Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce...
by zaptheimpaler on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:57PM
(#15829307)
Im all for regulation in any industry when companies do bad things and people don't have recourse.
If Google started manipulating search in a way that really hurt and people did not have recourse, great regulate the f* out of them. Same goes for smart phones.
Its not inconsistent because my guiding principle is not "enough competition/too much concentration in this industry or not?", it is "are their behaviors significantly hurting consumers or not".
Re:AT&T wants you to forget that it blocked FaceTime over ce...
by throwaway2048 on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:44PM
(#15829225)
The demand for consistency across all examples before any action is taken is a very common canard to block progress on an issue pretty much forever.
Imagine if criminal law worked this way, where nobody could be punished unless everyone that violated a law was punished....
This is not "whataboutism." People who think that search or smart phones shouldn't be regulated, I think, generally have a notion of how awful government regulation can be. So they say that we should only do it when the concentration, and thus the potential for abuse, exceeds a certain, high, threshold. Their view is that the threshold is not exceeded in smart phones, or search, or parcels. This is, I think, a really common view. Under that view, it's relevant that the market concentration in cellular is comparable to those other industries.