News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by rayiner on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:12PM (#15829020)
Citing market power as a reason for special regulations in cellular, where in almost every major city there are 3-4 completely fungible carriers, makes no sense. Verizon and AT&T have about 1/3 of the market, T-Mobile and Sprint have a little under 1/3, and in any given market there are smaller players like Boost Mobile.

That's an entirely normal level of competition for the economy at large. In smart phones, in contrast, Android has 82% of the market, Apple has 18% of the market, and Windows is well under 0.5%. In search engines, Google has about 2/3 of the market, Microsoft has about 1/4, and Yahoo has a bit over 10% (but they use Microsoft's back-end). In soft drinks, Coca Cola has 42%, Pepsi has 27%, and Dr. Pepper Snapple has 17%. In parcel service, UPS has about half the market, FedEx about 30%, and the Postal Service about 15%.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by zaptheimpaler on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:20PM (#15829068)
1. AT&T claimed it has NEVER blocked third party apps when that concern was raised in relation to Net Neutrality.

2. AT&T DID block Facetime, and wanted to allow access only on special plans.

3. The magic of the free market and competition did not step them

4. Special regulations about not blocking third party apps could have stopped them.

This issue is always framed as some lofty philosophical debate about "free market vs. regulation!!!" by companies.

In reality its perfectly clear that neither extreme works or even exists currently, just a precarious balance we as consumers have to protect that companies are always trying to erode.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by rayiner on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:23PM (#15829086)
It's fine if you think the government should intervene aggressively for consumer protection. But it's inaccurate to suggest that cellular is somehow unusual in the level of market concentration as the reason for such regulations.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by zaptheimpaler on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:35PM (#15829162)
Market power/concentration can be both common/usual relative to some context (eg the US) and yet too high to maximize consumer welfare, or too high relative to another context.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by rayiner on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:40PM (#15829198)
The U.S. economy is characterized by oligopolies, and I think there is a rational position that they should all be subject to regulation. I happen to disagree, but it's internally consistent. What's not internally consistent is to say that cellular is so concentrated that it requires regulation, then to say that there is plenty of competition in smart phones or search.

This is not "whataboutism." People who think that search or smart phones shouldn't be regulated, I think, generally have a notion of how awful government regulation can be. So they say that we should only do it when the concentration, and thus the potential for abuse, exceeds a certain, high, threshold. Their view is that the threshold is not exceeded in smart phones, or search, or parcels. This is, I think, a really common view. Under that view, it's relevant that the market concentration in cellular is comparable to those other industries.

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by zaptheimpaler on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:57PM (#15829307)
Im all for regulation in any industry when companies do bad things and people don't have recourse.

If Google started manipulating search in a way that really hurt and people did not have recourse, great regulate the f* out of them. Same goes for smart phones.

Its not inconsistent because my guiding principle is not "enough competition/too much concentration in this industry or not?", it is "are their behaviors significantly hurting consumers or not".

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by throwaway2048 on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:44PM (#15829225)
The demand for consistency across all examples before any action is taken is a very common canard to block progress on an issue pretty much forever.

Imagine if criminal law worked this way, where nobody could be punished unless everyone that violated a law was punished....

Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by gnulinux on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:50PM (#15829591)
I don't understand this "free market always wins" argument. What if all companies agree on throttling a particular service like bittorent? What if all competitors are too expensive for me to choose them and my competitor is throttling a majority of the internet? What if I'm already in a 2 years plan and cannot leave my service without paying some extra? Do these reasons give my service right to intervene in my internet experience?
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by Broken_Hippo on Saturday December 02, 2017 @04:44AM (#15831194)
Those concerns aren't unfounded. Companies have formed alliances to keep prices artificially high. Some are out in the open, some aren't.
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce... by scarface74 on Friday December 01, 2017 @11:22PM (#15830135)
Most of the "smaller" players like Boost either resell from one of the major carriers are owned by one of the major carriers.

Sprint owns Boost Mobile, Virgin Wireless in the UD

AT&T owns Cricket Wireless

T-mobile owns MetroPCS