News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by monster_group on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:56PM (#15827972)
Can somebody with knowledge of radio communication explain how we are able to send a radio signal to a destination that is 21 billion Kms away? How powerful does the signal need to be? What kind of technology is used to generate such a powerful signal?
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by jacquesm on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:51PM (#15828458)
It's mostly a function of how well your antenna is able to amplify the signal, how precise you can aim that antenna and how slow you transmit. If you have a very good antenna with lots of gain and a very precise mechanism of aiming it (at an object whose location is very well known, and Voyager is a moving target) it will take much less power than if either one of those elements is not optimal.

The idea here is that any radio energy that does not end up in the vicinity of the target was wasted and at 21 billion Km that gives you plenty of opportunity for mis-alignment.

Receiving the signal has similar challenges, with the added complication that this time the sender is sending with a power level that puts its signal under the noise floor by the time it reaches Earth.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noise_floor

Fun fact: this goes for the GPS satellites as well by the time their signal reaches your pretty little hand-held receiver and it takes nothing short of magic (to me, not to the people that design that stuff) to recover the signal.

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by pfarnsworth on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:08PM (#15828988)
If we launched a proxy satellite into the solar system to help communicate with these probes, would it make things easier/better? Or is it better to just communicate directly from the Earth?
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by dfox on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:47PM (#15829250)
For Voyager-like mission profile building useful network of such data relay satellites/probes would be prohibitively expensive.

For missions where that makes sense (mars probes, STS, ISS and IIRC even original Apollo moon landings) relay satellites or even networks of them are/were used. To some extent for such constructions to be useful it has to be constructed of satellites that orbit something which is near to target of the probe, which is impractical for probes that are on highly eliptical orbits around sun, not to say probes that are on exit trajectory like Voyager.

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by jacquesm on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:52PM (#15829277)
Isn't Voyager on an an angle relative to the ecliptic that is large enough that a single satellite could have it in view at all times?
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by dfox on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:06PM (#15829378)
See the other thread :). Such satellite would need impractically large Rx sensitivity and Tx power. Doing that on surface of earth is simpler and significantly cheaper.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by DavidWanjiru on Friday December 01, 2017 @11:29PM (#15830161)
Are there bots that downvote comments on HN? Why would anyone downvote this comment?
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by jacquesm on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:35PM (#15829161)
I think it would make things worse, the only advantage I see is that if you got it to work at all you could do away with the requirement that you'd need three base stations on Earth. A single Geostationary satellite should be able to keep both the base station and the Voyager in sight at the same time. But that's a lot of money to spend for very little advantage.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by dfox on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:51PM (#15829268)
There is no launch vehicle that is capable of launchibg anything remotely similarly sized as typical DSN antenna, not to mention of similar mass. Also station and attitude keeping of such an satellite would be non-trivial problem at sufficiently high orbits for such thing to be useful.

Edit: TLDR: for the amount of money required to design, build and deploy such relay satellite in geosynchronous or such orbit you can do several manned missions to mars or some other planet of your choosing

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by jacquesm on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:53PM (#15829286)
It would not nearly have to be as heavy as it would have to be on Earth (no gravity to withstand so skeletal build will do just fine) and a 20KW transmitter could be powered on a satellite with relative ease. There have been quite a few proposals for antennae that unfold in space.

As for your edit: very heavy satellites cost (including launch) ~$250M whereas a manned Mars mission is estimated to cost $6B.

I really don't see how you could do 'several manned missions to Mars or another planet of your choosing' for the same budget as a single relay satellite, even a large one.

The problems I see with such a design are simply that it does not give you any advantage for spending all that money and actually stands a fair chance of making things worse. More stuff, so more stuff that can go wrong and if it does it is in a place where you can't fix it. Limited life-span as well compared to the Voyager itself because of the larger complexity (must keep two antenna's aimed at the same time while moving itself).

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by dfox on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:04PM (#15829365)
Unfolding some lightweight structure is certainly possible, but the attitude-keeping requirements are harsh.

Uplink path of DSN is capable of significantly higher power levels than 20kW, several orders of magnitude more. Also the whole transceiver electronics are especially fiddly, with various cryogenically cooled and/or high-power microwave valves without meaningful solid-state replacements, which is not something you want to have in GSO without any chance of mainteance.

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by jacquesm on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:07PM (#15829384)
> but the attitude-keeping requirements are harsh.

Yes, that's exactly what I wrote upthread, that's the hard requirement. And that is what will fail and then you've got a very expensive doorstop in an orbit outside of any repair capability. Inability do do maintenance / repairs is the killer.

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by dfox on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:43PM (#15829801)
My point was that the actual payload is mainteance-heavy.

On the other hand it is certainly true that RCS of such satellite would require exceedingly large stores of RCS supplies which will invariably run out and have to be somehow replenished.

Edit: even hall thrusters require stores of xenon and with the precision required the amount consumed is far from practical.

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by pfarnsworth on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:50PM (#15829264)
Interesting! Thank you for the info, I'll ruminate over that for a while!
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by InclinedPlane on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:10PM (#15829001)
There are high gain antennas on both ends, and use of error correcting codes, as well as extremely high grade low noise amplifiers on the Earth side.

The Voyagers have a 3.7m diameter parabolic radio dish, larger than the Hubble space telescope's mirror even. That alone provides a huge amount of gain on communications. Additionally, the spacecraft have 10s of watts of power available for transmitting signals, which is a fair bit considering (while on the other end the ground stations have up to hundreds of thousands of watts to transmit). The ground-stations in the deep space network (DSN) are tens of meters across, a small antenna is 34m, the biggest ones are 70m across. That also provides a huge amount of gain alone. It means that there is more area to collect signals from the spacecraft and it means that the beam from the ground station to the spacecraft is much tighter, concentrating the total transmission power into a smaller cross-sectional area at the distance of the spacecraft.

The spacecraft also uses error correcting codes, which involve transmitting many more bits than the underlying data, but in such a way that errors due to noise are not only detectable but correctable.

On top of all of that you have the state of the art low noise amplifiers in the DSN antennae. A typical low noise amplifier is a carefully built electronics assembly made by experts. The DSN amplifiers? They use 99.95% purity ruby rods chilled to 4 degrees above absolute zero to form microwave MASER based amplifiers.

There's a neat little video (series) here on the DSN and contacting the Voyagers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FzRP1qdwPKw

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by femto on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:08PM (#15829388)
There's also a neat book for those interested in the engineering details of their receivers:

"Low-Noise Systems in the Deep Space Network" Edited by Macgregor S. Reid

https://descanso.jpl.nasa.gov/monograph/series10/Reid_DESCAN...

It's published by the JPL as part of the "Deep Space Communictions and Navigation Series". The rest of the books in the series, listed in the book's front matter, have some fascinating titles.

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by ufmace on Saturday December 02, 2017 @12:46AM (#15830409)
Cool video, thanks! They also mention this website[1] where you can see the status of the whole DSN live, what antennas in what locations are communicating with what spacecraft, with signal strengths and transmit powers and bitrates and all.

They mentioned that the received signal from the Voyager spacecraft is actually stronger than the signals from several closer craft, because the Voyagers have such good antennas.

The videos of their decoder screen brings back memories of doing very similar things with oilfield tools. The same sorts of techniques are used to get data from deep below the earth, though not with RF but mud pulse telemetry instead. Same digital encoding types and decoders. I got to work with the guys who designed all of the telemetry systems and wrote the decoders for that stuff too.

[1] https://eyes.nasa.gov/dsn/dsn.html

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by quotemstr on Friday December 01, 2017 @11:56PM (#15830239)
That's amazing.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by muxator on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:57PM (#15828510)
It's obviously a question of power and antenna gains, but a very important role is played by the encoding: Pioneer before, and Voyager after introduced concatenated codes [0], which consist of a viterbi decoded convolutional code inside an outer Reed Solomon code.

Curiously, those codes are now superseded by other, more modern approaches, for example Turbo Codes [1] which are used not only in deep space probes, but also in cellular communications and other applications that we consider normal these days.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concatenated_error_correctio...

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbo_code

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by anderspitman on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:53PM (#15829285)
I worked as an RF engineer for a few years and one of the senior engineers once told me a story about how they launched Voyager (I think it was Voyager) with a Viterbi encoder, even though we didn't have the ability to make a decoder at that time due to lacking the computing power. So they launched it knowing they would eventually have the technology, and of course they were right. No idea if that's true or not but I love the story.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by botskonet on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:12PM (#15829017)
I read those links because I'm really curious but I clearly lack the prerequisite knowledge.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by elihu on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:55PM (#15828486)
According to the inverse-square law, doubling the distance will reduce the power of the signal by 1/4th. The moon is about one light second away, whereas Voyager is about 70,000 light seconds away. If we round down to 64k light seconds, that's about 16 doublings. If each doubling represends a 6db loss, that's about 96 decibels.

So, starting from a system that can communicate from Earth to the moon, if you can find a way to add 64 decibels then it can work from Earth to Voyager. Ways to add decibels include using more directional antennas on one or both ends or transmitting with more power. Alternatively, you can make up some of those decibels by communicating much slower.

The interesting thing about the inverse square law is that it's insensitive to the scales involved. For instance, going from 10 meters to 20 meters results in a 6db loss, and going from 1 light year to 2 light years also results in a 6db loss. This is much different from, say, light in a fiber optic cable, which would experience a 6db loss from impurities in the glass each time the light traveled some constant distance.

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by tempestn on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:10PM (#15828602)
That's assuming you're firing the signal out in all directions though, right? For example, a laser doesn't drop in power in this way. I would think a tightly focused radio signal could also avoid such extreme degradation.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by elihu on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:32PM (#15828740)
It's really hard to make electromagnetic radiation perfectly parallel. If you shine a laser pointer at something far away, the dot gets bigger with distance.

If you could send a perfectly parallel beam, it would effectively be an antenna with infinite gain. As far as I know, that's not possible but getting as close as you can is a good strategy. There's also antenna aiming limitations to consider -- it's possible to have too much gain if it exceeds your ability to point in the right direction.

The opposite extreme is an isotropic radiator, which emits equally in all directions. (That isn't possible either, but it's a good theoretical baseline.) Antenna gain is usually described relative to an isotropic radiator. So, an antenna with a gain of 12dbi means that in the direction it sends its strongest beam, it's 12 decibels stronger than it would be if the antenna were an isotropic radiator.

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by FabHK on Saturday December 02, 2017 @01:48AM (#15830622)
> According to the inverse-square law

I think that's the crucial point. While transmission through a cable etc. has exponential decay, transmission through vacuum has quadratic decay, so much more feasible.

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by jimktrains2 on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:02PM (#15828027)
https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/9824/how-much-rf-t... A good bit but not a ton seems to be the answer. Maybe in the range of a radio station.

The more interesting part is that Voyager can send signals we can receive (with giant, huge radio dishes, but still).

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by AdamJacobMuller on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:48PM (#15828426)
I'm not sure that the more interesting bit is the voyager->earth part.

Keep in mind that there are inefficiencies in simply transmitting with more power. The more you amplify, the more noise you introduce. No matter what you do, you can never improve the size and hardware that you're transmitting to.

I don't work much with RF, but, with optical transmissions, the major innovations I've seen are from better receivers that are better able to separate signal from noise at lower power levels. On the earth side of things, we can use massive dishes connected to modern hardware that have very advanced signal processing capabilities. Ultimately, Voyager is 1960s-era hardware with very very very minimal ability to change the software in any way.

If they wanted to (and had the funding to) build a dish on earth that was 10x larger to receive the signals from Voyager with hugely advanced signal processing, that's a totally doable thing. On the other hand, there is virtually nothing you can do to make voyager hear better.

Ultimately, its a lot easier to amplify something faint than it is to shout louder.

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by interfixus on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:17PM (#15828649)
Our end is not stuck with 40+ years old, non-upgradable electronics. The Voyager end is where the magic is.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by AdamJacobMuller on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:20PM (#15829699)
Exactly my point. The fact that voyager can still hear us, with 0 upgrades, is far more impressive than the fact that we can still hear voyager.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by jacquesm on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:52PM (#15828469)
> Ultimately, its a lot easier to amplify something faint than it is to shout louder.

Yes, but since you are amplifying the noise right along with the signal if the other side shouts louder it really helps. As does a very good directional antenna (parabolic, very solid mount, very precise control of its orientation).

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by AdamJacobMuller on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:21PM (#15829703)
and Voyager is listening using 40-50-year-old technology, its far more impressive that voyager can still hear us than that we can still hear voyager.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by jimktrains2 on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:53PM (#15829843)
We can yell louder, listen harder, and pour more computer power into decoding the signal than Voyager can, though.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by mechagodzilla on Friday December 01, 2017 @04:59PM (#15827998)
It’s mostly just very high gain antennas in both directions. You don’t need all that much power if your data rate is very slow and you have a very narrow beam.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by nojvek on Saturday December 02, 2017 @09:56AM (#15832053)
Does anyone know what is huge baud rate for voyager? Dial up?
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by pcunite on Saturday December 02, 2017 @10:28AM (#15832222)
In the neighborhood of 160 bits per second I think for telemetry. There is other information.

https://youtu.be/FzRP1qdwPKw?t=4m40s

Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by wglb on Friday December 01, 2017 @05:46PM (#15828417)
At a very low baud rate.
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by jacquesm on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:01PM (#15828541)
He said that ('slow data rate').
Re:After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrus... by lucb1e on Sunday December 03, 2017 @02:36PM (#15839068)
I was wondering the same thing and found this:

https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/958/how-does-voyag...

(Searched for "voyager communication" on DDG, top hit.)

I was surprised to learn that it's a ground-based system. I'd think they would need antennas in space (on satellites) so that you can both send extremely powerful signals without disturbing others, and receive without having to go through the atmosphere. Instead, there are just three ground stations at approximately 120° around the earth for continuous communication.