News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by jermaustin1 on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:05PM (#15812120)
>Free-market AA could offer better incentives

Baseless/Unsubstantiated comment. Unions come in when the people who are working there feel they aren't being treated fairly. Sure Free-market AA could offer better incentives to SOME, but at the detriment to MOST.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:19PM (#15812202)
Can't speak to the peculiarities of this situation, but in general, unions have the exact opposite effect: they benefit SOME workers at the expense of MOST workers outside the bargain.

Argentina is a model example of what happens when the pilots have a strong union: they have the highest pilot salary in south america and there are consistent service outages due to strikes on holidays.

Fear not that if union workers could collect a paycheck without showing up to work and no consequence, you would not see any working.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by jackvalentine on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:30PM (#15812253)
> Fear not that if literally anyone in the world could collect a paycheck without showing up to work and no consequence, you would not see any working.

Fixed that for you.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:48PM (#15812357)
I agree 100%
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by ubernostrum on Thursday November 30, 2017 @07:14AM (#15815125)
So you're in favor of a 100% estate tax, and outlawing parents creating trust funds or other vehicles for their children to get around that tax, yes?
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by pavel_lishin on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:04AM (#15816229)
jackvalentine didn't propose anything, just stated a fact. You should ask politely before trying to put things in people's mouths.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by ubernostrum on Thursday November 30, 2017 @04:40PM (#15819807)
It's the logical conclusion, though. If it's a fact that anyone who can "collect a check" without working will do so, and if it's considered bad that someone would do that, then a 100% estate tax would fix one big way people manage that. Since as we all know, anyone who inherits enough money that they don't need to work will never work.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @08:06PM (#15821149)
It isn't. Stop insisting on that.

If you wish to talk about the 100% estate tax I'm willing to talk about it tho. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JPdjuPPtnWA

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by ubernostrum on Friday December 01, 2017 @01:03AM (#15822253)
I'm more interested in why:

1. People selectively choose to care about whether another person or class of people can live without needing to work, and

2. People selectively advocate for contradictory universal statements about human nature depending on which humans they're talking about (in other words, applying different "universal" rules about motivation and behavior depending on whether the hypothetical person they're talking about is already wealthy or not).

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Friday December 01, 2017 @10:22AM (#15824275)
My original comment about collecting a paycheck without working is about the contrast between the alledged dignity of union workers versus their intended goal.

jackvalentine said that the intended goal is shared by everyone. And then I agreed.

There is nothing immoral in living without needing to work. ITs sometimes the opposite: should mentally deranged people or children be forced to work or live free? Those leeches. In the future its possible nobody will need to work. Thats just not the world we live in today.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by jackvalentine on Thursday November 30, 2017 @06:45PM (#15820719)
Don't put words in my mouth.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:34PM (#15812277)
> they have the highest pilot salary in south america

Sounds like a pretty good benefit for everyone involved.

> there are consistent service outages due to strikes on holidays.

Sucks for consumers, but your point was about the workers, not about consumers, etc.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:50PM (#15812365)
> Sounds like a pretty good benefit for everyone involved.

Yes, its just a terrible one for everyone else. Thats the whole point.

> Sucks for consumers, but your point was about the workers, not about consumers, etc.

Consumers are workers. If we talk only about pilots, its also bad: the union prevents other pilots from being hired.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by rev_bird on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @09:30PM (#15812992)
>Consumers are workers.

This is circular logic, isn't it? It's like saying McDonald's should only pay workers $3 an hour because I, some uninvolved person who happens to be a worker elsewhere, would like a cheaper hamburger. That's not pro-worker, that's pro-hamburger.

If the question is about a fair playing field between bosses and workers, I don't understand what a strike inconveniencing people has to do with it.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:33PM (#15813253)
It isnt, because not all workers can unionize. In consequence, unionized get the better on non unionized.

The artificial increase of wages has the same effect that the artificual increase of profits

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by jackvalentine on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:40PM (#15813285)
> It isnt, because not all workers can unionize.

Yes they can.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @11:35PM (#15813500)
They cant, for multiple reasons. But even if you believe what you said, all workers dont unionize. Thats an empirical fact.

So while they dont all unionize, still some workers eat others.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by mcny on Thursday November 30, 2017 @04:22AM (#15814469)
I agree with you to some extent. I want costs to go lower. To that end, unions are a barrier. However, why isn't executive pay also a barrier? Why can't we ever talk about it? I think there is no reason why our corporations should pay millions of dollars to the CEO and I think it should be illegal to be compensated for being on a board at all. Imagine the cost savings that could be translated to either the shareholders as dividends or the consumers as lower prices or both!
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:57AM (#15816707)
I think ceo compensation is another topic, but its very important to understan that CEO compensation does not come from workers, it comes from investors.

If you could effectively limit what CEO's make, the savings will go into the stock and investors, it will not raise wages, because wages are not set by CEO pay.

Think of the effects of a maximum wage in an economy. It cannot possibly help workers. It will definitely help investors/capitalists/employers.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:06AM (#15816805)
A crock. If the CEO gets a bonus, and everybody else no raise and some layoffs, how exactly can that be called compensation from investors?

Wages and bonuses are set by CEO decree. And they, across the board, set them as low as they can get away with so they hit their quarterly numbers and get their bonus.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @12:23PM (#15817493)
Im guessing that you think that all wages come directly from capital, so there is a limited pie of wages that can be given out. So when a CEO makes a lot of money, he has to be taking more from that limited fund and not allowing others to get it.

But its not really true: wages are paid by the production of the worker himself. In a farm with a landowner, an apple picker picks 10 apples and pays 20% on the landowner. That is, his wage is 8 apples.

A guy comes in picks 100 apples. By the same rate, he would earn 80 apples, or the wage of 10 common apple producers. By the same nominal rate, he would earn 98 apples. The common producer has a lot to envy on that person, and might make a case for him getting 8 apples, 80 apples or less than 98 apples. But in any case whatever he lobbies for will go to the landowner, because the landowner already has lots of people that pick 10 apples and pay 2.

CEO pay is agreed in a market, and albeit there are interesting governance issues, it is truly drawn from investors. Personally I do believe investors are getting stiffed. ITs just not the solution to increase wages.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by mcny on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:02PM (#15818988)
> CEO pay is agreed in a market, and albeit there are interesting governance issues, it is truly drawn from investors. Personally I do believe investors are getting stiffed. ITs just not the solution to increase wages.

except it is not. A CEO of corp A is a member of the board in corp B. Disgraced ex-CEO of citi John Thain is on Uber's board now. I think Eric Schmidt was on Apple's board at some point? Point is the board is NOT representative of ordinary passive investors or even institutional investors like Vanguard. The passive investors have almost no leverage. How do you propose we level the playing field for the investors?

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:50PM (#15819383)
I'm not sure, but my point is that docking CEO pay is not the way to increase wages.

The easiest way to decrease CEO pay is to obviously..have more CEO's. Interestingly enough, the more the public disdains them, the less you have.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by mcny on Thursday November 30, 2017 @09:35PM (#15821500)
> I'm not sure, but my point is that docking CEO pay is not the way to increase wages.

I actually agree with you more than I disagree with you. Beyond a certain point, higher wages are bad. I don't want much higher wages. I am just saying we need to cut wages at the top.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by jackvalentine on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:54AM (#15814343)
For multiple reasons. Which you don’t list.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:30AM (#15816458)
State often limits who can unionize. For example in argentina, police and firemen cant unionize. In the us maybe the military cant ( but the can in argentina!)

Second some jobs are easier to unionize than others due to geographicalities. Farmers in the us have below minimum incomes. Their effective unionization has no limit on how much wages they could get. But because its impossible to be cohesive with small numbes and large distances it doesnt happen.

Unions form successfully by their capcity to limit supply. Anything that can be imported breaks unions. Anything that cant helps them. Thats why teachers, cops, garbage and transport are unions in the us, but electronic manufacture isnt.

Hope this is enough!

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by jackvalentine on Thursday November 30, 2017 @04:28PM (#15819704)
Farmers unions exist. Police and fire brigade unions exist. Manufacturers unions exist.

Did you know that unions have been illegal in various countries at various points of time? People still unionised and fought to have it made legal.

It isn’t always easy, but any worker can unionise. You seem to be confusing possibility with activity.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @05:18PM (#15820112)
Any worker can unionize, but not all workers can. Akin to saying everyone can be rich and have a servant.

The prohibition of unions was a terrible thing indeed, and unions themselves have also been producers of tremendous violence, murder and oppression. There are no short examples of abuse.

Nevertheless, any union that has significant effects has them by providing new limitations on labor. You don't need to ban unions to make them dissapear, you just have to let labor roam free and then they dissipate instantly.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by jackvalentine on Thursday November 30, 2017 @06:45PM (#15820717)
> Any worker can unionize, but not all workers can. Akin to saying everyone can be rich and have a servant.

The barrier to entry for unionizing is a lot lower than getting rich and hiring a servant. That is not a comparable situation. Incredibly poor labourers and rich professionals alike unionize.

> you just have to let labor roam free and then they dissipate instantly.

We have completely voluntary unionism in my industry and people join the union voluntarily. You seem to have a _very_ skewed view of unions that only takes the negatives.

My union (Professionals Australia) takes a pragmatic view to labour relations. I resigned from my previous union because they didn't take that view and focussed on short-term gains for only a subset of their members.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @09:02PM (#15821367)
Trade unions are the easiest example of monopolization of labor. I bet you a bitcoin they either lobby to require professional degrees to excercise labor or give out their own. Tell me if i should give you an address.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by jackvalentine on Thursday November 30, 2017 @09:57PM (#15821568)
I'm torn. I really want to say 'I'm not making childish bets with you'. But then I really want you to give me a BTC.

I'm not making childish bets with you.

You have an... interesting... view of labour relations that I haven't come across before. Did you say you were Argentinean?

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:25PM (#15821885)
Yup.

Professional licenses are one of the most classic examples of limiting supply. Classic as Adam smith, wealth of nations, 1776 classic, where he talks about the artificial restriction of a certain number of years of study to be able to exercise some labor skill.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by jackvalentine on Friday December 01, 2017 @12:03AM (#15822059)
Ugh my union does no such thing - but you won't believe me so let's just stop there hey?

Even if it did, I have no moral objection to labour banding together to restrict supply. It's just the free market in action. Actors (capital, labour, consumer) are free to band together and increase their functional power.

There is no perfect state of equilibrium in a market, just a temporary pause. Same goes for capital and labour - what works now won't work tomorrow and so constant tension and negotiation will occur. Some parties will lose and some will win. Either way the situation is merely temporary.

Or is the free market just for capital to band together to increase it's power?

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Friday December 01, 2017 @10:36AM (#15824396)
I just went over the website a bit. Its interesting. First, there is this RPEng, which is exactly what I thought it would have. They do certification.

It also has an interesting advocacy section:

- "At least 10% of the work carried out on Victoria’s major projects must be undertaken by apprentices, trainees or engineering cadets...we were able to make the case, and change Government policy."

On Privatisation of power - "As well, privatisation resulted in large reductions of the number of staff employed as well as significant outsourcing of important functions"

If you asked me, I'd say its unavoidable for unions to do these kind of actions the same way its unavoidable for private companies to try to monopolize a market. Its the basic incentive.

> Even if it did, I have no moral objection to labour banding together to restrict supply. It's just the free market in action. Actors (capital, labour, consumer) are free to band together and increase their functional power.

Sure, thats not really a problem at all. There are plenty of circumstances where that will provide real and palpable defenses against employers that have powers that shouldn't be. But dont mistake the debate of allowing unions to exist, and encouraging them.

Much like the biggest employer monopolies, the biggest union results come through the government. Unions lobby for the government to put rules, like the eng cadets or limit outsourcing, or require accreditations given by them, etc etc. If you had a union that didnt have the power of government to apply those rules, they wouldn't be very relevant.

> There is no perfect state of equilibrium in a market, just a temporary pause. Same goes for capital and labour - what works now won't work tomorrow and so constant tension and negotiation will occur. Some parties will lose and some will win. Either way the situation is merely temporary. Or is the free market just for capital to band together to increase it's power?

This is a common theme I find on this topic: capital monopolizes and gets profits they shouldnt, so why shouldnt workers do the same? Well, two wrongs dont make a right, and someone being a criminal and profiting from it doesn't mean we should all become criminals. Free markets are precisely a tool against forming monopolies, both on companies and on labor.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by chimeracoder on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:41PM (#15812702)
> Fear not that if union workers could collect a paycheck without showing up to work and no consequence, you would not see any working.

You can look to the TSA or the NYPD for examples of this happening in the US.

There are TSA employees who have patterns of repeatedly showing up to work drunk, sleeping on the job, or stealing from passengers' bags and have managed to keep their jobs, because

And let's not forget three years ago, when the NYPD openly refused to do their job for three weeks[0], but still got paid all the same[1].

[0] I'm not complaining that the NYPD stopped enforcing low-level drug offenses that shouldn't even be crimes in the first place, but they literally collected paychecks while openly refusing to do it.

[1] https://nypost.com/2014/12/29/arrests-plummet-following-exec...

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by kalleboo on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:22PM (#15813208)
Why is Argentina the model example, and not, say Sweden? And are you saying that the pilots unions in the US are weak?
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @11:37PM (#15813503)
The pilots in argentina is a remarkably powerful union. I single it out because im argentinian
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by kalleboo on Thursday November 30, 2017 @01:42AM (#15813916)
I would argue that the behavior of unions in Argentina has more to do with Argentinian culture than the strength of the unions. In Sweden unions are also very powerful (to the point where e.g. laws about minimum wage don't even exist since that's covered by the unions, and unemployment benefits to a large portion are distributed by the unions rather than the state), but Swedish culture has a stronger emphasis on consensus so the results are different https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saltsjöbaden_Agreement

It could mean that unions or some forms of unions (state-backing etc) are incompatible with certain cultures though.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:35AM (#15816493)
I know that europe has collaborative uniones and they have shown very different results. I have yet to study the german transport case.

The unions in america and Argentina are more similar to italian and spanish unions which are rent seeking and confrontational. In argentina, unions have constitutional level protection, and union leaders have pseudo diplo powers( they are harder to arrest for ex). The result is very rich union leaders and all industries where unions exist have terrible employment and costs

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by ubernostrum on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:20PM (#15813200)
Without labor unions I would not be alive right now. I would've died young after slaving my life away in a coal mine, in permanent debt to the company that owned it.

But please. Do go on about how unions harm most workers.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @12:23AM (#15813668)
I don't know where you are from, or the situation you are talking about. If you give me some context, I'm confident I can make a case.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by ubernostrum on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:09AM (#15814156)
I grew up in the Appalachian coal belt of the US.

If you'd like to continue making blanket statements about unions being harmful to "most" workers, I'll be happy to give you citations of what life in the mines was like before the unions.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:42AM (#15816555)
I dont need citations of worker exploitation, i have enough done by the state, by the capitalist and by other workers.

Im from a country where almost half the employment is under the table, and the rest is unionized. Teachers, truckers and state workers enjoy plenty of perks and would defend like you are the role of unions. They should if they simply respond to their own incentives.

The result? Logistic cost is 50% the cost of food, education tripled staff and got worse results in the last decade and state spending is 50% of gdp.

The teacher can reminisce of how sad it would be for the kids if she didnt have such benefits or were fired and would ask you a name of who is being punished by her benefits. And you couldn't answer with a persons name like the teacher could. But its still very real.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by munchbunny on Thursday November 30, 2017 @01:47AM (#15813926)
The parent poster is probably referring to the American labor movement in the early 1900s.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by emmelaich on Thursday November 30, 2017 @02:07AM (#15813973)
Australia had one of it's most dramatic Union disputes with airline pilots. The airline / government (Labor/leftwing!) won. During the dispute the Air Force supplied some pilots and some pilots were brought from overseas.

The result is much cheaper airfares and no loss in quality.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1989_Australian_pilots%27_disp...

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by bernawil on Thursday November 30, 2017 @04:54PM (#15819927)
Argentina has the highest salaries in many other jobs too.

Correlation is not causation and all that fuzz.

Also, that piece of propaganda conveniently forgets that Avianca just suffered the longest ever strike in Colombia, not really the most worker or union friendly place.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @08:09PM (#15821163)
> Argentina has the highest salaries in many other jobs too.

I get the point. Pilots however, are super interchangeable, like software engineers. There's no reason peruvian, brasilian, paraguayan , brazilian and chilean pilots wouldnt move to argentina to work and depress wages. Except the biggest payer and employer of pilots in argentina is the State. And it doesnt hire that many foreigners, for some reason...

> Also, that piece of propaganda conveniently forgets that Avianca just suffered the longest ever strike in Colombia, not really the most worker or union friendly place.

I dont know what colombia has to do with argentinian pilots.