News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna" by buster on Sunday August 08, 2010 @06:41PM (#1586382)
I get that, but that's a shame. It's like stating that the Sun (the magazine) or the "Bild" (german magazine) are well written and respected journals because they are read by millions of people. I always hated how those magazines can be read by so many people.

Or to rephrase that: If it's news (it's Hacker NEWS, right?), the first and most important point is that the article is objective and neutral. Atleast for me. And that's why i don't like those links on the frontpage, just as i don't like the suns, the mirrors or the "bilds" frontpage.

Or to put it yet another way: daringfireball.net is the subjective opinion of a single person who seems to rephrase a lot of apples marketing talk. It's not journalism, it's not news, there is often no objective proof, no scientific proof, just the personal opinion of a single person. It doesn't belong on a page that has a certain quality. In a news magazine, i'd rate that as bad journalism, bad news. And again, this page is for news, i thought.

Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna" by tptacek on Sunday August 08, 2010 @07:01PM (#1586425)
You just ignored 2/3 of my comment to focus on "yes, Gruber is pro-Mac".
Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna" by gojomo on Sunday August 08, 2010 @08:11PM (#1586564)
I prefer reporting with a strong point of view to that which adopts an "objective and neutral" pose.

Perhaps because he's so pro-Apple, he sometimes has new details -- as in this piece, that the internal bug for the antenna issue was two years old.