Re:Show hn: Photo based captcha
by ermac on Friday August 06, 2010 @08:35PM
(#1582774)
Your concern is somewhat valid although if someone is making 30 plus attempts to submit a form can we not assume it is a bot? We have made a configuration interface to allow users to increase the number of possible response photos if they are security paranoid.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Show hn: Photo based captcha
by bsnss-mn-cdr on Friday August 06, 2010 @09:20PM
(#1582842)
You are missing the way people break captchas... it is not because they have super cool software that can read the captcha, have a huge database of hashed portions of a particular captcha softwares library or make blind random attempts that would set off any simple limits ( although some have 1 and 2 ) it is because they build technology that sends the webpage to an outsourcing house that performs the actions remotely. I know of one with 200 FT employees each shift ( 24 / 7 ) that solve on average 4 per minute per employee.
Re:Show hn: Photo based captcha
by mike-cardwell on Friday August 06, 2010 @09:00PM
(#1582816)
I'd probably use just use Tor or similar to make all requests come from different IPs. You don't need to increase the number of pictures by a couple, you need to increase the number of possibilities by several orders of magnitude.
A traditional captcha with 6 letters/numbers has 2,176,782,336 possible combinations. Not 36. The whole point of a captcha is that there is a large enough set of possibilities such that you can't just get it right by guessing randomly a few times.