* Discount rate of 6% (we're talking about an asset with a 40-year lifespan and zero terminal value).
* $25K in annual school costs.
* $25K in annual opportunity costs. (May be conservative for people who are college material but didn't get a degree.)
* Four years to complete the degree. Which is very aggressive.
* $23K earnings differential. (The current average.)
* Forty years of post-degree work.
In this model, you get to breakeven 26 years after you start school. So, to the current high-school senior: assuming the job market in 2036 looks pretty much like it does now, treat these projections as solid.
It gets worse. If you assume a more realistic graduation timeframe of six years, the value is -$18K after 40 years. Of course, you can keep working; you'll hit breakeven after 54 years (at age 72).
See sheet two for my assumptions:
https://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=0AjzB7A88UMCBdGVrUUN...
Your figure matches about what it costs to go to a private school, but, from my experience, public schools are also more likely to give scholarships [2]. Even still, no one is forced to go to a private school.
[1]: http://www.collegeboard.com/student/pay/add-it-up/4494.html
[2]: I went to a private school my first year. It was around $30k/yr, but I was also given a scholarship that cut that price to around $18k/yr. Most of the people I met on campus also received scholarships of some sort as well.
The public schools I applied to that weren't rolling-admission 5th year of highschool types ended up costing the same in the end, because they didn't give need-based aid, and their merit scholarships were not large for people who don't play sports.
Merit scholarships are easy to achieve, given that you are exceptional. But if you are middle class and not especially proficient, I do agree that you have one of the hardest college experiences in america.
Also, if we were to put opportunity cost into the calculations (because you could work/work more if not going to school), it would quickly approach the $25K figure.
[1]http://www.collegeboard.com/student/pay/add-it-up/4494.html
A median of $9k is still less than half of what the GP used, and my cost of tuition is a lot closer to the average than the $25k the GP used.
Also, if we were to put opportunity cost into the calculations (because you could work/work more if not going to school), it would quickly approach the $25K figure.
Which the GP already did.
So run those numbers assuming school costs of 15K, opportunity costs of 5k, 23K earnings differential, and student loan costs of 3.5% tax deductable.
PS: A friend of mine worked his way through school making 7.50$ an hour as a cook at without student loans. He worked 80hours a week in the summer and 40 hours a week during school and graduated in 4.5 years. He also lived in a trailer with his wife and child and got an internship his senior year at 13$ an hour it was a major pay raise.
You're right about summer jobs, but the vast majority of summer jobs pay less than 1/4 of what you'd get working the full year (plus you have to do a job search for a three-month job, versus a job-search for a multi-year job). Outside of law school summer associates, I don't know of anyone for whom summer jobs routinely mean a raise.
I like your friend's story! But imagine if, after four years, he had credible evidence that he could work extremely hard, plus tens of thousands of dollars in savings. A good situation to be in if he wants to start a business.
Google "college dropout rates". Consensus figures seem to be around 40% of enrollees don't have a degree 6 years later.
That's not valid.
If you found data that said, for example, 30% of college graduates took longer than 6 years to earn their undergraduate degrees, then I would agree with you.
If it's less than 10%, then the using 6 years as a cutoff would be a very good rule of thumb estimate.
Maybe the reason why the 6 year cutoff is so often used is because someone already crunched the numbers and found it was good enough?
No. I provided a counterexample that falsifies an implicit assumption of the 6-year cutoff model of the college dropout rate. If you measure your dropout rate as the percentage of students who have not graduated within 6 years of enrollment, it is provably true that your measurement is an overestimate of the true value.
"Maybe the reason why the 6 year cutoff is so often used is because someone already crunched the numbers and found it was good enough?"
If someone had already crunched the numbers, the appropriate correction factor to apply to the 6-year measurement would be well-known and, instead of reporting the 6-year cutoff value, a distribution-corrected 6-year cutoff value would have been reported instead. If nobody crunched the numbers to find out what the characteristics of the distribution's tail are, then the methodology is sloppy. If a correction factor was applied but not explicitly mentioned where the value is reported, then the reporting is sloppy. Either way, a reasonable person is justified in regarding the reported value as merely an upper bound on the dropout rate and rejecting the assertion that it is an accurate measurement of the true value.
It's something the feds and various boards are really interested in.
I think most people got mortgages because it was a sure thing investment that appreciates over time. That didn't hold true.
I'm arguing that a college education doesn't exactly equate to a higher salary these days.
Even if diploma-wielding programmers can command high salaries in boom times, they have a tougher time getting jobs when there are unemployed programmers with degrees applying for the same jobs during a recession.
then do you think that there will be a crash in this area, and if so, how bad do you think it will be?
i imagine it wouldn't sneak up on us like the housing crash because of the nature of the loans, but that it could lead to a longer, lingering problem kicked off by the housing crash.
Degrees clearly are great revenue producing machines for the portion of the workforce currently unemployed with degrees. I remember a few years ago, "The housing market can't crash, it's impossible, it's the only safe investment vehicle after all of those silly tech stocks".
The unemployment rate for degree-holders in the US is currently 4.5%, compared to 10.5% overall. The bulk of the unemployed are in blue-collar sectors and among those who have graduated with a high school diploma or less. We can argue about what is or isn't an "acceptable rate" of unemployment, but typically for America it's been 4-5% unemployment. That even in this Great Recession, degree-holding citizen unemployment sits within the "acceptable" range, tells you that there is tons of value to getting better educated in this country at this time, and even in this climate.
In fact, it looks like the unemployment rate for college-educated workers is falling:
http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2010/07/28/high-unempl...
If your loan repayments are $700 a month when you graduate, they will be $700 a month for the next ten years. There is no mechanism by which they'll suddenly jump to $3,000.
Even for degrees which you wouldn't expect great things from -- like, say, English -- the value of the degree exceeds the price by huge amounts. The NPV of a bachelor's degree in English is about a million bucks. You still come out ahead with virtually any college/loan combination possible, as long as you find a job with it, and unemployment among college graduates is still at ~4.5%.
There are a few degrees which are exceptionally bad decisions, but they are the exceptions rather than the rule. One example is culinary school, particularly the ones which will load you with the federal max of loans so that you can get a $12 an hour job as a line cook. There is one glaring sore thumb in the data for master's degrees, too.
If folks are interested, I'll blog about this in a few weeks. I did a project for a client looking at government data and a few other sources to try to get numbers on the worth of degrees by majors. The work is 99% over but, clients being clients, there are some more steps it has to go through before they want to launch it publicly.