News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by mberning on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:06PM (#15839251)
I really cannot sympathize. My father raised a family of 6 making ~$30k/yr at his peak. Yes we struggled at times. Public school. Knock off sneakers. Cheap cost cutter food and small simple meals. Crap car. Etc.

When I started working in software I made way more money right out of school than my family ever made. And I developed a lot of bad spending habits as a result. After a few years I got my head on straight. Paid off all my debt, got disciplined about saving, and cut out unnecessary expenses.

It’s not that hard to live very comfortably on 100k. But you aren’t going to be eating out all the time, driving new cars, living in a gigantic mcmansion, etc.

Edit: My youngest sibling was born in 93. 30k in 93 is like 50k today. HALF of what the people in this article are living on. Give me a break! These people don’t need a raise or a hand out, they need a realistic budget.

Re:Living on $100k a Year by ivraatiems on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:17PM (#15839319)
> My father raised a family of 6 making ~$30k/yr at his peak.

When your father was working and you were growing up, $30k was worth more (perhaps much more, depending on how old you are) than it is now. His job probably had benefits and protections modern jobs don't have. What used to work for people increasingly doesn't work, in large part because benefits are disappearing, government programs and subsidies are being cut, and what's considered a "fair wage" hasn't tracked at all with how much things actually cost, especially on the coast.

Re:Living on $100k a Year by flatline on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:26PM (#15839379)
Crap cars are also expensive as hell to keep running nowadays. Buying new or nearly new, if you need the transportation for your job, can be more economical. That wasn’t the case 40 years ago. That labor that his mom presumably put in is also not without monetary value - two working parents cost a fortune in childcare, and many people need both salaries to make the equivalent of what just one used to.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by ams6110 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:47PM (#15839504)
Really, any "mainstream" car made in the last 15 years is going to be quite good. I'm talking about Honda, Toyota, Nissan, Ford, etc. My newest car is a 2004 Honda with 230,000 miles. I bought it used when it had about 80,000 miles. It's been very reliable. I've likewise had a good experience with a 2002 Ford.

40 years ago, 100,000 miles was considered the practical life of a car. If it hadn't rusted out by then it had probably had a major failure such as a transmission or engine. The only advantage they had was being mechanically simple and easier to repair, but they needed more repairs and more maintenance than a car made in this century.

Re:Living on $100k a Year by RickJWag on Sunday December 03, 2017 @08:55PM (#15840926)
Agree, totally. We're living in an automotive 'golden age', where reliability, safety and performance are at all-time highs.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by rayiner on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:47PM (#15839503)
That's a falsehood people tell themselves to justify buying a new car. One of my parents' cars is a 2003 Acura. It's never needed anything but oil changes since we got it. Cars these days are much cheaper to operate than they used to be.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by RickJWag on Sunday December 03, 2017 @08:53PM (#15840920)
Totally true. Just about every reputable financial advisor says to drive used cars and run them 'till the wheels fall off.

Today's used cars are fantastically reliable, historically. (At least if you stick with 'Best Buy' recommendations.)

Re:Living on $100k a Year by flatline on Sunday December 03, 2017 @04:26PM (#15839680)
Hondas are notoriously reliable, but at a certain age things can start going wrong and if you need that car you can easily pay more than it’s worth to keep it running a few more months. It’s happened to me before, it just happened to my friend’s CRV. The problem is that they are a gamble.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by MisterKent on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:37PM (#15839441)
Crap cars are a poor tax. They can't afford the lump sum payment for a nice car, so they basically pay the same amount or more but spread out over the life of their crap car.

It's not that they don't know it's a terrible financial move, they just don't have any other options besides high interest loans or not owning a car (which likely means not being able to get to

Re:Living on $100k a Year by brutus1213 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @06:17PM (#15840227)
Completely agreed. House prices/rent and high child care costs are what have done our generation in. What salary do you need in Mountain View to afford a house? 400K?? It is nuts!
Re:Living on $100k a Year by disallusioned42 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @04:05PM (#15839595)
I completely agree with you. I used to be in a very similar situation. I made about the same amount of money (quite a few years ago when it would have been worth a good bit more than today). I had a very similar experience. I lived paycheck to paycheck with nothing extra in the bank. Any unforeseen expense generated significant stress. It was not a fun experience. I can totally sympathize and agree that it feels miserable. But I cannot agree with the implications this article is making.

I was able to turn my situation around, not by getting tax cuts or help from the government, but by changing my lifestyle and my idea of what I needed. That house that you think you can afford that sets you back 20% of your gross pay? You don't need it. Cut your residence costs to something reasonable like 10% of of gross pay and boom, you magically have a surplus of ~$800 / month. That $400 - $500 / month car payment? You don't need that either. Stash away four months of the savings we just got on our residence and buy a used clunker for $3200, drive that into the ground, and by the time that dies, you will have saved up enough money to buy a perfectly fine used car for cash.

I have an artist friend who lives in NYC on ~$30k / year. She even has a car, which is an expense that a lot of people in NYC do without. Even in this situation she has been able to consistently put money away into savings and investments because she manages her money well. It's not about how much you make. Your choices have far more to do with it than most people are willing to admit.

Re:Living on $100k a Year by tedivm on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:20PM (#15839343)
Three out of the four "people" on this list are actually families, not individuals. So that $100k isn't going towards a single person- it's going to anywhere between three to five people. At least one of them mentioned having medical debt. That is a rather huge difference than what you describe for your life.

The other person is making $100k in a very high cost of living area. He's living as you do- frugal, paying down debt, and living within his means. He does raise a good point though- $100k does not feel like the fortune and there is still quite a bit of inequity.

Re:Living on $100k a Year by epmaybe on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:21PM (#15839348)
So to summarize you're basically saying to live within your means.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by arca_vorago on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:20PM (#15839344)
How long ago was that? What kind of cost of living area? You really can't take a number and use it to judge someone without taking into account so many variables. 40k in Texas would be about 80 in Cali. Due to inflation and other things that eat away at purchasing power that's much harder to raise a family or even oneself up on. Gone are the days of one person working and supporting an entire family like most baby boomers seem to still think is possible.

Of course the billionaires like it this way. They are destroying the middle class, but they keep the fighting at the lower ranks.

It's not the 1% that are the problem, it's the .01%.

Re:Living on $100k a Year by xor1 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:08PM (#15839259)
>My father raised a family of 6 making ~$30k/yr at his peak

If you're in the US, how are your parents faring for retirement? Are you and your siblings helping out?

Re:Living on $100k a Year by mberning on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:11PM (#15839278)
My dad retired and had a modest 401k. He also gets social security now. My mom works part time in the kitchen for the local school district. They are doing ok! I imagine they will come live with my wife and I when they are ready. I won’t put them in a home.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by xor1 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:47PM (#15839507)
What about the rest of your siblings? Are they going to help?

I ask because my parents are retired, and they are nearing the age where they will need assistance. It's just going to be my sister and I when it comes time to deal with figuring out what we are going to do. My mother has been financially dependent on my father throughout their entire relationship.

I currently live near them and visit once a week, but I don't see how I can afford to stay in the area if I want to start a family of my own, unless I find a partner that earns around as much as I do so that we can clear $300k+ a year. Modest starter homes in a neighborhood with both decent schools and a commute time under an hour to where the jobs start at $700k.

My sister and I also have to figure out how we are going to deal with my mom's relatives, who currently barely want anything to do with her, but will be ready to take advantage of her once my dad passes (assuming he passes away first -- I'm quite sure he will), and she's the main holder of everything. I already saw it happen with both of my grandmothers, so this isn't just unfounded pessimism. Both sides of my family are full of shitty people.

I absolutely do not mind every single cent in their networth being used to care for my mother in old age. I do mind that money being mismanaged and wasted, especially if that results in her needing more than what was originally set aside by my father.

Re:Living on $100k a Year by pm90 on Monday December 04, 2017 @01:44PM (#15846329)
You should absolutely have an honest conversation with her about her finances and talk to both of them about at least informing you about any changes they wish to make before they make them. Old people are very impressionable, and there are some very shitty people out there who give bad advice. They also scare easily, so they might take all their money out of their accounts when the market starts to go down even a little.

Apologies, no harm intended towards older people, just have seen a lot of them get screwed over. e.g. my managers Mom had all her (late) husbands retirement money in a pretty great account which was sponsored by her husbands company. But her friend convinced her to take it all out and hold it in cash, which turned out to be really really bad advice.

Re:Living on $100k a Year by pishpash on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:12PM (#15839286)
If he did that then he had government support out the wazoo and free meals in the school as a child and all sorts of benefits.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by newfoundglory on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:17PM (#15839316)
Is that meant as a response to the questions about how his parents are doing in retirement? Free meals as a child don't usually help with that.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by mberning on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:16PM (#15839307)
Yes we were on food stamps and WIC for several years when my two youngest siblings were born. Never on welfare. We got reduced lunch at school. It was about $0.50 if I remember correctly.

What’s the point though? If anything there are more benefit programs today than were available then. At $100k/yr you really should not be eligible for much benefit when you consider how much better you are doing than average.

Re:Living on $100k a Year by tedivm on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:21PM (#15839351)
Food stamps and WIC are welfare. What exactly do you think welfare is?
Re:Living on $100k a Year by Spooky23 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:34PM (#15839420)
Usually temporary assistance, which is when you get cash is considered welfare.

Most people who understand this stuff don’t consider safety net programs like food stamps or WIC that way. The difference is that the Food stamps/WIC allow you to work, and most people on them do. “Welfare” requires you to not work in order to get a benefit.

The most vociferous disgust regarding people on welfare usually comes from people who you would consider to be on “welfare”.

Re:Living on $100k a Year by tedivm on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:46PM (#15839495)
That is a pretty ridiculous definition, and isn't even self consistent. With the exception of disability insurance and unemployment the majority of welfare programs (including where people just get direct cash) are income based (meaning people are allowed to work, but if their income rises above certain levels they lose some of the benefits).

Food stamps are exactly the same, as is the reduced price lunches mentioned. If his parents made more money they would lose access to those welfare benefits.

Re:Living on $100k a Year by Spooky23 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:56PM (#15839540)
Perception is reality.

When the average redneck is barking about “welfare queens”, he’s not talking about food stamps, WIC, Medicaid or SSDI. Half his family is enrolled in one or more.

The difference with something like food stamps is that a “normal” working class two parent household can get some benefit. It doesn’t make a lot of sense, but that is what many if not most people believe when you actually ask them.

When well to do people hide their assets in trusts so they can collect Medicaid when they get old, they don’t consider that welfare either.

Re:Living on $100k a Year by mberning on Sunday December 03, 2017 @04:26PM (#15839678)
Yes. This exactly. We never received currency which is what most poor people understand to be “welfare”. In fact there is a bit of a hierarchy to these things and in school it was definitely way worse to be on “welfare” than food stamps. God forbid the kids at school found out you were getting welfare. You would be hounded about it. Food stamps not so much. Kids are savage to each other.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by tedivm on Sunday December 03, 2017 @05:07PM (#15839909)
Okay, but you're not a child anymore. You should understand that you did in fact receive welfare.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by pishpash on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:26PM (#15839382)
The point is that the difference the extra income makes is less than it appears, and the risk is entirely on the shoulders of the 100k earner. Not only no benefits but more taxes and more stress because no safety net.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by shas3 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:20PM (#15839345)
You’ll be downvoted for preaching frugality because many coastal-city HN software folk making six figure salaries are probably inimical to frugality: buying 3000 dollar bikes, luxury cars, eating at fancy restaurants, etc. in very anti-fragile way without saving with substantial cushion for rare adverse events.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by throwaway5752 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:30PM (#15839401)
Even if what you say about "HN software folk" (what do you and why are you on HN?) is true, I bet that you could not live on $30k/yr while building savings and supporting an average family, without relying on the charity of others. Particularly in a major metropolitan area in the US.
Re:Living on $100k a Year by emh68 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @03:24PM (#15839368)
My great-great-great-great-great grandfather lived on $1/day! Stop whining!