News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by sxp on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @03:57AM (#15958757)
I'm wary of anyone who tries to explain complex numbers without pictures. The best explanation of complex numbers that I've ever seen is http://acko.net/blog/how-to-fold-a-julia-fractal/. I wish that explaination existed when I was struggling with my Electrical Engineering classes in college.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by dsacco on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:46AM (#15960120)
You want to be careful with that. Pictures can be helpful in mathematical education (especially in something like a first course in real analysis), but if you get accustomed to relying on learning with pictures your mathematical intuition can break down once you arrive at a place where pictures don’t make sense.

Once you’re working in k-dimensions, where k > 3 (or maybe 4), you can’t rely on pictures anymore because there is no satisfying depiction of 4 or greater dimensions on a 2 dimensional medium. Complex numbers can be learned this way because they’re (simplified) the set R^2. Number systems in general are sort of okay to learn this way because they typically just extend other number systems, so you can successively build intuition on top of previous abstractions.

But you won’t really “learn” a lot of much more complicated topological or geometric (and therein analytic) concepts if you can’t build intuition without “seeing” it. As a very simple example, contrast these two approaches to defining a trivial concept in topology, which you’d probably come across before complex numbers in an analysis course:

1. A neighborhood of a point p in a Euclidean space is the set of all q such that d(p, q) < r, where r is some radius greater than 0.

2. A neighborhood is a circle (or sphere) with a radius of r surrounding a point p.

One of those feels more immediately intuitive, but that’s only because we’re dealing with the simple case of k = 2 or 3. You can’t “dodge” the complexity by visualizing it once you get into higher k, you have to just formalize it to develop intuition rigorously. Definition 1 is useful because it abstracts to conceptual domains we cannot practically visualize. Definition 2 would be useful if you could build a visual intuition of a 3-sphere, or 4-sphere, and so on. But building a visual intuition of k > 3 dimensions just shifts the problem away from what you’re trying to learn to something that is just as difficult: eventually you have to just get comfortable staring at a page of frustrating numbers, unfortunately.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by alimw on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @10:45AM (#15960938)
> 1. A neighborhood of a point p in a Euclidean space is the set of all q such that d(p, q) < r, where r is some radius greater than 0.

Isn't that what mathematicians call a ball rather than a neighbourhood? A name which rather suggests that they are visualising it.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by dsacco on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:13PM (#15961719)
Not really, no. It’s a neighborhood. A ball is one description of a neighborhood in a specific context. I hesitate to link to Wikipedia, but: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neighbourhood_(mathematics)

It would not be correct to use terminology like “ball” to describe a “neighborhood”, even if, in specific instances, they are the same representation in different contexts (i.e. geometric vs analytic).

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by xelxebar on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @03:26AM (#15967937)
Balls are definable in metric spaces, neighborhoods in general topological ones, so "neighborhood" is indeed the more general term.

That said, once we have a metric space, the metric balls give a natural basis for the topology, which means that every theorem about neighborhoods has a corresponding one that uses balls instead. So in practice, when in a metric space we just use balls everywhere because they let us exploit their extra structure if it's needed. This is why you see the abuse of language calling neighborhoods balls, despite that being technically incorrect.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by alimw on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @02:12PM (#15963110)
I am not using 'ball' to describe a neighbourhood, you are using 'neighbourhood' to describe a ball! From your own link:

In a metric space M=(X,d), a set V is a neighbourhood of a point p if there exists an open ball with centre p and radius r>0, such that B_r (p)=B(p;r)={x∈X | d(x,p)<r} is contained in V. (My emphasis.)

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by philipov on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:17PM (#15961767)
A sphere is the surface of a ball. Your criticism applies to (2) but not to (1).

However, 'ball' is from geometry, while 'neighborhood' is from analysis. They overlap, but they're not to be confused, because 'neighborhood' is used to emphasize that one should not visualize it.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by dsacco on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:33PM (#15961941)
> However, 'ball' is from geometry, while 'neighborhood' is from analysis. They overlap, but they're not to be confused, because 'neighborhood' is used to emphasize that one should not visualize it.

You’re right, but in fairness I’ve seen multiple analysis textbook authors use terms like “circle” and “ball” to describe a neighborhood in topology. This is usually in the fashion, “...(in other words, E is a ball.”

This is precisely the sort of thing I dislike, because aside from being technically incorrect like you say, it can (for that section) encourage a student to think, “Oh, why didn’t he just say that?” and skip the heavier definition -> theorem -> proof sequence preceding it, to the detriment of understanding later material.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by vorotato on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:52AM (#15960568)
That's actually untrue. 3 Blue 1 Brown has an excellent example of how you can use visuals to aid intuition in higher dimensional thinking. It's just not the naive representation.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by mjburgess on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:15PM (#15961737)
Yes, I think this advice isn't quite right.

A pictorial formalism is possible for most if not all mathematical concepts as much as a symbolic.

It just won't be naive and may not have been systematically developed and communicated / taught anywhere.

The issue here is mostly just an awareness that, naively, the pictures change fast than the formula. (r^1, r^2, r^3... look more a like than lines, circles and spheres).

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by dsacco on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:20PM (#15961797)
I agree with what you and the parent are saying here, and I suppose I didn’t well enough communicate my meaning. To clarify, I am focusing on the naive representations, which I find people rely on too much. It is easy to learn lower dimensions naively and feel like they make sense, but you won’t bridge that understanding to higher dimensions as seamlessly as going from a point to a line to a circle to a sphere, etc.

And for the pictorial representations which do exist, implicit in understanding them is the symbolic information. Conversely, you can understand common naive representations without an implicit understanding of the formalism. For example, we all know what a circle is before we know about irrational numbers, but it’s silly to try and understand a 5-cell or a tesseract without a broader understanding of k-dimensional space. It’s precisely that naive intuition that doesn’t generalize well.

In other words, my point more simply was caution: use pictures, but don’t replace symbolic formalism with them, just use them augment your understanding once you’ve at least sort of got it.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by dsacco on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:16PM (#15961751)
Yeah, good point. I like 3Blue1Brown’s videos but in fairness I would say that video is quite a bit closer to the formal side of things than the visual side. I was talking about naive representations - if you build up to the compound visualization 3B1B walks through you’ve covered a lot of the rigor implicitly.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by logfromblammo on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @11:44AM (#15961464)
It's okay if you also develop the skill of constructing a duplicate mental picture from a sufficiently detailed description of it.

Build up your picture-mirroring skill on 2-dimensional and 3-dimensional pictures, and you can eventually imagine pictures with more dimensions. Maybe you could even manage an animation in 4-dimensions. About the only thing I can reliably imagine in 6 or more dimensions is a hypersphere, and even that might be incorrect if one of the dimensions is not mutually perpendicular to all the others or if its basis vector doesn't square to itself.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by salvar on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:56AM (#15960601)
Would you say there is a use for imagery, or should it never be applied because there is a risk of someone, somewhere, becoming reliant on it?
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by dsacco on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:29PM (#15961894)
I would say there is absolutely a use for imagery - I wouldn’t advise learning real or complex analysis of without visual aids :). I just think they are easily abused and used to mask gaps in formal knowledge.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by sgdread on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @05:10PM (#15974320)
You have to start somewhere. Once idea is visualized and internalized on lower dimensions, you move to the next level, where images not needed; however to get to that step 0, where you understand why complex numbers used in AC: lots of folks never bother to explain that it's just the best way to describe rotation.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by Grue3 on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @05:27AM (#15959191)
I'd rather be wary of explaining mathematical concepts with pictures. Pictures are known to be highly misleading and force the reader to imagine a thing in a certain way. For example, most pictures of triangles have all 3 angles being acute. This leads people into forgetting the case when one of the angles is obtuse.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by i2om3r on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:48AM (#15959788)
You can explain things with more than a single picture. You can also play with pictures in your mind, and you can encourage students to do so by giving them more than one picture. Visualizing corner cases is often very useful. For triangles, you can change angles and side lengths and see which facts still hold and which don't and how certain values/function results develop.

Moreover, it very much depends on who your target group is. My brain, for example, works entirely inductively (in the beginning). I won't be able to develop an intuition of something if I don't start with examples. Pictures are often good examples. During my undergrad studies, my linear algebra prof was as critical about pictures as you and other commenters here. I hated it. I was never able to get an intuition about the more abstract topics until I saw concrete examples including pictures in later lectures and projects. Moreover, not everyone is going to be a theoretical mathematician or quantum physicist. I suspect that by not showing pictures, you usually lose more students along the way than pictures would ruin students that need a fully abstract understanding (later). It would be interesting to see some data on this, but I guess its going to be difficult to collect.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by mathgenius on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:07AM (#15959561)
"Algebra is the offer made by the devil to the mathematician. The devil says: I will give you this powerful machine, it will answer any question you like. All you need to do is give me your soul: give up geometry and you will have this marvelous machine." — Sir Michael Atiyah, 2002
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by wglb on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:00AM (#15959852)
Ok, so how would you explain venn diagrams without pictures? How would you describe Mandelbrot sets without pictures? How would you explain hyperbolic parabaloids without pictures? How would you explain conic sections without pictures? How would you explain a trapezoid without pictures? How would you describe a sine wave without pictures? Eversion of a sphere? How would you illustrate the calculation of the slope of a curve when talking about derivatives without pictures? How about a cycloid? How would you show the representation of a signal in both time domain and frequency domain?
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by Grue3 on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:11AM (#15959923)
>How would you describe Mandelbrot sets without pictures?

It's literally easier to describe Mandelbrot set without the picture than with it. The set of complex numbers c where recursive equation "z_n = z_(n-1)^2 + c, z_0 = 0" does not diverge.

In fact, the picture of a Mandelbrot set is actively misleading! You think you can see the set, but it's a fractal! It's infinitely complex in a way that cannot be shown in a picture.

>Eversion of a sphere?

Pretty sure that one was figured out way before anyone was able to visualize it. Same with Banach-Tarski paradox. These things resist visual intuition in the first place, so it's much safer to rely on equations when dealing with problems like these.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by wglb on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:23AM (#15959993)
If you read of the early work that Mandelbrot did on this equation, you will recall that despite having those symbols in front of him, he had to plot it out, crudely at first on a line printer, before he fully understood the implications.

Thus pictures are not only tutorial but a fundamental necessity for understanding mathematics.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by Simon_says on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @10:41AM (#15960904)
You picked possibly the worst example for what you're trying to say. Nobody knew it was a fractal until it was plotted. Proving it's a fractal was done with a written, rigorous proof, but the intuition for where to look came from the pictures.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by Falkens_Maze on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @05:45AM (#15959266)
Completely agree. It's what Prof. Susskind states in one of his lectures on QM explaining quantum fields. Eventually pictures and mental abstractions break down, and it's better to not visualize.

At some point, one's limited biological brain will be unable to fully perceive or visualize some mathematical object. That's where intuition comes in.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by jules on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:07AM (#15960264)
You can still reason by analogy with something you can visualise. You can't visualise 3+1 = 4 spacetime dimensions, but you can pretend that space has 2 dimensions so that you can visualise it as 2+1 dimensions. Blind algebra rarely works. I think that many have an optimistic view of blind algebra because proofs are often stated as algebra without geometric intuition, even when the author of the theorem almost certainly used geometric intuition to come up with it. This can give a false impression. I've seen people struggle tremendously with simple proofs in Hilbert spaces, when the corresponding proof in 2 dimensions is easy by drawing a picture and translating that into algebra that works just as well in the more general setting. For example, let S be a closed subspace of Hilbert space H and x in H. Prove |x-y| is minimised over y in S iff x-y is orthogonal to S.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by AstralStorm on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @06:09PM (#15965320)
Analogies break down as easily as they are helpful. On average, they help mathematical intuition less than expected. (Check Bose-Einstein thought experiments and the mathematics they spawned for an example.)

QM went into blind math side way past any analogies. Yet it is currently matching observations which is as good as it gets with true.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by jules on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:50PM (#15965995)
QM did not go into blind math mode. The way physicists usually do QM is by glossing over a lot of the subtleties of Hilbert spaces and act as if the results from finite dimensional linear algebra work. Concepts physicists have been using for a long time, such as the Dirac delta function and path integrals, only got formalised much later. Many revolutions in QM, such as Feynman diagrams, are very much based on intuition. You can transfer all of that back into formal math, as Dyson did, but Dyson could not have done so without Feynman having invented them first.

Especially in mathematics it is fashionable to write proofs in a style that completely erases the reasoning that lead to the proof. I think that's a pity. So much unwritten knowledge gets lost that way when the originators die. Differential forms, for example, have a beautiful geometric interpretation, but the way they're taught nowadays obscures that completely and makes it seem like they're a formal algebraic tool only. In fact, we're now several generations later, so even some of the instructors may be unaware of that, because their own instructors failed to transfer the original geometric intuition!

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by yummy on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:23AM (#15959619)
On the contrary, graphs is a good example, when pictures make perfect sense and any other way is rather meaningless for human brain. But yes, algebra specifically and pictures don't gel.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by crispyambulance on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:06AM (#15959557)
Yep, although theorems and proofs are, of course, central to mathematics, pictures are absolutely essential for developing intuition and for introducing concepts.

In the case of complex analysis, pictures are critical for explaining the contour integrals for example. The pictures do not mislead, they elucidate.

That said, there's nothing wrong with the OP article. It is an introductory piece and folks seeing this stuff for the first time do well with a variety of approaches to the topic-- this one happens to not use pictures. That's OK.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by roenxi on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:06AM (#15959559)
Heartily agreeing. If the Reals are fundamentally the set of all points that make up a line, the "imaginary numbers" are the set of all 2d points in a plane. Turns out there was never a call to limit numbers to living in a straight line, but our notation was settled on before we realised that. I'm got grumpy just earlier this evening that the first 9 negative numbers didn't get their own glyphs.

i is basically "rotate by 90" in the same way -1 is "head left from 0 instead of right"

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by sjy on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:36AM (#15959716)
The set of all points in a plane is ℝ², not ℂ. ℂ has many special properties that aren't shared by ℝ²,[1] so while you can think of ℝ as just the number line, ℂ is more than just a plane.

[1]: https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/444475/whats-the-di...

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by posterboy on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:11AM (#15960278)
in the same way the imaginary numbers are more than the real number line, i * ℝ != ℝ.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by yequalsx on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:34AM (#15959701)
Complex numbers along with the Quaternions are the only finite dimensional associative division algebras that properly contain the reals. The interesting thing is that the 2d real space can be equipped with a multiplication operation that works. This isn’t always possible to do on a finite dimensional real vector space.

It happens to be true that this field called the complex numbers is a two dimensional real vector space. It took humans quite a long time to come up with 0 and negative numbers. There’s no way the jump to the complex numbers was going to be as easy and it isn’t as simple as, “numbers in 2d”. Why isn’t 3D a finite dimensional associative division algebra?

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by Meegul on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:36AM (#15960060)
You speak of a multiplication operation that "works", also stating that it's not always possible for a finite dimensional real vector space. Doesn't the definition of a real vector space require multiplication that "works" (through the scalar multiplication requirement) or are you referring to the multiplication between vectors within that space "working"?
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by yequalsx on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:43AM (#15960097)
Multiplication of vectors. That’s the meaning of the algebra word in the phrase, finite dimensional associative division algebra. In R^3 you can’t define multiplication of vectors in a way that works. That is, in a way that each vector can be multiplied by itself and in which each vector has a multiplicative inverse while preserving the real vector space structure.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by Meegul on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:28AM (#15960388)
Thanks! I'm still in the process of really grokking linear algebra as I only just took a class on it, so this is helpful.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by globuous on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:53AM (#15959814)
> If the Reals are fundamentally the set of all points that make up a line, the "imaginary numbers" are the set of all 2d points in a plane

I'm not sure that's true. It's a very good way to visualize complex numbers at first, but the set of points in a 2D plane does not define complex numbers.

That's a very interesting question actually, what is the difference between R^2 != C ? Here's someone's attempt at showing this (top answer): https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/444475/whats-the-di...

To me, trying to visualize complex numbers is an easy way to forget that R^2 != C.... They look the same but don't behave the same way (how do you multiply to members of R^2 with each other ? you need to define it, whereas multiplication in C is already defined). C doesn't behave like 2D vectors either. Since multiplying 2 complex is not the same as multiplying 2 vectors (whatever that means) although their components could be the same.

structure structure structure.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by zardo on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @01:57PM (#15962940)
>(how do you multiply to members of R^2 with each other ? you need to define it, whereas multiplication in C is already defined)

You can use the geometric product, and C falls out as a result.

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by beagle3 on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:40AM (#15960085)
> Turns out there was never a call to limit numbers to living in a straight line

There is no reason to limit to the plane either[0]. Or four dimensions for that matter[1]. Complex numbers have ways in which they are "more fundamental" than quaternions in the same ways that reals are "more fundamental" than complex numbers.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quaternion

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octonion

Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by arkj on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @04:29AM (#15958928)
Thank you for the brilliant link. I've been looking for a good explanation on complex numbers to share with a few struggling students.
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by mercer on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @05:41AM (#15959259)
That site is a work of art. Also, apparently I unlocked an achievement for refreshing the page!
Re:What are the complex numbers, really? by Kagerjay on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @12:17PM (#15961765)
coolest math site I've ever seen