https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-cjfTG8DbwA
"America is too spread out" is a bullshit argument. You put the rail architecture back in and you'll watch communities draw inward, zoning laws merge and neighborhoods get closer and more sustainable.
Access to transportation is the biggest factor in being able to move out of poverty. That's not a subjective statement. It's been verified in study after study.
Don't like living next to people and hate public transport? That's fine. There are tons of Europeans and Australians like that who live outside the cities and drive. They have that choice, because the cities are affordable and livable. Every Australian capital has commuter rail except Darwin, Hobart and ACT. In America, it's incredibly difficult to live without a car in almost every major city and most of our capitals, and we have a far far greater population density.
It may well be a bullshit argument, but it's also an argument that I did not make.
My point was entirely that the markets do not seem to value high speed rail highly enough to justify its costs, and that the U.S. (for its faults) largely represents this low market valuation of high speed rail by not financing it. You seem to make an argument with the assumption that you know the utility of high speed rail is higher than the cost, I avoid this assumption.
High speed rail is apparently worth less than it costs, state pricing distortions included. You might like it, it might be attractive, it might make things more dense, you might think that's a good thing... and none of that matters because apparently it's just not worth it to the market which will be tasked with funding it, all things considered.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intercity-Express
Or the Shinkansen:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shinkansen
(a major cultural touchstone for Japan in additon to the economic aspects).
When a Thalys route was opened between Paris and Brussels (200 miles), Air France withdrew their flights and booked seats on the train instead. American, Delta and JetA also operate a code sharing route on the train route.
Beyond Brussels, Skyteam group uses Thalys to link Brussels with Schipol.
So, yeah, link cities as you would with plane (airport time included), and High Speed Rail works. I've used it, and it's a vast improvement over wasting time in airports and jumping through air travel 'security' hoops.
Shinkansen are very popular in Japan. I don't know how you could not call them a success story.
The Shinkansen may have some popular (profitable) lines, but it took a long time for the service to shed the lines which were built for purely political reasons under JNR. The fascist approach to building rail lines relies on hiding the true cost of rail (across private land) in subsidies and loans which are structured out of successors and written off by the government.