News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by tptacek on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:27PM (#1576624)
When you call those prosecuting the US/NATO side of the conflict in Afghanistan "murderers", you run the risk of implicitly taking the side of US/NATO's adversaries, who in this case are the Taliban.

Here's what I'm wondering: when did it become fashionable to stick up for the Taliban? The Taliban aren't the Sandinistas. The Taliban aren't the North Vietnamese Army. They aren't even Hezbollah.

It is conceivable --- even directly observable --- that countries can survive and thrive led by any of those movements, however much we may disagree with their politics and practices and the mechanisms they used to take power. Say what you will about Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, but women can go to medical school in Iran and (presumably) Lebanon.

I've read a little bit about the history of Afghanistan leading up to the Taliban. I know it was a disaster, and I know the Taliban took root in part because they managed to impose some semblance of order over a country governed essentially by banditry. But as near as I can tell, the Taliban is objectively evil. Apart from consolidating the warlordism in Afghanistan, what possible virtue can there be to defending them?

Outing innocent informants and getting them killed --- which I know hasn't been reported to have happened yet --- is bad no matter where it happens. But I don't have much of a moral qualm about directly opposing, say, the Iraq war. But I don't understand how you can construct a worldview that permits you to cheer on something that assists Gulbuddin Hekmatyar, who may be the closest thing the Earth has to an actual comic book supervillain.

There's a lot of secrecy and dissembling and corruption in the world. You have to choose your battles. Wikileaks chose a really crappy one this time.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by rbanffy on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:49PM (#1576694)
> When you call those prosecuting the US/NATO side of the conflict in Afghanistan "murderers", you run the risk of implicitly taking the side of US/NATO's adversaries, who in this case are the Taliban.

Nice strawman. Calling the folks who recklessly fire on civilians murderers may be a bit exaggerated. Human error happens and human error when the human is on the trigger of a 30 mm cannon is usually disastrous, but automatically siding those who propose a less reckless fight with the Taleban is a flaw of logic.

When you are in position of using lethal force, you must use it responsibly, with great care.

Also, removing the Taleban from power in Afghanistan was necessary, but empowering corrupt local powers is, most definitely, not the best way to employ the resources consumed in this invasion. People die in wars and we owe them to make wars short, clean and effective, so that no more people need to die other than absolutely necessary.

This whole situation is appalling. It reeks incompetency and corruption from top to bottom. It's unworthy of the high ideals that are, or, at the very least, should be, the core philosophy of the groups we authorize to use lethal force against our fellow humans.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by tptacek on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:59PM (#1576734)
People who recklessly fire on civilians are murderers and should be tried as such. Commanders who issue orders that make ignore forseeable events like that should be held criminally responsible.

Corruption should be eliminated.

Corrupt local replacements for the Taliban should be thwarted.

Incompetancy is bad and should be rectified.

Now, all those things being true, help me understand how it can be OK to arm the Taliban with lists of probable informants?

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by rbanffy on Thursday August 05, 2010 @07:25AM (#1577760)
And, BTW, do you have any hope recklessness, corruption and incompetency would be eliminated without being first exposed for what they are?

There is need for secrecy in war. But when this secrecy becomes a shield to protect those who should not be fighting (or commanding) it, for they are reckless, corrupt and incompetent, it's time to end it.

I am not for the indiscriminate release of information, but there has to be a middle-ground and organizations like Wikileaks provide it.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by vegai on Thursday August 05, 2010 @01:25AM (#1577300)
How do you do the four things you listed if all information is contained?
Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by rbanffy on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @09:07PM (#1576757)
When you know the identity of your informants was compromised, you should remove them from the field immediately. If you don't, it's at least 50% your fault when they get killed.

Keep in mind the US government knew what documents would be leaked before the Taleban could get access to them.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by tptacek on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @09:11PM (#1576775)
OK. It's 50% the US's fault if people get killed. What's your point? Note well: people are likely to be killed who aren't actually informants. Death squads don't do due process.
Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by Ardit20 on Thursday August 05, 2010 @02:49AM (#1577414)
His point is that perhaps the anger should be directed not towards the messenger, but towards the one who has the power, that is the government, for not taking up on their offer.
Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by elblanco on Thursday August 05, 2010 @12:09AM (#1577184)
> When you know the identity of your informants was compromised, you should remove them from the field immediately.

I sure hope you have enough space for the huddled masses of Afghanistan in your house since an awful lot of them are "informants".

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by rbanffy on Thursday August 05, 2010 @07:45AM (#1577797)
If you can't protect you informants, don't have them.
Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by elblanco on Thursday August 05, 2010 @10:21AM (#1578114)
I guess we could just conduct WWII style carpet bombings against civilian population centers instead. Or do you not understand the purpose of using informants?
Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by rbanffy on Thursday August 05, 2010 @02:04PM (#1578784)
I do. I also know that a handler has responsibilities towards them.

And that's why the handler should never disclose personal data on the informant. If you can't trust the analysts down your chain, you can't protect your sources and, ultimately, yourself.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by elblanco on Thursday August 05, 2010 @10:46PM (#1580041)
Since you've brought up handlers, I now know that you actually do not understand how informants work.
Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by kemiller on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @09:10PM (#1576769)
I wonder which clean, efficient war we should compare it to.
Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by rbanffy on Thursday August 05, 2010 @07:22AM (#1577753)
I believe it was not fought yet. Nevertheless, you (I am not American, or better, I am European, born in South-America) owe everyone that gets killed in the wars you fight that, at the very least, their sacrifice is not in vain. And you owe that to both sides.

The fact the other side won't honor this ideals is what separates you from them.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by mcantelon on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:39PM (#1576659)
>Here's what I'm wondering: when did it become fashionable to stick up for the Taliban?

When there are two groups of killers involved in a conflict recognizing the killing of one group doesn't mean one is excusing the killing of the other group.

If you are familiar with the history of the Taliban you are likely aware of the role the US played in their rise to power (http://nyti.ms/ddOTcu). The Taliban would likely not exist without the support of the US. The US didn't nurture the Taliban for the good of the people nor are they attempting to control Afghanistan for the good of the people.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by tptacek on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:43PM (#1576670)
I don't understand why it matters that the US helped bring the Taliban to power. Help me understand why our culpability in the rise of the Taliban doesn't make us more obligated to eradicate them.

Please understand, I think that this article we're all commenting on is all the way at the crazytown other end of the spectrum on this issue. The notion that the US should be allowed to kidnap people in friendly countries and haul them back to the US for military trials is also repellent.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by mcantelon on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:55PM (#1576721)
>Help me understand why our culpability in the rise of the Taliban doesn't make us more obligated to eradicate them.

If I could believe that eradicating the abuses of the Taliban is in some way part of the mission I might agree, but I fail to see any reason to believe that whatever regime the US installs post-Taliban will be any different.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by rbanffy on Thursday August 05, 2010 @07:59AM (#1577833)
> I don't understand why it matters that the US helped bring the Taliban to power.

For one, I think they would be better off had the Soviet Union succeeded invading it. They would have some industry, mining operation, separation between religion and state and so on. It's not like the Taleban ever were "freedom fighters".

The Soviet Union would get rid of the Taleban for free.

It's, in fact, the kind of poor judgment that minimized the threat the Taleban presented and made it worth to defeat the soviets by any means possible that worries me. Had the Taleban been properly groomed and supported (and "westernized") after driving the Soviets out, the world would be a far better place now.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by tptacek on Thursday August 05, 2010 @08:03PM (#1579755)
My understanding: it's largely a myth that the Taliban is the direct creation of the US government.

The Taliban are themselves a direct and overt reaction to the warlordism and banditry that followed the Communist puppet regime in Afghanistan. They were formed to remove the status quo that American support for the Mujahideen created.

I understand some of the power politics involved in, for instance, disfavoring Massoud and arming Hekmatyar and how decisions (and, more importantly, negligence) in handling that stuff hurt the west in the long run. Still, though.

It's a drastic oversimplification to say that the US created the Taliban.

It also seems pretty irresponsible to suggest that the world would have been better off if the Soviets had succeeded in surpressing Afghanistan. It very well might have been worse.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by indrax on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:43PM (#1576989)
Murderers can kill bad guys too.

Calling someone a murder means you assert that they have murdered.

Don't make a leap of logic and then try to tell other people what they 'risk implicitly' doing.

The fact that you took this nonsense as far as you did makes me wonder whether you have some emotional need to justify these murderers, or if it's just part of your job.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by earl on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @09:17PM (#1576795)
Please. Calling soldiers shooting children murderers doesn't mean I like the Taliban, it means I don't want our soldiers murdering children. Really, this isn't complicated.

The Taliban might have been evil, but it doesn't mean that the replacements will be any better. As near as anybody who isn't a jackass can tell, the US has inserted ourselves into a pair of century (millenia?) long sectarian conflicts. Government barely exists 100 miles from the Kabul. These warlords were fighting each other before the Taliban, somewhat subjugated by the Taliban, and will be fighting each other again after we finally leave. All we've done is inflicted horrendous collateral damage on whoever happened to get in our way while mouthing trite bullshit about democracy. In order to leave the citizens of the country in a position that will be, at best, no better than under the Taliban. And probably much worse. We've killed how many in order to install some thug and his drug / warlord brother atop the heap?

As for Wikileaks, after Bush decided to run black prisons and endorsed the torture at Abu Ghraib, I frankly stopped believing anything out government says. Obama, with his support of the Afghanistan war and Bush era spy laws, has more or less endorsed Bush' view of civil liberties and demonstrated that the US government is worth the trust of exactly nobody. I'll believe what the government says when Bush is executed for war crimes, and there are a long line of US Generals up there with him. In light of those facts, Wikileaks is a force for good. Since we've demonstrated that morality and probability of success have no impact on our decisions, perhaps Wikileaks can damage the war effort enough to get us out of Afghanistan. Frankly, the less Americans trust their government, the better.

Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by tptacek on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @09:25PM (#1576812)
You're right. Calling people who shoot children murderers doesn't make you a supporter of the Taliban.
Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by Ardit20 on Thursday August 05, 2010 @02:47AM (#1577409)
What on earth were you saying then?
Re:Wikileaks Must Be Stopped by tptacek on Thursday August 05, 2010 @07:55PM (#1579739)
That one should be careful not to defend the Taliban, who unlike the NVA or Sandinistas have no legitimacy and are objectively evil. That giving material support to the Taliban is something to be avoided, not cheered on.

As a greater stretch, I also object to the notion that the conflict in Afghanistan is illegitimate. I've no doubt that it's been prosecuted badly, and to the extent that "badly" involves corruption and murder of innocents --- while I might not be happy to see this happen --- I can understand the moral calculus behind leaking information about criminal activity in the conflict.

But opposing the conflict for it's own sake, because "it's not about defense", strikes me as dangerously close to tacit support for the Taliban.