I'm not going to necessarily make the argument that Tesla's share price is rational, but I do think this spending is good for shareholders. The balance sheet equity is a pittance compared to market cap. People are betting on large future profits. And there is just no way the level of production they are currently at could earn enough to justify the price. They have to grow. To grow they have to invest. It's just the nature of the business they are in. I think being in tech gives people the idea that you can create enormous value without capital risk, but that just isn't reality in most of the physical world. I think they are at least being responsible about it. They went out and established there was substantial interest for the 3 prior to undertaking all of this - something Ford didn't do for the Edsel, which in terms of financial sins would be on par with this failing.
To get back to the initial point here, I do think the amount of debt they are using might be a bit on the high side if you consider their current and not future revenue, but the capital markets have shown a huge willingness to stomach secondary offerings of the stock, so it seems like they can and probably will remedy that.
It's pretty obvious that current losses like these could easily overcome a decade-plus of future profits. Their debt is already rated a junk bond, so they aren't going to get any good deals on future debt. At some point, you would think, surely rationality will set in. I mean, Tesla is not the only EV manufacture in the world. Wouldn't it make more sense to invest in another car company that is also making EVs, and have finances that look much more appealing? Why would anyone subsidize a company just to produce a product that others can easily replicate? At some point, this has to stop.
Because you, and I think a lot of people, think Tesla is a car company. It's not; Tesla is becoming a battery company and a charging station company. That will make them as big as gas companies, because everyone will be needing both batteries and electricity, even if they need to offload their car business. Tesla will be far bigger than just cars for decades to come, and I think that's where a large part of shareholder trust is coming from.
I mean how many other EV charging networks are active?
Tesla's cash flow from investment was -$1.21B last quarter alone. I can scarcely think of a startup that consumed cash at this rate. That's an annualized rate of -$4.84B. Not even the pets.com or Webvans of the world ever reached this level of "cash burn." Cash flow from operations were -$300.56M last quarter, and losses were $671.16M. Annualized, this puts them at around -$1.2B and -$2.68B per year respectively.
If this is due to excess headcount from unreleased products, I say that's crazy and they should stop attempting those unreleased products.