News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: please review SmartPeople by rick_2047 on Saturday August 07, 2010 @03:59PM (#1584193)
Well this is good but what I would really like (and was just thinking about since yesterday) would be the ability to follow a conversation. Some time on an article, the a particular thread starts to become much more interesting than the story itself. At those times (and it happens very often) I wish HN would allow me to "watch" that thread. Sure I can bookmark the link of the thread, but its just a pain to maintain that. And also I usually forget to open it again
Re:Ask HN: please review SmartPeople by vyrotek on Saturday August 07, 2010 @04:17PM (#1584232)
And on top of this, I would love the ability to know which comments were added since the last time I viewed the thread. Sometimes posts like 'Review my app' get a lot of feedback and spawn multiple discussions, but I can't easily tell which were new comments from the last time I looked. I can only see that the 'comment count' increased.
Re:Ask HN: please review SmartPeople by wvl on Saturday August 07, 2010 @09:02PM (#1584681)
I found that frustrating as well, so I wrote a browser extension (available in Safari and Chrome) that highlights new comments:

http://hckrnews.com/about.html

Re:Ask HN: please review SmartPeople by johnwatson11218 on Saturday August 07, 2010 @05:26PM (#1584355)
Seems like I watched a demo of google wave online and it had stuff just like this. I thought that google wave would have been a perfect replacement for the threaded discussion model that we have here.

These discussions seemed too short lived for my taste. I know that many people come up with insightful observations after they think about an issue for a day or two. By then the story is off the front page and what is the use in making the comment?

Re:Ask HN: please review SmartPeople by rick_2047 on Saturday August 07, 2010 @05:30PM (#1584369)
These discussions seemed too short lived for my taste. I know that many people come up with insightful observations after they think about an issue for a day or two. By then the story is off the front page and what is the use in making the comment?

We really need to solve this. People have a tendency to comment only on things which are on front page. This is in part the fault of being karma centric and also the sheer volume of traffic.

Re:Ask HN: please review SmartPeople by whatusername on Saturday August 07, 2010 @11:48PM (#1584831)
General web forum software (phpBB etc) all solve this - bumping the most recent commented piece to the top of the forum. Digg/Reddit/HN broke this mould,,
Re:Ask HN: please review SmartPeople by vyrotek on Sunday August 08, 2010 @12:27AM (#1584859)
Exactly, there needs to be a separate feature/page where submissions are sorted by most recent comment date.
Re:Ask HN: please review SmartPeople by ritonlajoie on Sunday August 08, 2010 @08:48AM (#1585268)
Hi vyrotek, I just added this feature. Hope you'll like it!
Re:Ask HN: please review SmartPeople by ritonlajoie on Sunday August 08, 2010 @08:50AM (#1585270)
Hi rick_2047, the feature is implemented now. There are many approaches to do that, I hope the one I choose is good enough : receive the latest comments only (not the entire threads with the new comments highlighteds). Hope you'll like it, and thanks for the support.