Re:Eric Schmidt on the Verizon Deal (et al)
by pvg on Thursday August 05, 2010 @01:34PM
(#1578706)
That's a 'fix' if network capacity were infinite. You can rephrase your corollary as 'why should my VOIP calls drop just because I'm downloading StarCraft II'. There isn't anything inherently evil in the notion that you might want to prioritize, say, latency-dependent traffic over traffic that isn't.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Eric Schmidt on the Verizon Deal (et al)
by nostrademons on Thursday August 05, 2010 @02:55PM
(#1578959)
Haven't people done studies on this and found that the cost to implement QoS is greater than the cost to just increase network bandwidth? That may not hold forever, but it holds now in the U.S.
Current residential broadband lines in the U.S. could go much faster with zero technical effort. They're capped because Verizon and Comcast only give you enough bandwidth to make sure that you get more than you would with a competitor. They hold the rest in reserve so that they can raise speeds and please customers easily when a competitor raises speeds.
We've got the slowest Internet speeds in the developed world, and you can bet it isn't because of technological reasons:
My point was that 'adding bandwidth' is not actually a solution to congestion-related problems. Double the bandwidth, now StartCraft II downloads in two instead of four hours, during which time your VOIP calls still drop. This is not unlike a problem urban planners have run across - adding lanes to a thoroughfare often does not relieve traffic congestion. So unless you can add bandwidth indefinitely so that there is never, ever any congestion, the issues are somewhat orthogonal.