, 2010 @08:58AM (#1597937)
> If the power fails they'll come on at the wrong time.

I was assuming the timer was battery-powered and not prone to power failure, while the pumps were. This could cause the timer to turn on the pumps, not detect that the pumps were off for 40 minutes during the cycle because of power failures, and then shut off the pumps after a predetermined duration. So the timer would start/stop a one hour cycle but during those times, the pumps would only work for 20 minutes. That could cause crops to fail because the pumps didn't irrigate sufficient water.

To fix this, you'd need a timer that would also detect the duration the pumps were working and adjust accordingly, increasing the cost of the system. Plus how does the timer deal with the next cycle schedule to start at 4am-5am when it has been pumping 30-40mins extra before the cycle before it took longer? I was just trying to say that setting up a workable schedule on such a device could be a lot more complex/expensive than a human texting "pump 2 on", "pump 2 off".

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by jacquesm on Thursday August 12, 2010 @09:02AM (#1597942)
But a human texting 'pump 2 on' suffers from the exact same problem, compounded by the delays of receiving the SMS (which in my case sometimes only appear hours or days after sending).

So it was meant as being the exact equivalent of what they have now. (I didn't see any evidence of a feedback mechanism in the article but I may have overlooked that).

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by pinstriped_dude on Thursday August 12, 2010 @05:05PM (#1599247)
Cellphones are everywhere in India. Practically everyone already has a cellphone, or is going to get one this week. Text Messages (locally called SMS) are often free, or are dirt cheap. It is common even for low-wage workers (day labourers, porters, gardeners) to have cell-phones in India. This is, in part because the landline infrastructure is very poor and unreliable, and a open economy has meant that cellphone operators have been able to provide good service for really competitive rates.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_in_India

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by kranner on Thursday August 12, 2010 @08:38AM (#1597901)
SMS is cheap in India. You can get plans with upto 500 messages a day for 99 rupees a month.
Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by maheshs on Thursday August 12, 2010 @09:48AM (#1598064)
99 rupees = $2
Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by jacquesm on Thursday August 12, 2010 @09:49AM (#1598067)
Someone should let Neelie Smit-Kroes in on that little secret.
Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by Setsuna on Thursday August 12, 2010 @10:33AM (#1598173)
why?
Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by jacquesm on Thursday August 12, 2010 @10:48AM (#1598204)
Because it's at least an order of magnitude more than what you'd pay in Europe for the same thing which is a good indicator that there is price fixing involved.
Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by Setsuna on Thursday August 12, 2010 @11:50AM (#1598378)
According to Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SMS

The key idea for SMS was to use this telephony-optimized system, and to transport messages on the signaling paths needed to control the telephony traffic during time periods when no signaling traffic existed. In this way, unused resources in the system could be used to transport messages at minimal cost.

So, in a sense sending SMS doesn't have to be so costly.

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by kranner on Thursday August 12, 2010 @10:57AM (#1598232)
Are you sure?

500 messages a day costs < $0.07 total. It's cheaper than that in Europe?

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by jacquesm on Thursday August 12, 2010 @11:04AM (#1598246)
No, rather the opposite.
Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by cubicle67 on Thursday August 12, 2010 @07:21AM (#1597786)
The comment from Anandshree seems to answer that:

I am making a comment based on the irrigation needs of an Indian farmer in Indian scenario. I think, the mobile based solution is best for the Indian farmers who want to monitor and switch on off their pumpset from wherever they are, maybe in the farms, residence, market or on travel. In the timers, there is no monitoring of whether a pump is on or off, whether a power is available or not at the pump.But, the mobile connectivity makes it is possible to check the status. Plus , in the agriculture, there might be needs of so many times of on/off of the pumps in the irrigation processes depending on the actual physical status in the farms activities. Hence, it needs a perfect engineering solution based on closed loop system rather than an open loop systems like timers.A perfect engineering solves the problems in an emerging market very much effectively, but for that someone must undestand the needs of an emerging market and for which there is only a way - to be among them and to understand their needs. No question of blaming anybody's situation or no question of contraversy about Indian or Non Indian should arise, but a real attitude to help a human being in the problems is a must.

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by kranner on Thursday August 12, 2010 @07:19AM (#1597780)
"so hard to run a mile of wire across a field?"

It's hard to keep that mile of wire from being pinched.

I remember how the highway authority here in Punjab had embedded blinking lights into the road's surface, over some stretches of road, to help drivers during our foggy winters. A few days after the lights went in, they were dug out and stolen. So new ones were put in. Gone again. New lights. Gone again. Finally the highway authority gave up and left the citizenry to its fate.

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by meric on Thursday August 12, 2010 @09:50AM (#1598070)
When I was in a small city in China visiting my relatives, they pointed at some of the 50cm by 50cm "drains" on the street gutter filled with shattered stones.

In the beginning, they had metal guards but they kept getting stolen. Then they had concrete guards with a metal wire skeleton. Those covers got smashed and the metal wires taken out of them. Now they just have concrete guards but people smash them anyway.

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by jacquesm on Thursday August 12, 2010 @08:15AM (#1597856)
Wire - sometimes even high voltage cabling - is stolen all over Europe (and probably the world) for the copper. Not a few accidents happen with people trying to steal a live wire.

http://www.google.com/search?q=cable+thieves+electrocuted

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by sanjayb on Thursday August 12, 2010 @07:51AM (#1597827)
once a bus-stop was stolen. http://www.mid-day.com/news/2008/oct/151008-Borivali-bus-sto... . wire - hrmph ...
Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by RodgerTheGreat on Thursday August 12, 2010 @10:09AM (#1598107)
This may be an overly simplistic approach, but if you're worried about something in a fixed position getting stolen, isn't it easy to stake the location out for a day or two and nab your thief? Even if it's a systemic problem, making an example of a few criminals should discourage others from stealing.
Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by kranner on Thursday August 12, 2010 @10:37AM (#1598178)
Sorry, too simplistic.

The police and highway patrol have bigger problems and you'd need to stake out long stretches of road indefinitely, pretty much.

Also, making an example of convicted criminals doesn't work. I'd assume thieves risking life and limb to yank LEDs and cable from the middle of a highway in the dark are desperate (and probably poor) enough not to care about precedents.

Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by ajju on Thursday August 12, 2010 @01:02PM (#1598578)
In Atlanta, there are gangs stealing A.C. units from outside offices for the $50 worth of copper wiring they contain!
Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by extension on Thursday August 12, 2010 @02:03PM (#1598732)
What prevents the rest of the pump system from being stolen?
Re:Jugaad, an inspired kind of duct-taped ingenuity by suraj on Friday August 13, 2010 @05:13AM (#1600461)
It is usually housed in an metal enclosure founded in concrete. Much harder to steal than a wire.