News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by Gormo on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:03PM (#1582317)
Deflation poses a couple of significant threats.

Firstly, it acts as a disincentive to real investment: the rate of deflation is effectively an interest rate earned on funds stuffed into mattresses. If deflation is at 5%, no one will want to invest in any project with less than a 5% return over the same period. Risk and liquidity premiums would also increase even for investments that do provide a higher return than the deflation rate.

Secondly, existing long-term debts would become extremely onerous for borrowers. The implications for outstanding mortgages could make the recent default epidemic pale in comparison.

However, it's worth pointing out that the 19th century was largely a period of sustained, gradual deflation, and was also a period of tremendous economic growth with little of the amplified boom-bust cycle we experienced in the 20th century.

I'd conjecture that a climate in which a small amount of deflation is accepted as a given would foster economic decision making that tends to focus more on real wealth-creation, and less on the kind of financial abstractions which have led to the recent turmoil. As long as we could manage the transition from a slightly inflationary to a slightly deflationary economy (i.e. find a way to deal with the problem of outstanding debt), I'm not so sure it would be quite the disaster that the article portrays.

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by 1053r on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:28PM (#1582369)
I agree with your reasoning as to why deflation is dangerous, but I feel compelled to point out that the 19th century most emphatically WAS a period with lots of boom bust cycles.

There was the recession of 1802, the depression of 1807, the recession of 1812, the depression of 1815, the recessions of 1822, 1825, 1828, 1833, then a couple of depressions in 1836, and 1839... I could go on, but you can read the wikipedia page yourself. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_recessions_in_the_Unite...

These weren't small either. Many of them saw decreases in business activity of over 15%. Contrast this with the postwar growth period of the late 1940s through the late 1990s, where you see inflation and strong steady economic growth (there were recessions, but they were all under 4%, and they were quickly erased by the growth that followed).

So without trying to start an economic flame war, whatever they were doing in the 19th century for the most part clearly didn't work, and whatever they were doing from the great depression to the late 1990s early 2000s clearly did, if what you are optimizing for is steady growth and to moderate boom / bust cycles.

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by flatulent1 on Friday August 06, 2010 @09:20PM (#1582843)
Actually, a 5% return looks BETTER not worse, when there's deflation - you're getting the return, plus the base value of the investment which later can buy MORE. In your example the investment would allow buying 10% more later, the mattress-money only 5%. Actually getting that 5% will likely be more difficult though. When there's inflation, you're return has to match the inflation rate for you to effectively break even in buying power terms and that's not counting being hit by taxes on the gain that wouldn't buy more.

The real danger of deflation comes when people stop spending thinking it is better to buy later because things will get cheaper. Along with problems getting funds, that's the killer with home buying. If people think there's continued deflation in housing, they'll try to hold off buying. Of course behavior has to be adjusted for other factors too.

Deflation from things like falling oil prices is good. Many consumers will buy more of other products if their energy costs fall. It would help others pay down debt. That's good, we don't want them to default. Of course those in the oil industry want things to fall just enough to kill/delay alternatives or improvements in efficiency. It's good if we reduce the percentage of our spending on imports if those prices fall, but bad if exchange rate shifts reduce demand for our exports. Deflation won't be flat across the board by wages, products, or region so analysis is very complex.

Income is another issue. Considering that most worked-for incomes haven't kept pace with inflation for some time now, our value to the workforce has deflated.

Deflation is bad in the sense of allowing those out of the country holding dollars to buy up more assets like real estate. We want people abroad buying our products and services, not our land. Not owning our land effectively makes us slaves.

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by nerfhammer on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:38PM (#1582391)
The period of deflation in the 18th century was associated with the Long Depression, and overall it was probably more severe than the Great Depression though/because it took its course more slowly

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_Depression

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by jbooth on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:10PM (#1582333)
What? The latter half of the 19th century had ridiculous booms and busts.
Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by Gormo on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:19PM (#1582346)
Even in comparison to the great depression and the recent financial collapse?

There are always booms and busts, but inflation tends to encourage much bigger booms, and thus much bigger busts. Could you imagine the kind of risk-taking behavior that led to the credit bubble happening in an environment of anticipated deflation?

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by jbooth on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:27PM (#1582366)
The great depression and recent collapse are 75 years apart.

There were 4 major downturns in the 1800s, 3 in the later half, and they were much more severe than the typical recession in the 20th century, 2 were full-fledged depressions:

http://au.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=2008030421573...

This is in the context of the industrial revolution, so yes, very much boom or bust.

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by noelchurchill on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:55PM (#1582295)
"For decades, politicians and pundits on the right have told us that we need to balance the federal budget in order to keep inflation low; this remains a staple of libertarian thinking (even though economic research demonstrates that except in wartime, there is effectively no relationship between the size of government spending and the existence of inflation)."

Well in that case, lets just stay out of war and let the gov hand out monthly payments to everyone so we don't have to work anymore. If government spending doesn't lead to inflation then this should work out fine.

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by gaius on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:19PM (#1582347)
Notice the phrasing. Not government borrowing, not "quantitative easing" (printing money) but spending. In the US and UK there's never been a peacetime high-spending government that didn't also borrow unsustainably.

So if you're say Sweden (high tax, high spending) then perhaps you can avoid high inflation, but you can't extrapolate from there to dissimilar economies.

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by noelchurchill on Friday August 06, 2010 @07:44PM (#1582656)
I don't think you read the article, or specifically the quote in my comment you're replying to. It specifically refers to the concern about balancing the budget. You can't run a unbalanced deficit budget without borrowing.
Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by jacquesm on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:03PM (#1582316)
I think there is wisdom in the first part of your plan, but I'm not so sure about the second.
Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by noelchurchill on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:28PM (#1582372)
Lol, ya maybe we should keep our day jobs just in case.
Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by sp332 on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:09PM (#1582331)
Computer hardware (and electronic hardware in general) has been in continuous deflation for decades. "Wait until the price comes down" is common advice in tech circles. And yet the market has grown exponentially regardless.
Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by angstrom on Friday August 06, 2010 @06:01PM (#1582430)
Yeah, but qualitatively you usually got more for your money by waiting with tech, the price may have gone down on the original product only because something better replaced it. The price drops are predictably cyclical.

If I buy a commodity like corn, oil, or steel I'm still getting a virtually indistinguishable good regardless when it is bought. The expectation of price drop can create a deflationary feedback if it happens in enough commodities.

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by ajg1977 on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:00PM (#1582308)
Krugman wrote a good article earlier this week addressing why deflation is a bad thing.

http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/08/02/why-is-deflation...

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by bfung on Friday August 06, 2010 @06:01PM (#1582429)
Plus the title of this post takes a naive twist to this topic. It's not the current prices that makes deflation bad for an economy, but that the (perceived?) future price will be even lower than the current price, which discourages investment since the investment will just lose.

As for the comment about computer hardware (and this applies to cars), the opportunity cost of using the physical good now vs later is a bit more concrete than throwing money in a "business", esp. startups, which are by nature extremely risky.

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by viggity on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:55PM (#1582292)
FTA: "For decades, politicians and pundits on the right have told us that we need to balance the federal budget in order to keep inflation low; this remains a staple of libertarian thinking (even though economic research demonstrates that except in wartime, there is effectively no relationship between the size of government spending and the existence of inflation)"

Sure there is no correlation between size of government and the existence of inflation, but that isn't what the "politicians and pundits on the right" have said, they said "we need to balance the federal budget in order to keep inflation low".

It isn't overall government spending is going indicate inflation, but rather large deficit spending and/or large gov debt that is going to lead to inflation because the only way to pay off creditors is to print more money, the more money in circulation the less value it has => inflation.

Am I wrong? Isn't there some awful inflation going on right now in Zimbabwe because they government keeps printing more and more money to pay off its debt?

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by chrismealy on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:09PM (#1582332)
That's not been the case for Japan.

The cause of the inflation in Zimbabwe is the collapse of their economy, not the other way around. More here: http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=3773

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by gahahaha on Friday August 06, 2010 @07:21PM (#1582614)
There is actually deflation in Zimbabwe now. From Wikipedia: """In an effort to combat inflation and foster economic growth the Zimbabwean Dollar was suspended indefinitely on 12 April 2009. Zimbabwe now allows trade in the United States Dollar and various other currencies such as the South African Rand, Euro, Sterling, and Botswana Pula. The use of the US Dollar yielded enormous results within weeks as inflation actually fell below zero to -3 percent."""

Also, a brief repetition of what we have learned from Keynes: """Economies can and often do suffer from an overall lack of demand, which leads to involuntary unemployment.The economy's automatic tendency to correct shortfalls in demand, if it exists at all, operates slowly and painfully. Government policies to increase demand, by contrast, can reduce unemployment quickly. Sometimes increasing the money supply won't be enough to persuade the private sector to spend more, and government spending must step into the breach"""

This is the point we are at now "government spending must step into the breach". And we can borrow to our harts content because we are in a liquidity trap where rates are zero, and deflation is the clear and present danger, not inflation. If inflation comes back, we should cheer, because that means that the economy is doing better again. Comparing the US to Zimbabwe is complete nonsense.

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by noelchurchill on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:59PM (#1582306)
You're right.

Inflation actually refers to an increasing number of dollars in the economy, not increasing prices of goods. More dollars in the economy will lead to higher prices of goods and services, so this leads to the common misconception. But like you said, if government spending is larger without larger deficits, this would mean they're spending more existing dollars, no new dollars are created, and prices of goods stay the same.

[deleted]
Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by lionhearted on Friday August 06, 2010 @06:03PM (#1582433)
Well, you're both right, or you're both wrong, depending on how you look at it. From your Wikipedia link:

> The term "inflation" originally referred to increases in the amount of money in circulation. Today, the term monetary inflation is generally used to distinguish such an occurrence from a general rise in prices, sometimes called price inflation.

"Price inflation" is the increase of prices. "Monetary inflation" is increases in the size of the money supply. Economists originally used to use the term "inflation" to mean monetary inflation (larger money supply), and if it's an economist not speaking to a popular audience, that's probably what he means. A larger money supply (monetary inflation) typically results in higher prices (price inflation).

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by jakehow on Friday August 06, 2010 @06:16PM (#1582472)
Gotta love the confidence. You are talking about price inflation, the parent is talking about currency inflation.

Maybe you guys should stick to Merriam Webster's definition which masterfully butchers them into one:

"a continuing rise in the general price level usually attributed to an increase in the volume of money and credit relative to available goods and services"

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/inflation

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by chrismealy on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:55PM (#1582294)
Folks interested in deflation will want to check out Irving Fisher's debt deflation and Hyman Minsky's work:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt_deflation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyman_Minsky

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by j_baker on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:54PM (#1582290)
This is what I love about slate. It seems to do a better job of reporting on issues like this without a lot of partisan ideology.
Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by kevbin on Saturday August 07, 2010 @04:07AM (#1583261)
Slate is partisan ideology packaged as Kinsley-ism: "the common wisdom is right, but not for the reason everyone thinks!" He brought that shtick over from The New Republic and it seems to have taken root, even Jack Shafer can't fix it.

If there's any doubt about Slate's partisan leanings, here's how Slate's editors voted in 2008: Barack Obama: 55 John McCain: 1 Bob Barr: 1 Not McCain: 1 Noncitizen, can't vote: 4

http://www.slate.com/id/2203151/pagenum/4

Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by hop on Friday August 06, 2010 @06:03PM (#1582434)
Information, trade and money flows at light speed around the world now. This is very different than the 1930's and with a world wide market system, and the US having the reserve currency, I think it would be tough to have spiraling asset deflation like the Great Depression. Whats not tough is abusing this and printing tons of money.
Re:Deflation - Are lower prices scarier than higher ones? by sentinel on Friday August 06, 2010 @08:10PM (#1582716)
Not for me they ain't.