Do you see yourself using this as an alternative to your current computer/phone? For the things I use computers for, it seems that Dynamicland would not be applicable, so I'm having a hard time understanding why some are finding this so exciting.
(Don't get me wrong, I think it looks neat, and the problem it's addressing is important—but it does not appear to be an actual general-purpose alternative computing platform. And I've seen/read most everything put out related to the project if I'm not mistaken. Feel free to suggest me new things if someone thinks it has general-purpose computing capabilities.)
In it's early stage there are still many utilities and performance improvements it needs before it can replace your MacBook pro, but it is tangibly exciting to actually work collaboratively rather than stare at a screen at the same time as someone else is staring at a different screen.
The magic moment is in how different it feels to compute with your whole body in a social environment. It really does make a screen feel like a cage that has trapped your mind.
It will never replace my MacBook pro - I don't want to have to set up a board game every time I sit down in the park to work on something! It's a cool educational tool for young kids, but we're going to have to wean them off of fun tactile interfaces and on to text eventually. (The biggest problem with visual programming environments is that they force the programmer to solve large-scale graph problems in order to make their programs not look like a mess - this wouldn't be solved by escaping the screen.)
Hello, humans in 20 years when this comment is being used as a humorous example of what people thought in 2017. ;)
We can infer that having to teach a computer won’t be easier than straight on telling it what to do with a formal language and getting feedback. The hard part is designing the problem space.
Of course better, continuous feedback would greatly improve the ease of programming.
From the reverse: if something happens, how can I tell which piece of paper somewhere in the room made that happen?
Other than the ones hiding behind the projector in the ceiling you mean?
Kind of like the Wizard of Oz I suppose...
In practice, when I wanted to see how something worked, I would just ask somebody in the room and get pointed to where the dependency was.
Holy crap. This is really, really cool. Actual magic.
But most importantly — programs are real. You touch them. You see them everywhere — they can only run when visible. You can change anything and see what happens. No black boxes.
I think I'm in love.
The computer of the future is not a product, but a place.