News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple CEO backs China’s ‘open’ Internet vision as censors... by forapurpose on Monday December 04, 2017 @11:29PM (#15849729)
> in free market capitalist system duty to shareholders takes priority over anything else

That's not actually true, though I agree that it is often repeated and there is pressure from shareholders and others. It's not and never has required absolute obedience; and IIRC even that idea in the theoretical sense was developed in the 1980s, long after the advent of large public companies.

> Do you suggest Apple leave Chinese market?

His choices are not so extreme. He doesn't have to show up at this conference, for example, or he can make a speech that promotes the freedom of the Chinese people. There are many other ways to navigate the situation; see my prior comment regarding that subject.

Re:Apple CEO backs China’s ‘open’ Internet vision as censors... by richardknop on Monday December 04, 2017 @11:48PM (#15849811)
> He doesn't have to show up at this conference

I agree. But that would be mostly meaningful gesture as it wouldn't change anything.

> he can make a speech that promotes the freedom of the Chinese people

This might be more meaningful and would actually mean he is putting something on the line / has skin in the game. Which is why I can't imagine Cook doing that. He would be putting Apple's business in China in danger by doing that.

> There are many other ways to navigate the situation; see my prior comment regarding that subject.

Yes, but the more meaningful actions Cook / Apple could take, the more likely it would damage their business. So it is against their interest to do anything other than empty gestures.

Re:Apple CEO backs China’s ‘open’ Internet vision as censors... by forapurpose on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @06:30PM (#15857176)
>> He doesn't have to show up at this conference

> I agree. But that would be mostly meaningful gesture as it wouldn't change anything.

I disagree about its impact. He legitimizes the oppression of the Chinese people with his presence; he says 'this is ok'.

> it is against their interest to do anything other than empty gestures

It is against their immediate financial interest; my whole point is that there are other interests too.