News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google offices raided by Korean police by jacquesm on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @09:43AM (#1591401)
Google is facing the same accusations in Germany (they've been cleared in the UK) and in other countries, I think the raid may have to do with them stonewalling investigators like they did in Germany. After all, the Korean police can read the news just fine and they must have tried to get a feeling for how google would respond if they asked.

The not-so-smart element here is that I presume google learned a lot from their previous encounters with the law in Italy, France, the UK and Germany and would not have left any relevant data lying around their offices for investigators to find.

What bothers me about googles' behaviour in all this is that they behave as though they're above the law in terms of privacy and on top of that they had no business collecting this information in the first place.

Saying you're going to photograph the streets but actually adding a wardriving module to your data collection vehicles is not something that you can claim you did 'accidentally'.

http://rawstory.com/rs/2010/0515/google-streetview-vans-acci...

I find that extremely hard to believe and I think google has some public explaining to do about how such a thing could ever happen 'by accident'.

Re:Google offices raided by Korean police by yellowbkpk on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @09:49AM (#1591416)
If I were spending millions of dollars sending cars + drivers out on every street in the world I would want to collect as much data as possible. I imagine they had cell radios, wifi radios, probably even FM and AM radios all collecting data in conjunction with highly-accurate GPS readings.

If their software to collect WiFi signal strength was based on a packet capture system (perhaps by interfacing with Wireshark or one of its libraries), I could see how it might be a mistake to save this data while attempting to collect other data.

However, I imagine that they simply wanted to collect as much data as possible, including WiFi traffic (that should really be considered public, anyway...).

Re:Google offices raided by Korean police by weego on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @09:55AM (#1591437)
If I were going on holiday or on business to a city, it would be incredibly useful if I could see a public/free wifi overlay (showing the radius of a decent strength signal) on top of the city map. The only way to do that of course would be to scan and record all available wifi networks at every step and then group the signals based on the ssid. That will obviously hit all networks, but if it cant access anything what is the problem?

If the ssid is visible and your network is available then everyone with a wifi card is doing what Google did every time they turn their laptop or smartphone on anyway.

Re:Google offices raided by Korean police by jcl on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @10:34AM (#1591551)
It's one thing to record the signatures of open wireless networks in a given location. But, from what I hear, Google was also recording the payloads of the packets it intercepted. I can understand people being upset by this, especially if carried out on a large scale.
Re:Google offices raided by Korean police by natrius on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @10:36AM (#1591559)
> If the ssid is visible and your network is available then everyone with a wifi card is doing what Google did every time they turn their laptop or smartphone on anyway.

That's not true. Unless the card is in promiscuous mode, packets intended for other machines will be discarded. Even if other cards were in promiscuous mode, they'd still have to intentionally save the packets to approach what Google did.

Re:Google offices raided by Korean police by jacquesm on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @10:35AM (#1591553)
Privacy laws are applicable to companies storing data, not on individuals that incidentally use someone's open network.

Also, they weren't just scanning for availability and signal strength, they were snooping the traffic and saving it.

Re:Google offices raided by Korean police by nanairo on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @11:43AM (#1591849)
Hey, nobody is arguing they shouldn't try to save some dollars... just that if they were going to gather more data than originally planned, they could have told us.

Moreover, if it was just economic sense, and hence it was done on purpose, then it would have been nice if they hadn't lied when prosecutors asked them.

I don't think it's that much to ask.

Re:Google offices raided by Korean police by barrkel on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @09:54AM (#1591432)
The way I understood the controversy they were trying to build a DB to help geolocation by mapping SSIDs / MAC addresses to GPS coordinates. Depending on how that's implemented, I can see it logging more or less data (perhaps depending on diagnostics flags) as it trundles by.

Frankly, I'm not in the least bit concerned by the allegations by Google here.

Re:Google offices raided by Korean police by whatusername on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @10:13AM (#1591488)
nope. They were logging network traffic on every unprotected wifi signal.. Sure they would only have fragments -- but it was a screwup on googles behalf.
Re:Google offices raided by Korean police by barrkel on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @11:34AM (#1591807)
Well if you're looking for MACs, wouldn't you need to listen in on network traffic? And then it comes down to whether that listened traffic was recorded or not, which is exactly what I'd expect to see from a diagnostic switch.
Re:Google offices raided by Korean police by ThomPete on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @10:04AM (#1591465)
I don't know why you are being downvoted so I upped you.

Off-Topic

There is a bad tendency that people just downvote when they hear something they don't like or disagree with. I hope this will pass, this is not reddit!