News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by IBM on Sunday November 26, 2017 @09:10PM (#15784313)
What? Did you actually look at their cash flows? They are massively free cash flow negative, and it's only getting more negative every quarter. The only reason cash is up is because they regularly tap the capital markets with debt and equity, which is why Elon is constantly looking for new ways to boost the stock.

The only way Tesla avoids bankruptcy is if the markets keep believing in the Elon magic, because the operations are definitely not financing the investment required.

This is the key thing people miss when people falsely compare Tesla to Amazon. Amazon has always been free cash flow positive. They may never have turned a GAAP profit for many years, but they weren't issuing stock to finance their growth.

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by dforrestwilson on Sunday November 26, 2017 @11:00PM (#15784715)
^ Why was this down-voted? This analysis is correct.

Tesla is on track to burn >$500m/quarter going forward and will once again have to access capital markets in 2018. Junk bond markets have been puking for the past 3 months, so that option probably is getting less likely. That leaves equity dilution. Not good for current shareholders. http://archive.fast-edgar.com//20171103/APA8Q22CZM22D262222M...

A lot of the "Assets" noted on the balance sheet are the reservation costs for all of Tesla and Solar City's promised products. Tesla recently laid off a significant portion of their workforce at the Model 3 factory. Output was much lower than they had guided to for the quarter. It doesn't look like that's going to change soon. If customers start demanding refunds a lot of the assets listed on the balance sheet go away.

The liabilities on the other hand, won't be going anywhere.

People can insist that Tesla is effecting some positive changes in the world, but it seems to me that mostly they have been good at repackaging and reselling the tech of other companies in creative ways.

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by smoll on Monday November 27, 2017 @12:34AM (#15785091)
> People can insist that Tesla is effecting some positive changes in the world, but it seems to me that mostly they have been good at repackaging and reselling the tech of other companies in creative ways.

I've seen this critique leveled at Apple and it makes more sense there (the Mac borrowing heavily from stuff they witnessed at Xerox PARC and the original iPhone just doing what a lot of other phones at the time were doing, except simpler and more mass-adoptable), but what evidence do you have for this applying to Tesla? Even if you admit that battery technology improvements that made EVs viable were implemented elsewhere, the entire automotive industry was 100% behind the combustion engine before Tesla, and now almost every car company is building EVs. This isn't merely Tesla effecting "positive change in the world", they proved that EVs were manufacturable, that the public wanted it, and solved numerous obstacles to actually bring it to market. The EV would literally not exist (to the public) in 2017 if not for Tesla. How is that merely repackaging tech?

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by friendzis on Monday November 27, 2017 @01:51AM (#15785362)
> The EV would literally not exist (to the public) in 2017 if not for Tesla.

According to wikipedia a rather well known EV Nissan Leaf predates Tesla Model S by 2 years. First hybrid Toyota Prius is 20 years old. Toyota had concepts of plug-in hybrids for quite some time. Countless local teams make electric swaps. We had electric golf cars and what not for quite some time.

What Tesla more or less pioneered is premium class performance EV and proved that there is market in this segment. They proved that not only "convenient home-work-home trip" (free parking, bus lanes, subsidies) can be market for EVs.

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by ZeroGravitas on Monday November 27, 2017 @04:07AM (#15785859)
Semi-random historical aside, one of the original founders of Tesla (no longer at the company) makes the claim that Al Gore "invented" the Prius by featuring the work of some academics on hybrid engines in a televised hearing. Although ignored by the American companies he was trying to convince, Toyota ran with the idea.
Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by thedaemon on Monday November 27, 2017 @04:09PM (#15791426)
GM created the EV1 in 1996. They eventually scrapped the project and all of the cars. They didn't want to compete with the petrol car industry.
Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by IBM on Monday November 27, 2017 @01:17AM (#15785257)
People who level that critique at Apple are the equivalent of sports fans of rivals to the Yankees constantly talking trash about the Yankees. That is, it may make fans of Apple angry (and it did all throughout the 90s and 00s) but it had no impact on the fundamentals of Apple's business. While people were leveling that critique against Apple, Apple was selling millions of iMacs, then hundreds of millions of iPods, and now over a billion iPhones. Now I would say it's extremely shallow analysis of Apple as a business to say they were just repackaging tech (you don't do hundreds of billions of dollars in revenue over the past 20 years if you aren't actually innovating [EDIT: actually iOS devices alone have done almost a trillion in revenue], especially if you don't have a monopoly in the relevant markets).

Tesla is not Apple though. In order for the analogy to Apple to work, Tesla would have to be shipping a massive amount of EVs (and a growing amount as well) while they were being criticized. They haven't. In fact the penetration of EVs as a % of all cars sold is single digits.

If you want to take the perspective of the author of the article, then we can at least say that Tesla may have induced rival car makers to at least get interested in EVs and demonstrated a small market exists for them, but it's not clear that once every automaker begins shipping EVs at scale that it's going to replace non-EVs in the market in a significant way. What if EVs just top out at 20%?

On another level it's kind of a silly perspective to take because real people have invested their money in Tesla. A lot of them might be rich tech workers who no one will shed tears for, but big institutional investors like Fidelity own significant stakes in Tesla, and they're managing 401ks for regular people.

I don't think too many investors who invested in telecom companies during the tech bubble took comfort in the fact that at least society was left with a lot of fiber and infrastructure.

What would Tesla even leave behind anyway? The only thing I can think of is the battery factory which hopefully would be able to produce batteries for other manufacturers. But even that is not clear to me since China is pouring billions into doing that as well (and they're going to have a lower cost of capital compared to some private entity without state backing).

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by conjecTech on Monday November 27, 2017 @01:30AM (#15785305)
Characterizing negative cashflows from investment as 'burn' is incredibly disingenuous. The cashflows from any capital intensive startup would look similar. The cashflows from operation are negative, but not egregiously so. In fact, they are probably dragged down by the increased headcount associated with unreleased products. If Tesla had decided to stop with the model S and X, they'd likely be profitable right now.

Your description of their assets is also off. Customer deposits have NO net effect on their balance sheet/equity value. They very clearly have a liability of $686 million to cancel out the cash received.

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by Hypx on Monday November 27, 2017 @02:21AM (#15785466)
https://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/tsla/financials/...

Tesla's cash flow from investment was -$1.21B last quarter alone. I can scarcely think of a startup that consumed cash at this rate. That's an annualized rate of -$4.84B. Not even the pets.com or Webvans of the world ever reached this level of "cash burn." Cash flow from operations were -$300.56M last quarter, and losses were $671.16M. Annualized, this puts them at around -$1.2B and -$2.68B per year respectively.

If this is due to excess headcount from unreleased products, I say that's crazy and they should stop attempting those unreleased products.

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by conjecTech on Monday November 27, 2017 @03:25AM (#15785687)
Sure, the absolute numbers are large. But in percent terms of market cap, they are far more reasonable. To put them in perspective another way, Tesla has around 450k net reservations for the model 3. Even if half of those people cancel, and everyone buys the base unit with no add-ons, that is nearly $8 billion of revenue. I have no idea what acceptable ratios of plant/equipment to revenue are, but that doesn't seem absurd if they can fulfill those orders in 2-3 years and amortize the equipment over 15-30 years.

I'm not going to necessarily make the argument that Tesla's share price is rational, but I do think this spending is good for shareholders. The balance sheet equity is a pittance compared to market cap. People are betting on large future profits. And there is just no way the level of production they are currently at could earn enough to justify the price. They have to grow. To grow they have to invest. It's just the nature of the business they are in. I think being in tech gives people the idea that you can create enormous value without capital risk, but that just isn't reality in most of the physical world. I think they are at least being responsible about it. They went out and established there was substantial interest for the 3 prior to undertaking all of this - something Ford didn't do for the Edsel, which in terms of financial sins would be on par with this failing.

To get back to the initial point here, I do think the amount of debt they are using might be a bit on the high side if you consider their current and not future revenue, but the capital markets have shown a huge willingness to stomach secondary offerings of the stock, so it seems like they can and probably will remedy that.

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by Hypx on Monday November 27, 2017 @04:16AM (#15785900)
Your argument is a long winded way of saying: The market believes in Tesla, so any and all losses are acceptable. Look, at $671M in losses per quarter, nothing about this company suggest it is viable. Worse, the "cash burn" rate, or negative free cash flow, is an even more astounding -$1.55B per quarter. That annualizes to $6.2B per year! That's how much the capital markets have to fund the company to sustain it going forward. If it wasn't for its high market cap, the company would have folded long ago for lack of funds.

It's pretty obvious that current losses like these could easily overcome a decade-plus of future profits. Their debt is already rated a junk bond, so they aren't going to get any good deals on future debt. At some point, you would think, surely rationality will set in. I mean, Tesla is not the only EV manufacture in the world. Wouldn't it make more sense to invest in another car company that is also making EVs, and have finances that look much more appealing? Why would anyone subsidize a company just to produce a product that others can easily replicate? At some point, this has to stop.

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by DennisP on Monday November 27, 2017 @08:00AM (#15786929)
No, the market believes in Tesla, and agrees that they should invest their earnings and new capital in building factories. Remove the capital investment and their losses are $570M for the year to date.
Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by Cthulhu_ on Monday November 27, 2017 @07:11AM (#15786719)
> Why would anyone subsidize a company just to produce a product that others can easily replicate

Because you, and I think a lot of people, think Tesla is a car company. It's not; Tesla is becoming a battery company and a charging station company. That will make them as big as gas companies, because everyone will be needing both batteries and electricity, even if they need to offload their car business. Tesla will be far bigger than just cars for decades to come, and I think that's where a large part of shareholder trust is coming from.

I mean how many other EV charging networks are active?

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by bhhaskin on Monday November 27, 2017 @08:06AM (#15786962)
Here is a dirty little secret. Panasonic makes the batteries. Infact the giga factory is really a Panasonic factory.
Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by kakwa_ on Monday November 27, 2017 @02:55AM (#15785576)
> If Tesla had decided to stop with the model S and X, they'd likely be profitable right now.

But they can't. A car manufacturer generally has to renew its models every ~10 years with an overall mid-life. Tesla would be profitable if it had a net cashflow including these renewals. I'm not sure it's the case right now because it's difficult to differentiate between capex like building new assembly lines or R&D on core technologies and cost purely associated with the new models.

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by kc10 on Monday November 27, 2017 @01:19AM (#15785262)
>If customers start demanding refunds a lot of the assets listed on the balance sheet go away.

I know a lot of people who reserved their model-3 paying the deposit. Pretty much they all know that their deliveries are going to be delayed but still put up the deposit. They just don't want to cancel their reservation and lose their spot as long as they get their car.

I think once Tesla's battery problems are resolved and start delivering the model-3s, they should see the cash flowing.

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by dalbasal on Monday November 27, 2017 @07:23AM (#15786772)
You're right, but (IMO) only looking at half of the whole.

Tesla is spending a lot. More than they earn. Whatever back-of-the-envelope profitability model you attribute to their car making operation to differentiate marginal-operational from capital-investment costs, it does not add up to anything like enough to cover all costs. They cannot cover costs from free cash (as you say) which means they need capital coming in (as you say), debt and equity.

But, this doesn't mean they are selling elonmagic. No one would expect a car company to bootstrap, grow from cash flow. The place they expect to be is cash-hungry. This is what accountants are for, figuring out if a company is headed towards profitability when free cash flow is not an indicator.

The whole idea is that Tesla will be gradually capitalized to the point where it is like GM or Toyota.

Where elonmagic does come in is the same place startup-magic always comes in. It's novel in the auto industry. But, it's bread and butter on crunchbase (or here).

Does this company have the potential to create a large, high margin business. The accountant will have a harder time telling you this, and so will annual report readers. It's like answering the question Will Facebook manage to build an advertising business like Goog's? The answer turned out to be yes, so FB is worth a lot of money. Valuation of FB at IPO time was essentially the aggregate investor's answer to that question at that time.

Elonmagigic plays a big role in that 2nd part, unavoidably. This seems reasonable and to me.

Accounts are accounts. Sometimes the story is simple, and accoutns tell a simple story. Sometimes the real story is there, but takes context, digging and smart accountants to tell properly. Some important parts of the story are not in the accounts, like the fact the Tesla can apparently produce a faster supercar than anyone at 1/4 of the cost.

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by DennisP on Monday November 27, 2017 @08:08AM (#15786974)
Most of the new financing is debt, which I referred to above. The new equity is only $472M for the first nine months of this year.

Their operating loss over the same period is $570M. As I also said, most of what they're spending is capital expenditure, amounting to about $3B.

I.e. the basic story here is simple: they're borrowing a bunch of money to build new factories, which is exactly what you would expect a new car company to do.

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by kgwgk on Monday November 27, 2017 @08:22AM (#15787069)
To be fair, Amazon issues shares to give to employees. The dilution is not huge but it’s real and helps to keep cash-flows positive and make the company look more profitable than it is.
Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by aerovistae on Sunday November 26, 2017 @09:40PM (#15784436)
Yeah, because they didn't have to build out factories and 500,000 cars in order to grow.

If they did, they would have tapped the markets too.

Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by krschultz on Sunday November 26, 2017 @11:02PM (#15784726)
That's a complete misreading of Amazon. Their entire competitive advantage is having really cheap capital which enables unbelievable capital investment. First it was in distribution centers (3PL), then servers (AWS), and next likely be parcel delivery (look out FedEx). The e-commerce business is the first and best customer of each of these services, but they're basically a conglomerate of capital intensive low margin infrastructure services.
Re:The purpose of Tesla is not to make money by IBM on Sunday November 26, 2017 @09:45PM (#15784459)
Amazon's "factories" were fulfillment centers, data centers, and free shipping. All of which were extremely expensive.