News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Exploring ZFS ZIL with Intel Optane and NAND by wtallis on Monday December 11, 2017 @06:32PM (#15901770)
Yeah, DRAM chips are the only ones that currently offer the right balance of performance and capacity per die. NAND and 3D XPoint dies are too big and too slow per die for this use case, so they're better used as nonvolatile storage to flush the log to in the event of power failure, not as the primary log storage media.

I expect it will soon become common for high-end enterprise NVMe SSDs to include a few GB of DRAM accessible through the new Persistent Memory Region feature, so that they can be accessed through simple PCIe memory read and write operations, but will automatically be preserved by the SSD in the event of a power failure. It won't be as fast as a NVDIMM, but works with existing form factors and platforms.

Re:Exploring ZFS ZIL with Intel Optane and NAND by StudentStuff on Monday December 11, 2017 @08:10PM (#15902281)
Battery backed DRAM is likely a better choice for performance & endurance in most applications, as the Optane product line is a lame duck with memory that dies around the 1TB of writes mark, leaving you with lost data and a dead SSD.
Re:Exploring ZFS ZIL with Intel Optane and NAND by wtallis on Monday December 11, 2017 @09:28PM (#15902592)
> as the Optane product line is a lame duck with memory that dies around the 1TB of writes mark, leaving you with lost data and a dead SSD.

You seem to be much more concerned with venting anger than conveying accurate or relevant information.

Re:Exploring ZFS ZIL with Intel Optane and NAND by Dylan16807 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @06:22AM (#15904699)
Considering that the Intel drive in https://techreport.com/review/26523/the-ssd-endurance-experi... self-destructed when it ran out of guaranteed lifetime, I think it's a fair criticism.
Re:Exploring ZFS ZIL with Intel Optane and NAND by wtallis on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @09:08PM (#15911442)
There's nothing fair about making up a number that's wrong by multiple orders of magnitude.

I'm not a fan of the end of life behavior of Intel SSDs either, but it's a consistent policy that does work well for enterprise usage scenarios, with no unexpected data loss. They probably shouldn't be applying the same policy to the consumer products. But the fact that there are valid criticisms to be made doesn't mean this particular one was fair or germane.

Re:Exploring ZFS ZIL with Intel Optane and NAND by Dylan16807 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:15PM (#15911977)
Oh, I wasn't even looking at the value of the number. Yeah, it's bad to exaggerate like that without being clear about it. But something performance-heavy can burn out an endurance of 10 drive writes per day pretty fast.