They do have over 3 million people. Many of whom are bilingual and reasonably well educated. It also has ports critical for international trade. Please don't dismiss an entire country so flippantly.
But apparently Tourism only accounts for $1.8B/year of PR's ~$100B economy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Puerto_Rico
Part of 2.5 Billion given out by just one department (Agriculture) specifically designed to modernize electrical systems for “poor white folk” in middle America.
Turns out those people are over represented in Congress who doles out such things whereas PR gets no representation...
If we did “poor white” rural citizens/states would be in big trouble as they currently get more money than they should from a purely proportional measure.
I'm perfectly willing to see my tax dollars go to the Puerto Rican grid as soon as they start paying taxes.
But they are US Citizens still. And the federal government subsidizes plenty of infrastructure into areas that pay relatively little federal tax, because we as a country care about fellow citizens’ well-being.
Great, then they should get no money from the rest of us.
>But they are US Citizens still.
So what? Puerto Rico isn't a state.
But unless we’re going to give them independence, we still have an obligation to protect and, to some extent, provide for them.
Let them pay their own way.
They also are a net drain on the treasury. They get more federal dollars out than they put in.
Let them pay their own way.
There is definitely something to be said about economic prosperity in a lot of places, but abandoning 3.41 million US citizens after a hurricane hits doesn't seem very American.
They're U.S. citizens and have constitutional rights, so the economic value of their existence doesn't matter.
(It's shocking to see first-hand entire regions in various states of collapse; furthermore becoming normalized in pop culture.)
> They're U.S. citizens and have constitutional rights,
What are you talking about other than providing electrical service to PR?
That's why you need to read the full sentence instead of taking out of context:
>They're U.S. citizens and have constitutional rights, so the economic value of their existence doesn't matter.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15646876
https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=googlryas
In one thread you inadvertently out yourself, saying "despite having an account for more than 8 years", while posting on an account that is 18 months old, that is replying to a comment your parent account made.
In others, you quote your other account as a disinterested third party: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15554173
And there's a near 1:1 correlation between articles and comment threads where you and googlryas can be found (most often, but certainly not exclusively, on the topic of Trump / Republican / conservative politics, including how both accounts regularly refer to 'T_D', aka /r/the_donald).
Not particularly upfront or fair behavior?
I appreciate the e-stalk, but that is really regardless of the point. What does this have to do with constitutional rights and a modern electrical grid?
Good question. In point of fact, the reading of your comment history (or e-stalking) was to see if there were examples of you using services most consider the government obligated to provide or support, without a specific Constitutional right explicitly naming them.
> Keep reading the history - I openly admit that I am the same account.
I don't think that's particularly ingenuous, though. "Keep reading my history and after several pages you may find an admission that they're both my accounts... if you're paying attention... if you even notice something odd in the first place..." when you're actively treating the two accounts as individuals 99% of the time (otherwise, why say "hey, user googlrys said something like that before", rather than "I said something like that before on my other account googlrys"?) and interacting between them in a manner that with very few exceptions doesn't say "we are one".
Constitutional rights are things the government can't do, not services they must provide. And yes, I do think government has a large role in our life, but it isn't because they are servicing our constitutional rights.