News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna" by tptacek on Sunday August 08, 2010 @05:26PM (#1586199)
(a) A significant chunk of HN'ers tend to agree with Gruber, (b) a significant chunk of HN'ers at least tend to learn things from Gruber posts (ie, the scuttlebutt that antenna-exec-guy was canned), (c) Gruber tends to be addressing issues that have captured the attention of HN, (d) Gruber captures the "quasi-official" "pro-Apple" side of those issues better than any other blog, and (e) Gruber's posts are extraordinarily well-written and people like reading them for that reason.

It's incredibly boring --- almost daft --- to complain that Gruber takes Apple's side in these posts. No shit, really, Gruber's pro-Apple, you say? Gruber has absolutely no incentive to be more fair to Apple's opponents than he is. He's not writing for HN; he's getting posted here by people who think he writes interesting stuff.

Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna" by buster on Sunday August 08, 2010 @06:41PM (#1586382)
I get that, but that's a shame. It's like stating that the Sun (the magazine) or the "Bild" (german magazine) are well written and respected journals because they are read by millions of people. I always hated how those magazines can be read by so many people.

Or to rephrase that: If it's news (it's Hacker NEWS, right?), the first and most important point is that the article is objective and neutral. Atleast for me. And that's why i don't like those links on the frontpage, just as i don't like the suns, the mirrors or the "bilds" frontpage.

Or to put it yet another way: daringfireball.net is the subjective opinion of a single person who seems to rephrase a lot of apples marketing talk. It's not journalism, it's not news, there is often no objective proof, no scientific proof, just the personal opinion of a single person. It doesn't belong on a page that has a certain quality. In a news magazine, i'd rate that as bad journalism, bad news. And again, this page is for news, i thought.

Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna" by tptacek on Sunday August 08, 2010 @07:01PM (#1586425)
You just ignored 2/3 of my comment to focus on "yes, Gruber is pro-Mac".
Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna" by gojomo on Sunday August 08, 2010 @08:11PM (#1586564)
I prefer reporting with a strong point of view to that which adopts an "objective and neutral" pose.

Perhaps because he's so pro-Apple, he sometimes has new details -- as in this piece, that the internal bug for the antenna issue was two years old.

Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna" by ergo98 on Sunday August 08, 2010 @07:04PM (#1586432)
What has anyone ever learned from DaringFireball? The scuttlebutt speculation that is utterly meaningless is such an example? If that's "learning" then your bar is entirely too low.

DF caters to special interest pro-Apple-enthusiasts such as yourself. His posts gets disproportionately elevated because your small group has to up arrow every unsubstantiated, usually inaccurate thing he says, while everyone else is busy paying attention to a distributed set of submissions.

In any case, it's daft to complain that people complain about Gruber's obvious bias.

Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna" by DenisM on Monday August 09, 2010 @01:44AM (#1587120)
If that's "learning" then your bar is entirely too low.

You're onto a something important here, but you aren't quite embracing your own point of view. If you think about it some more, you will end up not reading, much less writing much of anything here. :)

Here's a better way to spend time: http://www.startupbook.net/