The protocol stops counterfeiting, the miners stop individuals from failing to fulfill a payment (i.e. stops double spends) and theft is governed by whatever jurisdiction the crime happens in.
The US government does not prosecute thefts of USD in other countries.
Whose job is it? Anyone who has a stake in trusting and maintaining bitcoin's value. So the rich are incentivized to safeguard the poor in some sense here.
Now I don't mean to be patronizing, but it is useful for us to ask ourselves, "how were we convinced that this was desirable?"
Essentially, the government creates it by law and then forces you to use it.
I'm struggling to see how this applies to bitcoin.
Please expand. Which state is forcing people to pay their taxes in Bitcoin, and/or authorizing it as legal tender?
My understanding is that it's scarcity is the prime driver of its value, at least in monetary terms, and bitcoin shares that quality. Of course gold does have physical qualities that are useful, but so do many other metals that are not used as stores of value.
The prime driver of gold's value is clearly its historical role as a commodity and its scarcity, neither of which are related to any kind of intrinsic qualities.
My point is that the two things gold has going for it (scarcity and the fact that people believe it is a good place to store value) can now be said about bitcoin as well from what I can see.
Full disclosure: I do not own any cryptocoins. Too volatile for my tastes.
scarcity is only one factor to consider - demand and fungibility are also important factors among others.
Everything in that sentence also applies to bitcoin. Probably the one difference I can see is that if someone loses their private key, the bitcoins associated with that key become useless. Gold does not have that problem.
EDIT: Okay, another huge con with bitcoins is that people don't understand them. Most people at least think they understand why gold is valuable. The confusion a "cryptocurrency" creates is a notable negative.
Currency itself has to be created out of thin air.
... as imposed (that is, "by fiat") by some governmental organization.
Bitcoin's "true" value may be dubious, but it's most definitely not a fiat currency.
And whose job is it to investigate bitcoin fraud and theft? No one.