Israel has enormous influence over the whole of congress.
http://original.antiwar.com/smith-grant/2017/07/17/aipac-sti...
Mearsheimer and Walt is still the big book on the subject:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Israel_Lobby_and_U.S._Fore...
The US give Israel billions of dollars in foreign aid every year. Allows them to disgregard UN resolutions and prevents the recognition of Palestine.
Israel has nuclear weapons and is outside the Non proliferation treaty and yet the US goes crazy about other countries that try to get weapons.
Meanwhile AIPAC isn't even registered as something foreign.
This can be happily discussed online and in every non US country it amazes people how a tiny country like Israel can get the US to support them no matter what they do.
Now even Jerusalem is recognized as the capital of Israel, by one country in the whole world.
Jews may be small in number but I would bet dollars to Latka’s that they vote.
If Tech issues brought people out to vote like guns or Israel I bet we would have more engineers in Congress.
At the time the US insisted on carrying out inspections of the Negev facility to ensure that weapons were not being developed. In the event they eventually stopped as they felt that their inspections were not particularly effective.
I hope it's seen as no less controversial today!
Do you expect a Josh Rogin to write a critical article on israel? Do you really expect washington post to publish negative articles on israel?
The editor of washingtonpost is martin baron, a child of israeli immigrants to the US.
The guy who wrote the op-ed and the editor both have ties to israel. What are the chances of a negative article regarding israel?
Uh, the Israeli news media is even more dominated by Jewish owners, investors, editors, and journalists (and caters to a more Jewish audience), and they have no problem ciriticizing the Israeli government from all imaginable sides.
On the opposite, the fact that criticism towards Israeli policies is much more pronounced and direct inside Israeli media than it is in the media of a completely independent country, is a clear sign that the debate is artificially stifled.
But not support for the claims that the reason is Jewish actors in media rather than, say, a combination of a broad consensus on US geopolitical interests and widespread and deep bias against Arabs and Muslims in the US.
While criticism of Israel is muted in the US press, it isn't inversely correlated, AFAICT, with outlets that have Jewish investors, Jewish editors, or even with the particular piece being written by a Jewish journalist/columnist.
No, Israel has enormous support by Americans so it gets a lot of support by Congress. No surprises there, that is how a democracy should function.
> The US give Israel billions of dollars in foreign aid every year.
Because they are a democratic ally with a stable government in a highly volatile region. Of course, there can be legitimate debate if that level of funding is a good idea, but it is entirely within reason. Additionally, much of the funding was in exchange for repeated concessions from Israel in peace talks which were always rebuffed and rejected by Palestinian leadership.
> Allows them to disgregard UN resolutions and prevents the recognition of Palestine.
...by which they are uniquely singled out and targeted by countries with tremendous human rights violations such as Syria, Iran, etc.
> Israel has nuclear weapons and is outside the Non proliferation treaty and yet the US goes crazy about other countries that try to get weapons.
Because Israel is a stable democracy under existential threat by it's neighbors, as opposed to, say, Iran or North Korea which are destabilizers.
> Meanwhile AIPAC isn't even registered as something foreign.
Because it isn't. AIPAC is made up of and supported by American citizens. And this is where these arguments begin to take an undertone of antisemitism. The assumption that AIPAC is a foreign organization implies that it's members (primarily Jews) are foreign by virtue of being Jewish.
> Now even Jerusalem is recognized as the capital of Israel, by one country in the whole world.
Because it is their capital. America recognizes Seoul as capital of South Korea and Pyongyang as capital of North Korea, does it not?
I can't stop but wondering if there is a startup opportunity here. What if it was possible to create a market to buy and sell politicians which was more efficient? May be we can dress it up little better... How about buy and sell "political cause"? Unlimited money allowed for each auctioning! Each political cause can then have underlying actual politician that gets part of the proceeds via campaign donations but all parties get to remain anonymous. No need to debate gun laws. Who ever is able to beat auction gets their say.
To me it looks like US Congress is dirt cheap. [...] No
need to debate gun laws. Who ever is able to beat auction
gets their say.
The cost of a bribe depends on multiple factors - but one of the most key ones is how important an issue is in terms of publicity and re-election chances.A senator won't take a bribe that lets them buy campaign ads that get them 3000 votes if it requires them to take a position that loses them 4000 votes.
So it's cheap to bribe a politician to support some trivial matter that won't make the news, like not auditing the use of subsidised water for agriculture; but expensive to bribe a politician on matters voters will find out about and care about, like abortion and gun control.
This is part of what gives groups like the NRA their power; by keeping their members informed, they convert trivial, cheap-to-bribe issues into important, expensive-to-bribe issues.
This is just flat out wrong. There was a rumor going around that a donation got Algeria taken off of a list of state sponsors of terror.
The problem is that it was never on that list in the first place.
Unless you meant something else, just more garbage.
Could you dig that up so we can see it?
The Politifact article states that it's false that Algeria was removed from the "terror watch list". That's not what the grandparent poster actually claimed - the GP is talking about human rights violations.
It IS true (the same politifact article even mentions this) that Algeria paid $500,000 to the Clinton Foundation and immediately got a lot more state department access to lobby on their human rights record.
A foreign country should not be allowed so much access. This kind of reminds me how in one of the Wikileak emails, Clinton removed a country from a list of human rights violators for a mere donation. China is far far worse than a small country and this is peanuts in the grand scheme of things. I sincerely don't understand why no one can publically reprimand China for turning into a dystopian dictatorship before our eyes. Xi orders complete video and cellphone surveillance, black bagging without trial, abolishes term limits, makes disappear any rival billionaire or elite, and no one says a darn thing. Instead, Tim Cook, Mark Zuckerburg are in the front row clapping. Literally. Xi announces all this and they congratulate him and clap in the front row.
We take a lot of tech freedoms for granted.