News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Mirai Botnet Was Part of a College Student Minecraft ... by tptacek on Thursday December 14, 2017 @07:35AM (#15921769)
I don't want to throw more shade at Schneier than needs to be thrown, but I want to point out that you've pointed out basically two† real credentials:

* He has a masters degree.

* He wrote a bunch of popular books, and reaped a lot of fame from them.

I work, part-time, in the cryptography space his best-known books cover. His most popular book, Applied Cryptography, is not well regarded in the field. Opinions differ on Cryptography Engineering --- I like it a lot --- but he's a coauthor on that book, alongside a practicing cryptographer of significant renown. The rest of those books are non-technical.

I've worked in security since the mid-1990s, and Schneier has been a presence in the industry that whole time. And his Mirai attribution is far from the dumbest thing he's had to say.

I want to be careful because I'm sure Schneier is very good at what he's good at. My concern is that in addition to that --- without intending to be --- he's also insidiously "famous for being famous", and that his takes on things like DDoS attribution are thus taken more seriously than they should be. There are HN commenters that I think have more reliable takes on what's happening in the computer underground than Schneier.

He should write HN comments rather than pieces that get syndicated into magazines. He'd be an excellent HN commenter. :)

† (You might add that he's a co-author of some well-known cipher and hash designs, and IIRC the sole author of Blowfish, his best-known design. [Don't use Blowfish.])

Re:The Mirai Botnet Was Part of a College Student Minecraft ... by Tomte on Thursday December 14, 2017 @09:21AM (#15922393)
Schneier decided to leave the academic/technical side and become a pundit.

That‘s nothing to be ashamed of, I‘m sure he didn‘t just do it for the fame, but because he wanted to make things better. I still think he‘s a better cryptographer than writer, but he really seems to enjoy writing.

But it feels uncomfortable when people misunderstand his role.

(And he lost some of my good-will and admiration when he ridiculed Randall Munroe‘s comic and didn‘t have it in him to post a correction for what was basically him not reading the comic, but projecting something he already had in mind. That happens to everyone, it‘s a bit embarassing and not really bad, but sticking to it when he knows full well that the masses trust him is inexcusable.)

Re:The Mirai Botnet Was Part of a College Student Minecraft ... by sasas on Thursday December 14, 2017 @08:22AM (#15922033)
Thanks for the perspective. How would you classify him if ranked against the other usual high profile “security personalities?”. Often an individuals ability for self promotion can place a shadow over their true ability making it difficult to discern their true qualities when not a subject matter expert on the topic at hand.

On the book front, would be keen to gain your perspective on the following crypto book that was recently published -

https://www.nostarch.com/seriouscrypto

Re:The Mirai Botnet Was Part of a College Student Minecraft ... by tptacek on Thursday December 14, 2017 @08:44AM (#15922159)
Serious Crypto is strong, and JP Aumasson is the real deal. I might still want both Cryptography Engineering and Serious Crypto; Serious Crypto is far more detailed and up-to-date, but Cryptography Engineering has valuable perspective on a lot of nuts-and-bolts stuff.
Re:The Mirai Botnet Was Part of a College Student Minecraft ... by sasas on Thursday December 14, 2017 @08:51AM (#15922208)
Great! That’s all I need to hear - will place an order.
Re:The Mirai Botnet Was Part of a College Student Minecraft ... by armitron on Thursday December 14, 2017 @08:44AM (#15922158)
"There are HN commenters that I think have more reliable takes on what's happening in the computer underground than Schneier."

Can you name them?

Re:The Mirai Botnet Was Part of a College Student Minecraft ... by drivingmenuts on Thursday December 14, 2017 @09:48AM (#15922610)
> He should write HN comments rather than pieces that get syndicated into magazines.

Sure, but he wouldn’t get paid very well for that.