News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by dirkdk on Monday December 04, 2017 @12:15PM (#15845489)
Finally! I love Apple but taxes should be paid. There is a difference between legal and ethical and US companies should begin to understand that. So hopefully others will follow suit.
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by tpush on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:35PM (#15846729)
The difference between legal and ethical is irrelevant in this case. Both Apple and Ireland had an agreement regarding Apple's taxes which was deemed illegal by the EU.

Apple and Ireland can count themselves lucky not to be additionally fined, since the likelihood that Apple's or Ireland's lawyers were unaware of the existing EU state aid laws are very slim.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by malux85 on Monday December 04, 2017 @01:58PM (#15846435)
I used to think this -- but then I heard the argument that if Apple was to behave "ethically" and pay the taxes that technically the law requires that they dont, then the shareholders can sue the company for not acting in their best interest.

Even if the above isn't true (not a lawyer) we cannot rely on ethics alone, it will have to be enforced by law, otherwise nobody will do it

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by vesinisa on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:32PM (#15846703)
> if Apple was to behave "ethically" and pay the taxes that technically the law requires that they dont, then the shareholders can sue the company

Well yes, but you know there's a shade of gray between engaging in complex, aggressive tax planning schemes and handing out unsolicited donations to the IRS.

A company's board is perfectly within its mandate to say it pays tax for its profits where it is incorporated, when the profits are made (and not delaying foreign profits in a tax havens). Because this is the very normal thing that almost all normal corporations do. The board is just as well within its mandate to say they do it for PR reasons to demonstrate corporate social responsibility.

For example, Nokia during its heyday happily paid a fair share of its taxes in Finland, eventhough they definitely had access and capability for all the tax dodging schemes in the world.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by pembrook on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @02:15AM (#15850326)
You must admit the irony in that Nokia example...

If Nokia had instead gone to the lengths Apple does to cut taxes and invested that money back in the company they might still be thriving as an independent entity today...ultimately generating far more benefit for the Finnish economy over the long run than being a shrinking Microsoft division.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by vesinisa on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @03:34AM (#15850579)
I admit to the irony, but sadly they could have never saved enough profits to turn around the company. They could have at best delayed the inevitable further down the road..
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by Nursie on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @02:48AM (#15850456)
Not so sure really, they likely would have burned through it anyway, such was the scale of the management screwup there.
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by barrkel on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:05PM (#15846484)
There's another way to twist that: cheating the people out of their government's revenue is a fine way to build up negative goodwill. That has a longer term cost.
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by alehul on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:22PM (#15846621)
This is very true.

There was a recent incident in France in which people protested outside an Apple store for them to "pay their taxes."

Apple wasn't explicitly breaking the law, however customers are entitled to vote with their wallets, and showing their vote will likely have some effect on the company.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by jotm on Monday December 04, 2017 @06:08PM (#15848430)
You're joking right? The tax deals and some protests will not affect Apple's bottom line in the slightest.

Customers vote with their uncaring brains, which will pull out the wallets just as they did before.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by alehul on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:42AM (#15849995)
Clearly some customers are not uncaring.

I'm not saying that one protest will have a massive impact on Apple's bottom line; just that:

1. protesting is a sign that the tax issue is an area customers care about, and those out protesting are likely a very small minority of those who feel that way.

2. the act of companies' feigned goodwill for a net profit could extend to any area customers care about, including legal vs ethical tax practices.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by pillowkusis on Monday December 04, 2017 @05:05PM (#15848009)
this is not exactly true, no[0]. The law's intent is to give shareholders a means of legal action if the leadership at a company destroys shareholder value for their own gain.

0: https://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2015/04/16/what-are-co...

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by Groxx on Monday December 04, 2017 @06:23PM (#15848505)
As one who isn't familiar with all this: "not exactly true" means very little. How does it behave in practice?
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by ABCLAW on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:34PM (#15846716)
That's a great argument in theory, but that isn't the way those laws work. The thought experiment is trotted out frequently to justify any type of corporate race to the bottom.

It isn't anything more than a misleading misreading of corporate law.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by matt4077 on Monday December 04, 2017 @08:48PM (#15849174)
This supposed legal responsibility to be cut-throat capitalists is somewhat mythical. You can't just give money away without justification. But management has extremely wide discretion in their decision-making. Almost all companies donate to non-profits, for example. Yes, you can argue that it is good for PR. But that argument also works for anything else that someone, somewhere, would consider "ethical behaviour".

Specifically for this case: there is no obligation to establish a super-complicated tax structure to lower your tax rate to 0.5%. Otherwise, 498 of the Fortune 500 would run afoul of it.

We probably can't rely on ethics, or, to use the term I prefer, "integrity" (doing the right thing even when nobody is looking). But that doesn't mean that we cannot fault companies for behaving unethically. If we expect people not to always exploit each others weaknesses in the pursuit of money, why not expect the same from companies? Corporations are people, after all.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by exDM69 on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:28PM (#15846669)
> then the shareholders can sue the company for not acting in their best interest.

I hear this argument often with tax avoidance and I'm not buying it. Has this ever happened to any company out there?

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by toomuchtodo on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:24PM (#15846646)
> but then I heard the argument that if Apple was to behave "ethically" and pay the taxes that technically the law requires that they dont, then the shareholders can sue the company for not acting in their best interest.

I've never considered central banks printing money to acquire majority interests in public companies in order to compel them to pay their taxes while preventing shareholder actions against them for doing so until this comment.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by ridgeguy on Monday December 04, 2017 @09:15PM (#15849267)
If Apple wanted to prioritize benefits to its home country (America) by avoiding use of ex-U.S. tax minimization schemes, it need only ask its owners (shareholders) for permission to do that.

I think Apple has enough market power to put shareholder return and tax benefits to its nation of origin at similar priorities. It would be interesting to see what Apple's shareholders would say, if asked.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by rayiner on Monday December 04, 2017 @05:12PM (#15848055)
That’s not really true, if it ever was. These days, officers and directors are quite insulated from law suits like that. The decision to pay more than you have to has to reach a level of just lighting money on fire, not taking less conservative tax positions.

Activist shareholders are the bigger source of risk.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by megy on Monday December 04, 2017 @04:57PM (#15847944)
> then the shareholders can sue the company for not acting in their best interest.

Sure, this COULD happen, but it is so rare to happen that it is incredibly unlikely. And has there even been a case of shareholders suing for a company not evading taxes enough? I doubt it, since all companies DO NOT do this.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by Nursie on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @05:14AM (#15850903)
We cannot rely on corporate ethics, that much is obvious.

But we can still make damn sure we expect ethical behaviour, and lobby for change where we can, and make our displeasure known through our purchasing habits and more direct communication.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by sumedh on Monday December 04, 2017 @06:13PM (#15848460)
> then the shareholders can sue the company for not acting in their best interest.

Has it ever happened before where shareholders have sued because a company was paying "fair" taxes?

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by dannyw on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @02:37AM (#15850400)
Also, the shareholders will just replace the board with one who would get the best returns for the investors.
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by philwelch on Monday December 04, 2017 @08:37PM (#15849135)
> There is a difference between legal and ethical

I don't see this as an ethical issue on the part of Apple (or, for that matter, any other taxpayer). I don't think anyone does any soul-searching about their tax deductions, nor should they. The soul-searching happens when we decide what the taxes and deductions are in the first place.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by adamnemecek on Monday December 04, 2017 @01:51PM (#15846386)
The tax system needs to be fixed.
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by stochastic_monk on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:08PM (#15846510)
It's going to need a lot more fixing after the disaster that happened this past week in US Congress.
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by adventured on Monday December 04, 2017 @02:22PM (#15846616)
US corporations will finally be more competitive on their effective income tax rates, with such nations as: Britain, Ireland, Sweden, Norway, Finland, Canada, China, Switzerland, Czech, Taiwan, Egypt, Estonia, Iceland, Israel, Italy, South Korea, the Netherlands, Turkey, Portugal, Romania, Russia, Singapore, Spain, Vietnam, Thailand and so on.

All of those nations have significantly lower effective rates.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by stochastic_monk on Monday December 04, 2017 @04:42PM (#15847803)
That's not accurate. Considering the enormous loopholes, corporations in the US actually pay something comparable to these other developed countries. The average company pays something between 12% [1] and 22% [2] -- much less than the ostensible tax rate. (See also [3,4].) Now we have nearly all the same loopholes and a lower base rate: a simple recipe for disaster.

[1] http://money.cnn.com/2013/07/01/news/economy/corporate-tax-r...

[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/09/business/economy/corporat...

[3] https://www.politico.com/interactives/2017/35-percent-corpor...

[4] https://itep.org/the-35-percent-corporate-tax-myth/

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by valuearb on Monday December 04, 2017 @08:28PM (#15849104)
This is ignorant and misleading, the only reason effective rates are lower than 35% is because of tax deferral, specifically for foreign earnings. Taxes on those foreign earnings are still owed when repatriated, but it would be foolish to repatriate them when companies would have to pay over 40% in both state and federal taxes, and their shareholders an additional 20%+ on any dividends.

Most countries don't tax their companies foreign earnings at all, so the rates don't even compare.

The real corporate income tax rate should be zero. There is no reason to tax investment, it's hugely counterproductive. Raise the capital gains and dividend tax rates to personal income tax rates, and eliminate corporate income taxes, you've eliminated double taxation and restored progressively to our tax system.

There is zero reason an 80 year old retiree living on a fixed income should be paying over 60% in taxes on her Apple dividends.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by drak0n1c on Monday December 04, 2017 @09:05PM (#15849228)
A lower tax rate is a boon to small and mid sized US companies that make up the majority of the economy and don't have the financial scale or international presence needed to take advantage of those loopholes. These companies compete daily against foreign firms, and against US conglomerates. I don't see how your comment counters the parent's argument that this a good thing for international competitiveness.
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by MarkMc on Monday December 04, 2017 @07:01PM (#15848710)
Not sure what your source is for that claim, but when you look at corporate tax revenue as a percentage of GDP the US is significantly below average:

https://espnfivethirtyeight-files-wordpress-com.cdn.ampproje...

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by valuearb on Monday December 04, 2017 @08:21PM (#15849066)
Lowering the corporate tax rate to 20% goes along way to making the US tax system better for everyone.
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by adamnemecek on Monday December 04, 2017 @08:37PM (#15849136)
How?
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by valuearb on Monday December 04, 2017 @08:45PM (#15849162)
Corporate income taxes are a double layer of taxes on investment. Investment is good, and lower taxes means more investment.

Apple's shareholders are currently subject to 40%+ total tax rates on dividends paid from US profits, and 60%+ total tax rates on dividends paid from foreign profits. Lowering the portion that's corporate income tax rates makes these rates far more reasonable.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by Nursie on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @02:51AM (#15850463)
Investment gets to be taken out before tax in most places.

Investment by the company in R&D, growth and training becomes more attractive in a higher tax environment.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by valuearb on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @06:09PM (#15856993)
Investments that companies make aren't an expense per se. It's almost always "capitalized" as an asset and can't be expensed, only expenses can.

But we are talking about investment in businesses by investors/owners. Imagine a successful US (California) company called Shmapple approaches you about funding a joint venture. You invest $10M for half of the shares in a subsidiary that will build a factory for a new product they've designed, they sell the resulting goods and split all profits with you.

So you ask, what will my share of the profits be? The company gives you very reasonable financial forecasts showing the factory should generate $3M a year in profit on average, grossing you $1.5M a year on your $10 million dollar investment, or 15%.

But wait, you say. I don't care about gross profits, only net profits after taxes. So you calculate it. First they have to pay California corporate income taxes (8.84%), about $260,000. Then they have to pay 35% federal corporate income taxes on what's left, or $1,180 more, leaving $1.78M (59%) left or $900k to you. But that's just the corporate level, you still haven't paid your taxes yet.

When the company pays you your share of the profits, you now owe income tax in your state, and dividend tax to the federal government. Lets say you also live in California, in the top bracket you average around 11%, or another $100k. And 20% for federal dividend tax, or another $160k. So you will net a little less than $640k, or a 6.5% after tax return on your investment.

But wait, it gets worse. Shmapple tells you that their business model is highly international. About 60% of the profits will actually be earned overseas, so they will also be forced to pay income taxes in every country products are sold in. So that's another 10% off the top. So you redo the math again, and now you only get $600,000 a year, or a 6% after tax profit (and you've lost $900k, or 60%, of your profits to taxes!).

So you say, hell no, I'm not funding that factory! I can make nearly that much risk free in treasury bonds, taking the huge risk on a new business for only an extra 1-2% a year would be colossally dumb.

So Schmapple says to you, okay, we've got a way to lower everyones taxes. Turns out we can defer the taxes on our foreign earnings if we don't bring them back to the U.S. We'll find a friendly country with an extremely low tax rate and deposit the profits there. And we'll wait for the US government to wake up and realize how awful their corporate tax system is, and pay the taxes then at a lower tax rate. In the mean time we can borrow against the foreign bank deposits and pay you dividends from that.

So you say, yea, even with all that hard work, my effective tax rate is still going to be close to 50%. You are just deferring, not avoiding, taxes, and when we pay them the future US corporate rate is still going to be pretty high, 20% or more.

So you make a counter-offer. Let's build the factory and incorporate the joint venture in Shmireland, a fair country across the sea. Sure the Shmirish might not be quite as good as workers as Californians are (maybe, maybe not, but they ain't much worse), but look at the tax savings.

Building in Schmireland means paying a 12.5% corporate income tax rate. Schmireland also doesn't tax world-wide income, just the income earned in Schmireland. We'll account for our profits being the same 60% rest of world (at an average 10% income tax rates), and 40% in Schmireland where we make the products. So our average tax rate is 11% TOTAL!. Now the net corporate profits are nearly $2.7M, and your share is $1.35M. After your California income and Federal dividend taxes, you will have around $960,000 left, or nearly 10% after tax. Now you tell Schmapple, do it in Schmireland and we have a deal!

This is what's happening in real life. If the U.S. tries to close it's "loopholes", say by no longer letting companies defer earnings in their foreign subsidiaries, they'll just make it even more attractive to invest overseas. It's already insanely more attractive now, how much do you think Samsung pays in taxes compared to Apple? It's Samnsungs biggest advantage!

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by Nursie on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @01:30AM (#15859033)
Well you certainly do make the US system sound bad, and heavily taxed.

In most cases though, as a non-US person it's the avoidance of taxes in the overseas countries that concerns me. It seems that many multinationals are finding creative ways to pay no tax in the UK. Starbucks, famously, but also amazon and others. Apple have this sweetheart deal in Ireland which amounts to a way to operate in the whole EU with no corporation tax owed. That's why both Apple and Ireland are in trouble here.

If you need to look at it in pro-business terms - it's skewed the playing market and left other companies less able to compete.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by Nursie on Wednesday December 06, 2017 @05:30AM (#15860020)
'the playing market'

Hah! I meant either the playing field or the market, of course :)

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by valuearb on Monday December 04, 2017 @08:20PM (#15849060)
First of all, nothing has been settled. This is just escrow, both Apple and Ireland are appealing.

Second, what Apple did was both legal and ethical. It had $200B in cash that it had already paid taxes on to the countries where it was earned. Ireland offered them a near zero tax rate on the interest it would earn if they deposited it in Irish banks. That was a great deal for Ireland, and a good deal for Apple, and hurt no one.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by matt4077 on Monday December 04, 2017 @08:40PM (#15849144)
> and hurt no one.

It hurt whatever country didn't participate in Ireland's race to the bottom, and would have been Apple's preferred base of operations when ignoring tax issues.

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by valuearb on Monday December 04, 2017 @08:46PM (#15849164)
There is no race to the bottom on bank deposits, Apple already paid taxes on these earnings to every european country.
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by matt4077 on Monday December 04, 2017 @08:53PM (#15849190)
?

There isn't even a tax on bank deposits, in any country I know. So what, exactly, do you think this case is about?

Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by valuearb on Monday December 04, 2017 @11:22PM (#15849703)
Talking about taxes on interest, not deposits.
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by ainiriand on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @07:48AM (#15851382)
It hurts because it adds to the already big amount of inequality in this country (Ireland). Me, as a software engineer, I am pretty much accommodated economically but you should see the amount of junkies and homeless people in this town. It is shocking.
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by Supernaut on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @12:11PM (#15853220)
In what way do Apple's tax arrangements here lead to people choosing to inject themselves with heroin?
Re:Apple Agrees to Deal with Ireland Over $15B Unpaid Tax Issue by valuearb on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @06:11PM (#15857013)
Do you really think that having Apple not invest billions of dollars in Ireland is going to help the homeless?