News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Some chip makers have hidden latency and jitter issues fr... by userbinator on Sunday November 26, 2017 @06:05PM (#15783613)
Does anyone here know why these modems even care about TCP/IP or ICMP or any other protocol higher than the network and physical layers? I could go read the DOCSIS spec in detail, but thought these operated at a similar layer to Ethernet (OSI layers 1 and 2.)
Re:Some chip makers have hidden latency and jitter issues fr... by rasz on Monday November 27, 2017 @02:33AM (#15785511)
They dont, This TLDR is wrong.

Puma 5 shipped with just enough resources for 8 downstream channels. Puma 6 has same resources, but 16 downstream channels. Bottleneck is in hardware accelerating packet decoding/assembly, queue/buffer is too shallow and more packets in flight result in stalls. You can disable this hardware block and magically modem stops being susceptible to DOS, but max throughput goes down to ~60Mbit (opposed to theoretical ~800Mbit with ~2Mbit DOS potential)

There are people with Puma 6 with ISP using only 6 downstream channels and their modems work just great. 8 is barely acceptable (even puma 5 has problems on the test and can be DOSed by ~10Mbit), 16 is just plan broken.

Re:Some chip makers have hidden latency and jitter issues fr... by nalllar on Monday November 27, 2017 @07:34AM (#15786820)
DOCSIS "modems" are layer 3 devices as well actually.

The DOCSIS standard requires filtering by IP address and port [1] built in to the modem, instead of at the CMTS. This is back-asswards, as a hacked modem can ignore the filtering, but it's part of the spec.

There are multiple sources of jitter in the puma 6/5: more channels = more jitter, more flows = more jitter/complete failure at ~2000 separate active flows in a 1 second period.

[1]: http://www.cable-europe.eu/wp-content/uploads/bsk-pdf-manage... - Annex F Protocol Filtering (Normative)

Re:Some chip makers have hidden latency and jitter issues fr... by user5994461 on Monday November 27, 2017 @08:30AM (#15787116)
>>> Does anyone here know why these modems even care about TCP/IP or ICMP or any other protocol higher than the network and physical layers?

IP is the network layer. Can't route packets without it.

Re:Some chip makers have hidden latency and jitter issues fr... by gricardo99 on Sunday November 26, 2017 @11:33PM (#15784851)
Most modern networking chips for NICs implement TCP/IP checksum offload, sometimes segmentation/fragmentation offload/reassembly
Re:Some chip makers have hidden latency and jitter issues fr... by revelation on Sunday November 26, 2017 @09:35PM (#15784423)
Maybe it does NAT in hardware.