News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Buy Anyone an Echo by gambiting on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:40PM (#15853590)
Yep. I have a friend whose house is almost exclusively using Hue bulbs and Google Home for voice control of them, and it's the worst experience I could ever imagine having in my house. Instead of a quick switch flick you have to say the command and pray that the device understood you correctly. It's borderline idiotic - we walked into a room and he had to repeat himself THREE times before google home understood and turned on the lights. He laughed about it and said "usually it works better". I don't give a damn. A switch has the exact same utility and works 100% of the time, always.
Re:Don't Buy Anyone an Echo by wakkaflokka on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:23PM (#15854152)
Sounds like he was just trying to show off his new gadgets? I've got Hue bulbs in every room, but if it's easier to flip a switch, I'll flip a switch (Hue bulbs still turn off/on with the regular wall switch...). What I think is useful is saying "turn off all the lights" when I'm about to go to bed, or if I'm out and about and want to make sure my lights are off.

The main reason I bought them was the ability to display multiple colors - I absolutely wear that out. I love having a red-colored room when I'm playing video games. Dimmed 'sunset' colors when watching a movie. Party colors when friends are over.

I think they're really fun, sometimes useful.

Re:Don't Buy Anyone an Echo by logfromblammo on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:58PM (#15853856)
Whenever someone says voice control I think of the two Scots in an elevator skit from "Burnistoun" S1E1. It's a BBC Scotland show, but may be available through your favorite streaming services.

When I want to remotely control a light switch with my voice, I tell a kid to get up and flip it. It doesn't always work, but I at least know that they understand what I want. And it means that sometimes you have to be the one to flip the switch for someone else.

Re:Don't Buy Anyone an Echo by icc97 on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @01:11PM (#15854024)
It is funny, but does a disservice to the major improvements in voice recognition. The one thing that most people don't complain about is the voice recognition of Alexa, Ok Google, Siri or Cortana.
Re:Don't Buy Anyone an Echo by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @05:42AM (#15860069)
Parent anecdote:

We have fireTV which offers push button voice commands, my 2yo -- who is a little retarded in his speech -- launched Plex the other day (I said "launch" he said "Plex"). I was, inter alia, impressed it managed to decipher his speech, albeit a single word.

Re:Don't Buy Anyone an Echo by icc97 on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @08:39AM (#15860943)
Very interesting, makes me wonder how young the voices included in the test sets were. Clearly it's not quite perfect yet though [0] :)

[0]: http://www.craveonline.com/design/1189025-amazon-alexa-doesn...

Re:Don't Buy Anyone an Echo by ashark on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:57PM (#15853840)
Time lost to light switches in a year is measured in, what, 10s of minutes and maybe $20 in wasted electricity and bulb-life a year? If you have a pretty big house and are kinda bad at turning off the lights when you should?

Even a perfect solution that never screwed up and wasted my time would have to also be very cheap ($100-200 for whole house—yeah, right) and take no time to install/maintain for that to be worth it to me.

Re:Don't Buy Anyone an Echo by scaryclam on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:56PM (#15853822)
To be fair to the Hue bulbs, we've got a bunch of them in the office since we have stand-up lamps. There's a physical switch controlling the Hue bulbs on the wall next to the door and it's way easier to get all the lights switched off if you're the last one leaving for the night with that one switch. But then, we've just embraced the common switch rather than replacing them all with voice commands.