News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by 1053r on Sunday August 08, 2010 @07:43PM (#1586511)
Let us assume, for a moment, that Ray Kurzweil's thesis of accelerating returns is correct. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerating_change#Kurzweil_an...

It therefore follows that as the pace of change increases, the length of time before an education becomes out of date or stale decreases. There is some percentage of the population today who would rather be poor than retrain. It stands to reason that as the rate of change increases, that percentage of the population will also increase.

Therefore, we as a society have two choices. 1) Let people be poor. 2) Pay for them to live like human beings not because they deserve it, but because they are alive. This is the crux of the choice. Will the haves (people with relevant education, who are disproportionately represented here of HN) give some of what they have to the have-nots just because they are human?

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by petercooper on Sunday August 08, 2010 @08:32PM (#1586601)
I've seen economists mulling over your second point a little lately - it's not a new concept though, it's called "basic income": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income

A fictional basic income exists in Star Trek TNG in relation to Federation credits. This is achievable because the Star Trek TNG universe is post-scarcity but credits are used to ration non-replicable goods.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by Ras_ on Monday August 09, 2010 @06:42AM (#1587563)
Basic income aka perustulo is popular topic in current Finnish politics. I believe the Green League (which is unusually large party here - nearly 10% share) adopted it first.

Recent polls indicate that the idea of Basic income could be favored by 30% of Finns.

More about the lengthy Finnish debate on Basic income: http://translate.google.com/translate?js=y&prev=_t&h...

marvin commented about Norway's "uførepensjon". Finland has it too. If you aren't able to get work for years and are deemed unemployable, you can get "unemployment pension" much in the same way as sick pension.

But basic income is another thing. Everyone - including the employed - would get a lump sum of basic income. On top of that they could earn extra by working (taxable income) or just live off with the basic income. It is seen as a way to drastically simplify the welfare system, where some money is simply lost to bureaucracy. The caveat is the possibility that too many could choose not to earn extra money by working.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by marvin on Monday August 09, 2010 @02:35AM (#1587195)
This is a pretty interesting idea. I actually saw it discussed in the Norwegian popular financial magazine Your Money (Dine Penger) last year. In this instance, the relevant point was that Norway already has a sort of de facto basic income system. It's called "uførepensjon" (a rough translation would be "pension for those unfit to work"). It consists of approximately 23,000 pre-tax US dollars per year, and it's where you end up if you are sick, disabled or otherwise unable to acquire a decent job over a period of a few years; basically if you have received unemployment benefits for years and all attempts by the bureucratic system to get you back into the workforce have failed.

Approximately 7% of all Norwegians currently receive these payments. The author of the article in question suggested a system of gradual negative taxation for very low wages, so if you earn less than 23000 USD per year at your current job, the missing part will be paid to you by the government. The line of reasoning is that most people will not be happy without more money than this, and hence will work normally.

I'm not sure if even Norway is rich enough to support a system like this on a full scale, and taxation in the US is _definitely_ not harsh enough to do it, even with the amount adjusted to GDP per capita. But it would be nice if we someday ended up rich enough that extreme poverty could be eliminated in this way. None of the people covered by this system have to starve, and all health payments are also handled through the official system.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by bugsy on Monday August 09, 2010 @06:53AM (#1587582)
"taxation in the US is _definitely_ not harsh enough"

It seems to me that the US spends 46.5% of all money spend world wide collectively by all nations on military spending. China, France, UK, Russia, and then next 10 biggest spending countries spend less than the US when they are all added together.

In addition the US imprisons more of its population than any other country in the world, including totalitarian police states, and a much greater proportion than any modern western nation.

In addition, the US spends a fortune on education and gets very poor outcomes.

In addition, the US spends far more per capita on health care than any other country in the world and has far worse outcomes than most countries, with infant mortality now falling behind many third world nations, and the interesting reality that the life expectancy of an indigenous Lakota indian man living in South Dakota receiving free unlimited federal health care is now 44 years. This is lower than 187 out of 195 of the nations in the world and is only higher than nations which are afflicted with BOTH massive civil war AND endemic AIDS, Malaria and Cholera.

Surely there is a way to pay for a basic living standard for the unskilled without raising taxes.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by Tamerlin on Monday August 09, 2010 @05:53PM (#1589555)
"It seems to me that the US spends 46.5% of all money spend world wide collectively by all nations on military spending."

Which is probably the real reason that we're in such debt -- it should be blindingly obvious to the entire world that there's no longer any valid reason to dump such an astronomically large amount of money into armed forces that we clearly don't need. Unfortunately, the magnitude of that spending is probably related to the fact that a sizable chunk of it winds up in congressional (etc) pockets, and has nothing to do with the actual military itself.

"In addition, the US spends a fortune on education and gets very poor outcomes."

Which agrees with the author's assertion that high school graduates are less skilled now than their predecessors, a trend that I've been seeing as well.

"In addition, the US spends far more per capita on health care than any other country in the world and has far worse outcomes than most countries,"

This is probably a combination of excessive organizational bloat and decreasing quality of the medical staff themselves. (The stories a close friend of mine told me about his medical school compatriots were nauseating... these people obviously didn't understand a single bit of the chemistry that they studied in college, and it became blindingly obvious that neither did most of the biochemistry professors at Johns Hopkins of all places.)

We're heading into a downward spiral, since these are the people who will be taking over and running the show as well as "mentoring" the next generation of educational victims.

It's a breakable spiral, but it won't happen unless a lot of people get a clue and recognize what's happening. Sadly most of them have been culturally conditioned to be automata, and avoid thinking for themselves, which is going to make this tailspin hard to break out of.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by yummyfajitas on Monday August 09, 2010 @09:09AM (#1587817)
...the life expectancy of an indigenous Lakota indian man living in South Dakota receiving free unlimited federal health care is now 44 years.

Maybe the conclusion we should draw is that medical spending and health outcomes are mostly uncorrelated to each other.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by dmm on Monday August 09, 2010 @08:05AM (#1587708)
> But it would be nice if we someday ended up rich enough that extreme poverty could be eliminated in this way

Looking at the history of welfare in the US I think it's safe to say that giving people money is a pretty poor way to eliminate poverty.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by jsz0 on Sunday August 08, 2010 @08:45PM (#1586624)
President Nixon mulled over the idea of a guaranteed minimum income for Americans which, IIRC, mutated into the earned income tax credit program. Of course these days no mainstream progressive or liberal would support the idea. Things have changed a lot.
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by _delirium on Sunday August 08, 2010 @09:22PM (#1586684)
It used to actually be a quite popular position among libertarian-ish economists, strangely enough: Friedrich von Hayek and Milton Friedman were both in favor of a guaranteed minimum income.
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by orangecat on Monday August 09, 2010 @01:01AM (#1587056)
Also see "the Plan", recently proposed by Charles Murray. The welfare state is entirely done away with; in its place every adult gets $10k/year for life.

http://www.radicalmiddle.com/x_murray.htm

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by scotty79 on Monday August 09, 2010 @01:13PM (#1588598)
It might be extremely healthy for economy. Market works because consumers make thoughtful decisions. Poor people have to put much thought in their purchases. Increasing money available to poor people without making them feel rich increases market ability to prefer more efficient producers and service providers.

Of course curbing commercials a bit to allow people to make less brainwashed decisions also would be good for market.

You also need safeguards in place so companies in search of greater efficiency won't release harmful products.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by dublinclontarf on Sunday August 08, 2010 @10:24PM (#1586806)
Really, sounds awfully like something they would be dead set against. Certainly if it was guaranteed by the government. Got any sources for that?
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by _delirium on Sunday August 08, 2010 @10:32PM (#1586826)
The three main reasons they gave were: 1) a functioning free market with rational agents voluntarily exchanging goods and services requires non-desperate individuals who can realistically say "no" to proposed economic exchanges; 2) a guaranteed minimum income would make people more autonomous market participants, as they would feel more free to be entrepreneurs, and to break from more cliquish kinds of safety nets like churches and ethnic groups; and 3) pragmatically, direct cash transfers are the least distorting kind of anti-poverty program, so a minimum income will greatly reduce political pressure for more distorting measures, like restrictions on when you can fire employees.

Here's one place Hayek discusses it, starting at the bottom of p. 54 and continuing through the middle of p. 56: http://books.google.com/books?id=0HzIUyFkwlYC&pg=PA54

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by tomjen3 on Monday August 09, 2010 @06:21AM (#1587529)
In Milton Friedmans capitalism and freedom, he discuss (among other things) that proposal - he admits not liking it too much, but it is better than the current system of welfare and it is more realistic to create that than to kill the welfare system.

In addition you save the expenditure associated with paying for the enforcement, social workers, etc.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by yummyfajitas on Monday August 09, 2010 @09:03AM (#1587808)
We could probably accomplish it as well, though I'd favor providing goods and services rather than money.

It would not cost a lot to provide millions of people with nutritious food, beds in a dormitory built in cheap locations and 1970-era health care.

We do live in a world where scarcity no longer applies to many goods. We just don't realize it because we compare ourselves to our neighbors rather than our ancestors.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by gaius on Monday August 09, 2010 @04:43AM (#1587385)
Hmm the thing is, the Star Trek universe isn't post-scarcity in any meaningful way. Sure, if you are living on a starship you can replicate anything and spend all your free time on the holiday deck. But the Federation (and all the competing civilizations) have very finite capacity to build and crew starships.
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by yummyfajitas on Monday August 09, 2010 @09:11AM (#1587820)
They can't build holodecks and replicators on the ground?
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by gaius on Monday August 09, 2010 @09:51AM (#1587950)
James T Kirk grew up on a farm in Iowa - what was he farming?
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by yummyfajitas on Monday August 09, 2010 @02:05PM (#1588779)
Kirk grew up in an era with neither holodecks nor replicators, on starships or anywhere else.
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by petercooper on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @10:56PM (#1593668)
People might do it for fun as they do now. No-one needs to farm anymore because you can just buy your food at the grocery store cheaper than it could be grown.
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by _delirium on Sunday August 08, 2010 @08:22PM (#1586587)
> Will the haves (people with relevant education, who are disproportionately represented here of HN) give some of what they have to the have-nots just because they are human?

Depending on what the ratios of the two are, they might not have any choice. If it gets more towards the extreme of 10% of people having lots of money while 90% starve, then those 10% had better get used to living in fortified enclaves, 18th-century-France style.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by petercooper on Sunday August 08, 2010 @08:39PM (#1586610)
A difference between 18th century France and a medium-term future may be that peasants were essential members of the workforce in the 18th century, whereas the "have nots" may, for the first time, be entirely unnecessary to the ruling classes in order to maintain their quality of life.

If that situation came about, I doubt they'd need fortified enclaves unless they truly preferred that set up. They could merely wipe out the have-nots and be done with it. Or, if we're going to the distant future and the "haves" are more moral, they could just leave Earth and live elsewhere leaving the "have nots" to fight over dirt.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by _delirium on Sunday August 08, 2010 @08:58PM (#1586641)
Part of my point is that I don't think the rich could win such a struggle of forces if they're a small minority: it would be more likely that the poor wipe them out, or at least confiscate their wealth, than vice versa. The rich currently survive easily basically because the vast majority of Americans support a rule of law that lets them retain their prerogatives; they are not capable of defending their own prerogatives, at least as things are currently set up. If it were angry masses versus rich people hiring private security contractors, I think angry masses win. A big wild card would be which side the government is on. If the government is run by populists interested in redistributing wealth, do you really think a small minority of wealthy could resist the police?
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by DenisM on Sunday August 08, 2010 @10:32PM (#1586824)
Well, corrupt third-world countries do live like that and it rarely comes to full-blown riots, usually only when there is little to eat. There doesn't need to be an open confrontation.

But you're right in that the poor are still part of the workforce, hence they do wield power, even if poorly organized. This might be not for long.

There is an interesting case of Russia which is populated by 142 million people, while the ruling elites only have a need for maybe 10% of that number to maintain their natural gas and oil revenue (plus the nukes to defend the same). It might be worth paying attention to as a model of what's to come.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by rsheridan6 on Sunday August 08, 2010 @11:01PM (#1586884)
An analogy with 18th century France does not call attention to the fact that the tiny minority of French who were aristocrats had survived the 17th, 16th, 15th, 14th, 13th, 12th, etc centuries just fine, putting down rebellions as needed. Like this one: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacquerie

The rich would have a much bigger advantage now because they could afford high-tech weapons. More so in the future. It's just a matter of how far they're willing to go.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by Unseelie on Sunday August 08, 2010 @11:44PM (#1586936)
At the same time, the saying 'the more you know, the less you need' applies to the poor as well as the rich. those who can afford, for instance, a network connection, can easily find out how to build such things as mustard gas, thermite bombs, etc. The capability of one person to do damage has increased a great deal since the industrial revolution, and a great deal more since the explosion of such things as libraries and later the internet.

My example? Iraq.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by rsheridan6 on Monday August 09, 2010 @12:05AM (#1586971)
The rich can use thermite bombs and mustard gas too.

Iraq could be an example either way. Saddam Hussein had an inferior military to the US, but he could rule the country because he had no compunctions about doing things like gassing villages for opposing him. He was from the Sunni minority, disliked by the Shiite majority, but he had no problem putting down rebellions even after getting badly beaten by the US in '91.

So, as a rebel, your chances depend on the kind of leader you're fighting. If it's a Bush or a Louis XVII, you're in business. If it's a Saddam or someone like the men who put down the Jacquerie, not so much. In the limiting case, the powerful could simply round everybody they didn't like up and exterminate them, Nazi-style, if they chose to do so.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by lsc on Monday August 09, 2010 @04:52AM (#1587397)
and what kind of leader do you think Warren "I don't pay enough in taxes" Buffet would be? And certainly, if you needed to keep the college-educated bleeding-heart middle classes and upper middle classes on your side, you would be forced to use tactics even less effective than what the us military currently uses in the middle east, which from here look pretty ineffective.

Hell, look at Gates; a guy who could almost be called bloodthirsty as a businessman, ends up donating some huge portion of his fortune to some feel-good charity.

I just don't think those guys have what it takes to be a Saddam. Even if they did; being ruthless and having a matériel and technology advantage is not always enough. Look at how Afghanistan kicked the crap out of the USSR. This wasn't 'cause the USSR was afraid to wipe out villages with it's vastly superior armament... this was because with currently available weapons, it's damn hard to occupy a country that doesn't want to be occupied.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by barry-cotter on Monday August 09, 2010 @11:23AM (#1588239)
Re: Afghanistan v. the Soviets The British could do it. I see no reason to believe the Afghans would be able to put more than a dent in total air superiority so they could have won the same way.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pink%27s_War

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by lsc on Monday August 09, 2010 @08:39PM (#1590042)
If the russians could have won through total air superiority, they would have. because they had it, and it didn't make the difference.

I imagine that flight was a greater advantage when it was new, before the insurgents figured out how to effectively counter it (which is to say, to hide amongst civilians friendly to the enemy or to stay underground)

but yeah, I think, at this point, advances in asymmetrical warfare techniques have largely neutralized the advantages of air superiority.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by rsheridan6 on Monday August 09, 2010 @08:52AM (#1587790)
Certainly our current leaders are not the type to mass murder unemployed Americans. But these things can change. Nobody in the 1920s thought that the Germans would soon be trying to exterminate unwanted ethnic groups and colonize Eastern Europe like whites colonized North America (nobody except Hitler, who had already planned it).
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by megablast on Sunday August 08, 2010 @09:37PM (#1586711)
Better start building ARC 2, for all the telephone sanitizers.
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by lionhearted on Monday August 09, 2010 @03:40AM (#1587287)
> Therefore, we as a society have two choices. 1) Let people be poor. 2) Pay for them to live like human beings

This is what's known as a false dichotomy.

A similar false dichotomy would read, "Therefore, we as a society have two choices. 1) Let criminals rule the world and have no laws. 2) Execute everyone who commits any crime."

There's other ways.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by roel_v on Monday August 09, 2010 @06:48AM (#1587576)
The premise of the choices, which you conveniently left out, was that a significant percentage of people would be unable to provide a sizable income for themselves, because they lack the intellectual capacities. From that the binary answer is quite reasonable; the inbetween would be that people would be able to make themselves non-poor, and we started out by saying that that would not be feasible.

Unless you have another middle of the road, which I would be interested to hear about. When claiming a false dichotomy the customary thing to do is to provide a(n) example(s) of other options, however short.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by tomjen3 on Sunday August 08, 2010 @07:54PM (#1586530)
>Pay for them to live like human beings

How much exactly is that? I would like to know before I commit myself either way.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by maqr on Sunday August 08, 2010 @08:24PM (#1586593)
But since we're talking about Kurzweil... let's define "human" first.
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by dpatru on Sunday August 08, 2010 @09:45PM (#1586727)
> Will the haves (people with relevant education, who are disproportionately represented here of HN) give some of what they have to the have-nots just because they are human?

Do the haves have a choice to "give"? The reality is that in a democratic society with an income tax, if the have-nots outnumber the haves, the haves will be forced to support the have-nots.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by tomjen3 on Monday August 09, 2010 @06:26AM (#1587542)
Sig, we live in a Republic, not a democracy. Things like that are the reason we do so.
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by kiba on Sunday August 08, 2010 @08:20PM (#1586579)
By the time the technological singularity approach, the human beings who are living might as well be kings to us.

So it become less urgent for the have to give to the have-not.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by TheEzEzz on Sunday August 08, 2010 @08:57PM (#1586640)
The have-nots of today might as well be kings to those living 1000 years ago. Still, having a strong middle class is good for everyone, regardless of moral imperatives to help others.
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by rsheridan6 on Sunday August 08, 2010 @10:58PM (#1586877)
Why is that? Even if there was enough wealth around to make everyone a king by today's standards, if someone had no marketable skills or capital, why would anyone give anything to him? It would be up to the haves whether they wanted to play Mr Nice Guy or not, and I don't think the choice is obvious.
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by Unseelie on Sunday August 08, 2010 @11:48PM (#1586940)
Everyone in the middle class is a king by the standards of the 1950s. I have, as a starving student, more wealth than any emperor of Rome. The assumption that we're not already upstream in the singularity is just bias of perspective
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by rsheridan6 on Monday August 09, 2010 @09:01AM (#1587803)
Presumably you have a job, or you have parents with a job that are supporting you, or you live on student loans given to you by people who expect that you will get a job and pay you back with interest. If there's a hypothetical machine that can do your job, then you won't get one, and there's no reason other than charity for anyone to give you money.

Until now, if a machine took a job, that just meant that another worker was available for another job that a machine couldn't do. Machines are pretty dumb, so that's not hard to find. A kid with Down's syndrome can sweep the floor at Taco Bell, but a machine can't. That changes with the singularity.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by fmora on Sunday August 08, 2010 @09:58PM (#1586760)
All humans have on average the same intelligence. Why do you assume that there will be a few who will be able to keep up with the pace of retraining oneself. In many poor countries the reason they stay poor has to do with cultural differences rather than IQ differences. i.e. If you teach your kids from a very young age to have good work ethics and good study ethics and teach that anything is possible as long as they work hard then they will grow up to be achievers. If you do not teach your kids this then chances are that they will be poor. Besides, if we ever do achieve the singularity and assuming that we do not destroy ourselves many things that are really expensive now will become extremely cheap in such a way that even the poorest person will still live like a rich person. Singularity will enable us to find solutions to energy much faster than if we tried to do it on our own. It will probably find a way to extract all the energy we need from the sun's rays. Once this happens energy will be as cheap as the oxygen you breath. We'll also have self replicating machines meaning that anything anybody has you will be able to build it in your own home. In fact, poverty may be eliminated all together. Who knows what will become valuable in the new economy. Really, I don't think we can even begin to imagine it. We will probably work to better ourselves and humanity. Yes, we will work maybe even more than before even if we have all the material wealth we can have. Why? Well, because most human beings become depressed if they are not doing anything. We will do what we truly feel passionate about rather than work in a crappy job just to pay the bills because there will be little to no bills to pay. The future is truly Star Trek.
Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by gwern on Monday August 09, 2010 @01:02AM (#1587057)
> All humans have on average the same intelligence. Why do you assume that there will be a few who will be able to keep up with the pace of retraining oneself.

I think you do not quite understand the concept of an 'average'. When one is hiring for a job, does one hire 'humanity' with its average, or an individual human who can be arbitrarily above or below the average?

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by fmora on Monday August 09, 2010 @02:12AM (#1587154)
I stand corrected. You are assuming that a person with a phd is inherently smarter than a person running a hot dog stand. He is not. He has more accumulated knowledge but I don't think he is necessarily smarter. I bet that if the hot dog person had been rightly motivated at a young age he could also get a phd. Also, a lot of people are able to game interviews.

The difference between an average intelligent person and a super genius is really quite small when it comes to brain power. What you will notice is that the super genius got to where he is because he has worked harder at it than anybody else. From the outside it looks like he is just that much smarter than you or me. The truth is that he is probably just as smart as you or me. He just works harder than you or me at what he does. Same with talented pianist or painters. People like to think that they are borne that way. The truth is that they log thousands and thousands of hours working at it, usually at a very young age. Once they become very good at what they do people label it as talent and do not remember the hard work that it took them to get there. A really brief example, to people from 2000 years ago you will seem like a super-super genius because of all the things you know. Is that truth? No, people from 2000 years are just as smart as you and me. Difference between geniuses and average person is probably so minuscule that it really doesn't contribute that much to success. Persistence and working at it is what makes the difference. There are a lot of supposed geniuses (really high IQ averages) that are complete bums and never achieve anything in life.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by gwern on Monday August 09, 2010 @05:08AM (#1587422)
> You are assuming that a person with a phd is inherently smarter than a person running a hot dog stand.

I'm assuming that if I pick random PhDs and hot dog vendors, I will get a higher average IQ from my random PhDs. Are my PhDs strictly greater in IQ than my hot dog sellers? Maybe, maybe not. But will, say, 99% of my PhDs have a higher IQ? I'd bet on that number or something like it.

> No, people from 2000 years are just as smart as you and me.

No, they were not. There were a few geniuses back then, the ones we still read and write books about. All few tens of thousands of them out of billions. But the average was vastly below the modern-day.

The environmental causes alone are legion: lead plumbing, no formal schooling (worth something like 5-10 IQ points), rampant parasitic diseases of every conceivable sort, irregular or poor nutrition with nutritional deficits (protein deficiency damaging early neurological development - low myelination of nerves, iodine deficiency, etc.), medicine that would kill most patients...

Your only valid points are that IQ is not perfectly correlated with success and that it varies within every group. This is not news to anyone who has done even a little reading on the topic.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by fmora on Monday August 09, 2010 @08:20PM (#1590000)
I think you and me are using different definitions of smart. You think a person is smart only if he goes to school. That is not what I mean by smart. So that you understand I'll use potential education ability as my definition for smart. A person from a hot dog stand has the same potential to get a phd as anybody else. A person from 2000 years ago has the same potential to get a phd as anybody as in our time. Now, what is the potential for a dog. Its potential is that he can learn a couple of hundreds of words during his life time. You cannot increase your potential to learn when you are born the same way that a dog cannot increase his potential to learn so that it matches that of a human. I would say the majority (99%) of the human population today as with those of 2000 years ago have the potential to earn a phd.

Please read this article: http://calnewport.com/blog/2010/08/09/beyond-the-10000-hour-...

A person with far more education than you and me and by your definition much more smarter than you or me pretty much agrees with me. If you want to become great- i.e. get a phd and do great research - you have to work harder than the other person. Notice how much "work" is emphasized.

Honestly if you still don't agree with me after this than I give up. Go on believing that only a selected few chosen by God were given the gift of being smart. You cannot convince the person that simply refuses to see.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by gwern on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:42AM (#1590681)
> You think a person is smart only if he goes to school.

I have never said this. It is a well-established fact that schooling is not just correlated with IQ, but actually causes an increase (Husén & Tuijnman 1991).

> A person from 2000 years ago has the same potential to get a phd as anybody as in our time.

...and you ignore my environmental arguments entirely.

And yes, I've read Hamming's lecture several times. Hamming was a great scientist. However, he was both not a social scientist, and he was addressing a room full of scientists at Bell Labs, one of the most effective research institutes in the 20th century. No one mentioned IQ because everyone there already had all the IQ they needed! Bell Labs was one of the brainiest places around! It was on par with MIT, where even the secretaries used and programmed early Emacs!

It'd be like discussing how to become a great programmer, and mentioning that you need to be alive. It's a prerequisite that's already met; discussing it is an utter waste of time and balmy.

Nowhere does Hamming say, 'and btw it doesn't matter if you score a 60 on an IQ test and can barely dress yourself in the morning, you just need to follow my suggestions and you have a shot at the Nobel!' Because that would be idiotic. Rather, Hamming at the very beginning states:

> "I saw quite a few very capable people. I became very interested in the difference between those who do and those who might have done."

He assumes from the beginning that he is discussing 'very capable' people and why some accomplish great things and some don't.

> Go on believing that only a selected few chosen by God were given the gift of being smart.

Hey, why give up? Doesn't Hard Work Conquer All?

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by fmora on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @05:50AM (#1590999)
>>Hey, why give up? Doesn't Hard Work Conquer All?

very funny

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by scotty79 on Monday August 09, 2010 @05:17PM (#1589428)
> I'm assuming that if I pick random PhDs and hot dog vendors, I will get a higher average IQ from my random PhDs. Are my PhDs strictly greater in IQ than my hot dog sellers? Maybe, maybe not. But will, say, 99% of my PhDs have a higher IQ? I'd bet on that number or something like it.

Are PhDs dominated by technical types? Can you have PhD in arts or post modern philosophy? Does that require high IQ?

> No, they were not. There were a few geniuses back then, the ones we still read and write books about. All few tens of thousands of them out of billions. But the average was vastly below the modern-day.

Not everyone could write a book back then. Not every book from back then survived. You can't tell how many ancient Ramanujans left no trace. Ingenious concepts of later ages often cropped up multiple times centuries earlier only to be dismissed and forgotten.

That said you are spot on environmental factors. Here http://www.ted.com/talks/esther_duflo_social_experiments_to_... it is said that thing as simple as deworming might increase very significantly children spend on learning and training their intellectual capacities.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by gwern on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:19AM (#1590646)
> Can you have PhD in arts or post modern philosophy? Does that require high IQ?

Yes, and yes for the latter. Philosophy is my own field, and while I would be much more comfortable making this assertion of analytic philosophers, post-modern (I'll assume you really mean 'continental') philosophers are still very smart people.

Since you aren't doing any research, I will do just a little, and point out that philosophy PhDs tend to have been philosophy majors, and philosophy majors tend to have extremely high GRE scores, and the GRE is extremely correlated with IQ; philosophy majors are #1 and beat every other major when it comes to the Verbal and Analytic Writing sections - surely not the work of people of average intelligence - and rank 15th out of 50 in math scores (ahead of majors such as biology, accounting, architecture and others; being beaten by various engineering, physics/astronomy, and math majors): http://www.ncsu.edu/chass/philo/GRE%20Scores%20by%20Intended...

> Not every book from back then survived.

Yes, but many catalogues (the Suda eg.) and quotes have survived. The survival rate and biases introduced by history can, and have been, estimated. (The latest one I heard about used statistics about the survival of works of the Venerable Bede, but I can't find the citation in a quick google.) The bias is not orders of magnitude, though it hits some authors badly (Sophocles's prize-winners, eg.) as one would expect from a random process.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by Unseelie on Sunday August 08, 2010 @11:55PM (#1586952)
Or, the future is the most competitive, up to date persons moving into a range of capability which allows them to marginally outcompete their less up to date peers, catching a faster acceleration. Their less up to date peers follow suit, but while they're retraining for their new devices, the leading edge is learning, faster than before, an even newer device.

Or, even better, the minds of kurzwiel's singularity are owned, trained, and taught by competitive corporations, who's only job is to make a great deal of money. The best firms are the ones who compete in the harshest manner, and again, the average gets left far behind. I think its far a mistake to assume that more stuff means an egalitarian future.

Re:Unemployed = 21st century draft horse? by fmora on Monday August 09, 2010 @01:10AM (#1587071)
If people are poor then they won't be able to buy your stuff. On the other hand people with more money means that they'll have a stronger buying power. It benefits the rich that the average person is also well off.

People will kill to own a singularity device. However, I don't think this will be necessary since by the time we are technologically ready to invent such a machine it will be invented or duplicated in every single country on earth and by anybody that wants one. We will reach a point in our future where the knowledge to build an Artificial Intelligence machine will be obvious by everybody the same way it is obvious now that the earth is round. This will make it impossible for any single entity to control this technology. The knowledge will be out there in the net for anybody to read. This assuming that we are not stupid enough to destroy ourselves before we reach this point.