News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by dhimes on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @04:03PM (#15801591)
I still think you have to give authors and artists a way to make money from their works, and in principle at least copyright is helpful. But copyright seems to be becoming effectively perpetual and that's not helpful. And the whole scientific publishing bullshit is even worse.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by mort96 on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @04:09PM (#15801667)
My impression has been that the way bands make money is not from selling their music, because the record company takes most of that money, but rather from going on tours and selling people expensive tickets to experience something which is fundamentally impossible to experience through piracy.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by ge0rg on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @04:01AM (#15805573)
Unfortunately, tour tickets are a scarce resource and there is a whole secondary market that makes tickets even more expensive [0]. This is not an argument pro or contra copyright, just another limitation of this approach.

[0] http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/featur...

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by craftyguy on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @04:57PM (#15802227)
So you found one niche that suits your argument. What should writers do, throw 'writing concerts'? How about photographers? Filmographers?
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by conanbatt on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @11:39PM (#15804620)
Writers are not really protected copyright wise...they can always talk and explain and expand on what they write. Photographers can do requests, filmographers can naturally have rights to first showcasing.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by conanbatt on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @06:52PM (#15803193)
> I still think you have to give authors and artists a way to make money from their works

I understand the sentiment but..why. Why is it necessary. Art and science advanced on its own long before copyright enforcement of any kind.

True there are things that are particularly benefited from copyright. But they do so at the expense of something else. It diverts labor to things that later require law enforcement to protect.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by jorleif on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @06:09AM (#15806003)
It is not necessary, but if society was good at assigning a price to the relative merits of informational resources vs physical goods it would result in a more efficient economy.

Yes, science and art will progress, but if there is no economy attached, then they will be dominated by people who don't have to make a living. Unless we fund the whole thing publicly. That would work, but in other contexts we believe the market is more efficient.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by dhimes on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @08:06PM (#15803581)
Art advanced along fine because there was no way to copy paintings and sculptures. There was no way to record a play or orator.

But that, of course, is no longer true. The advent of technologies to capture and distribute art has led to new forms of art, and with that an amazing situation where people have unparalleled access to the works of genius. However, those new forms also have a drawback: they can be easily copied and distributed without compensating the originator. So in order to keep being able to support filmmakers and novelists and musicians we need to shield them from this. Otherwise, they will stop making their works.

Who is going to spend 5 years writing a novel if they can only sell one copy?

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by conanbatt on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:08PM (#15804223)
> Who is going to spend 5 years writing a novel if they can only sell one copy?

Hopefully no-one. Apparently there is no value to that novel unless resources are spent protecting it.

We see today things that in a non-copyright world would not exist. But we dont see the things that would exist instead ,so its hard to know.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by kbutler on Friday December 01, 2017 @01:13PM (#15825831)
Economists call this the "Free Rider" problem: people are able to derive value from a common good without paying for it, so there is less incentive to produce the type of good than would be optimal.

Roads. Infrastructure for sewers. Defense. Fire suppression.

These are all cases where a purely free market fails to provide optimal levels of the good or service.

People are evidently willing to pay for novels, so we know they have value. The question is whether the current copyright system gives copyright owners too much power to extract rents at the cost of the public domain.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by conanbatt on Friday December 01, 2017 @07:11PM (#15829003)
Isn't the author a free rider on the states legal infrastructure?

Writing books, making movies and composing music are some of the things that should we should never have an interest in creating externalities for.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by kbutler on Friday December 01, 2017 @10:17PM (#15829927)
No, assuming the author pays taxes, the author is not a free rider on the law enforcement infrastructure.

The act of publishing the book has positive externalities (people derive benefit from reading it). Copyright is an attempt to allow creators to capture some of those positive externalities to promote more production of books.

Your position that the creator should not have a mechanism to capture any of those benefits is rather extreme, as is the position of the copyright maximalists that assert they should capture all of the benefits.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by dhimes on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @03:18PM (#15810454)
Apparently there is no value to that novel unless resources are spent protecting it.

That is a non-sequitor.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by conanbatt on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @03:58PM (#15810778)
Why? If the argument is that a novel would not exist because the author cant collect value from it without copyright protection, then the value he is collecting is based on the copyright protection costs.