News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by saulrh on Thursday November 23, 2017 @12:11AM (#15762941)
> But this is ignoring the whole debate: proponents of net freedom don't consider fast lanes to be a problem.

I think that this is the part that I can't comprehend. The railroads misbehaved so badly that the government had to break rail transportation as an industry to kill them. Ninety years later we're still using long-haul semi trailers for everything. Bell's abuse of its monopoly was similarly severe. How do people hold this belief without becoming laughingstock?

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by ghaff on Thursday November 23, 2017 @12:35AM (#15763034)
>Ninety years later we're still using long-haul semi trailers for everything.

No. There's actually a very healthy cargo rail system and relatively little trucking is truly long haul.

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by saulrh on Thursday November 23, 2017 @01:33AM (#15763247)
According to the DOT [1] it looks like my intuition is a bit out of date. Right now US freight about even, trucking still a little bit ahead by ton-mile. Ten years ago rail carried 2/3 as much freight as trucks. Last-mile delivery on trucks (from the rail station to the point of use) is taken care of by the unit of measurement (one ton of freight traveling one mile), so I think that those numbers are relatively reasonable.

So I'll admit: fair enough, the rail industry is still healthy and carrying a good amount of cargo. I'll withdraw the wording; we do not in fact use long-haul trucks for everything. The fact that trucks are competing with rail at all, however, given the geographical extent of the US and how horrible long-haul trucking is, I believe makes me stand by my claim that the US rail industry was broken and never recovered. It frankly astonishes me that driving something down the highway is even remotely financially effective in comparison to rail freight.

And, of course, none of this is relevant to my original point: the railroads abused their powers to an astonishing degree and the government was forced to smash them for the good of the economy. Is it obvious to me that today's ISPs are following in the footsteps of yesterday's railroads and telephones and I don't understand how people convince themselves otherwise.

[1] https://www.rita.dot.gov/bts/sites/rita.dot.gov.bts/files/pu...

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by thinkloop on Thursday November 23, 2017 @03:20AM (#15763663)
It's wasn't obvious to me that trucking is much less energy effecient than rail. According to treehugger.com rail achieves "400 ton-miles per gallon whereas trucks currently hover around 130 ton-miles per gallon" [1]. I wonder why that would be - rubber tires vs steel-on-steel? Traffic? There isn't much traffic during the majority of a long-haul and the last few miles have to be done by truck anyway.

[1] https://www.treehugger.com/cars/rail-versus-trucking-whos-th...

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by hirsin on Thursday November 23, 2017 @03:56AM (#15763824)
Braking and acceleration - once you get x tons of anything moving, it generally wants to keep moving. Trains are tens of times longer than trucks, brake significantly less often, and have a lot more horsepower for acceleration.
Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by pwg on Thursday November 23, 2017 @08:36AM (#15764936)
Lowered overall wind resistance also plays a significant part.

With Semi's, each separate truck has to endure its own wind resistance independently.

With a train, each rail car effectively drafts the car in front, producing significant reductions in wind resistance for all cars behind the locomotive.

This site (https://www.energy.gov/eere/vehicles/parasitic-loss-reductio...) quotes wind resistance, braking, and rolling resistance as responsible for a 45% reduction in efficiency.

This site (https://www.nap.edu/read/13288/chapter/7) has a table that separates the factors out. Of the parasitic losses, aerodynamic losses (i.e., wind resistance) is responsible for consuming 53% of the motive power.

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by int_19h on Thursday November 23, 2017 @05:30AM (#15764170)
The other thing is, you can string wires along the rails relatively easily, and power everything directly with electricity - which offers substantial savings from efficiency of large scale power generation, even accounting for distribution losses. Better yet, you can then use regenerative braking, and feed energy back into the line.

I do believe there's some benefit from the tracks themselves as well, though. Surely there's a lot less friction (per ton of weight) between the train wheels and steel rails, than there is between truck tires and the road?

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by libertyEQ on Friday November 24, 2017 @04:40AM (#15770299)
>you can string wires along the rails relatively easily, and power everything directly with electricity -

Except all freight trains in the US have 6600 HP diesel engines, usually ~6-8 engines per 100 cars from what I've seen (which is mostly coal).

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by int_19h on Friday November 24, 2017 @06:51AM (#15770610)
US is an outlier in that regard. In other developed countries, railroads are mostly electrified.
Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by em3rgent0rdr on Thursday November 23, 2017 @05:39AM (#15764206)
I'd also say increased engine efficiency resulting from being able to have a bigger engine to move more tons.
Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by emiliobumachar on Thursday November 23, 2017 @07:30AM (#15764590)
A small part of it is air resistance. A train has a lot less frontal area per ton.
Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by transposed on Thursday November 23, 2017 @12:39AM (#15763061)
I don't think that many people actually do hold this belief. That's why someone had to make a bot to create the illusion.
Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by rtpg on Thursday November 23, 2017 @01:57AM (#15763333)
A bunch of the GOP seems to hold this belief. If there wasn't such a strong movement for net neutrality, I bet a bunch of Democrats would like this as well.

I understand there are a lot of lobbyists, but there are many people who sincerely believe the "less regulation and more competition will solve the issues" mantra.

I place a lot of the blame on outlets like the Wall Street Journal giving credence to arguments that strip out all context and use fancy words to justify these positions. Doesn't help that other people are afraid to call out their lies because they came from the same social circles.

Yes, the "free market + competition makes things cheaper" argument works well when you remove all the reasons why a specific case does not fit the theory perfectly.

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by jinfiesto on Thursday November 23, 2017 @04:31AM (#15763941)
I'm pretty liberal, and I believe that there is some truth to the "less regulation and more competition will solve the issues" mantra. The issue here being that there isn't a real way to inject more competition into the ISP space. Soooo, we are just getting less regulation. Which will inevitably lead to abuses.
Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by Fnoord on Thursday November 23, 2017 @05:47AM (#15764239)
If the government owned the infrastructure, would be held accountable to maintain it, and would provide access to different ISPs there would be more competition. The problem is that some people see this is "regulation" or "socialism" or "lack of choice" while others see this as "healthy competition" and "liberty".

If there's just one infrastructure, or maybe two (cable and DSL) and the ISPs own it then there's barely any competition. That's when you get anti-competitive behaviour.

Such behaviour would be punished in a free market even if it were allowed. But we don't have a free market in this segment. We got monopolies and duopolies.

There are different ways to limit the power of monopolies and duopolies. One is legislation to force them to treat all data equal. Another one could be to break up the large mammoths who are monopolies and duopolies. The latter ain't happening, so why revert the former?

Either due to sheer stupidity or because of heavy lobbying from certain interest groups who'd profit greatly from this (ISPs is my guess).

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by throwanem on Thursday November 23, 2017 @01:20PM (#15766863)
> If the government owned the infrastructure, would be held accountable to maintain it, and would provide access to different ISPs

Yeah last time we tried this we got Amtrak so I don't really see it as a workable solution. Size limits and market choice requirements might work, though. They did, pretty well, with media companies, for quite a long time.

Of course, those also only last until we get an FCC that's either so corrupt it'd be right at home in the Gilded Age, or so out of touch it'd be right at home in Versailles. I tend to the latter suspicion, myself; DC people are long known in general to make a habit of thinking of 495 more or less as the end of the civilized world, beyond which lies only a terrifying wasteland full of barbarians and howling ghosts. That's why lobbyists exist - just as in Versailles, there's a market for paying people to present one's case and pray intercession on one's behalf at court. I suppose we'll see whose lobbyists pray most effectively this time. And next time, and the time after that, and...

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by QAkICoU7IDNkpFu on Thursday November 23, 2017 @05:09AM (#15764095)
Break up the biggest ISP's by force.
Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by vidarh on Thursday November 23, 2017 @10:20AM (#15765524)
Or properly regulate local loop unbundling and force cost+ resale of access to subscriber lines.

E.g. the way it works in the UK (it works similarly, but not entirely identically, in all EU countries), which is absolutely not ideal but gives reasonable competition is that BT OpenReach (by virtue of BT's past monopoly) is regulated and is required to offer any ISP access to their network on equal basis. This means the ISPs have a few choices:

* They can put equipment in the exchanges, and "just" get access to a raw connection to the subscriber. OpenReach maintains the lines.

* They can contract OpenReach for "backhaul" of IP traffic to central locations.

* They can build their own last mile network.

I can pick from dozens of providers because of that, but most of them mean I'll pay a basic line rental either directly to BT or via the provider, and that is the same for any of them. Others are free to build their own network without the same restrictions, but this for natural reasons happens very slowly (predominantly fibre providers in dense urban areas, and a cable provider).

In that model net neutrality is less of a concern. It's not entirely free of issues, as major ISPs certainly still could offer preferential access to certain content, but at least we have real competition beyond the last mile.

The biggest problem with this is that the way it is structured does not give BT a strong incentive to invest in improving the last mile network. I'd have preferred if there was an additional clause restricting them to only take out dividends from OpenReach proportional to the investments made in improving the network. But overall it's working reasonably well.

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by rtpg on Thursday November 23, 2017 @07:50AM (#15764669)
The biggest issue is that since this is a network the most cost effective thing is for there to be a single network.

Networks are a great example where a regulated monopoly on one level can allow for a healthy free market on the upper levels.

If you forget about the money, having a single operator makes the most sense. Thus we should model our economic system to take this into account

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by Endy on Thursday November 23, 2017 @07:46AM (#15764653)
We'd need another Teddy Roosevelt for that to happen. Unfortunately, we have Trump. And frankly I don't see politics changing from that mindset for a long time.
Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by Brybry on Thursday November 23, 2017 @08:38AM (#15764949)
The Ma Bell breakup was probably started under Nixon/Ford (lawsuit filed in 1974) and finished under Reagan.

Not that it worked completely, because everyone has nearly merged back together, but it is evidence that Republican administrations aren't necessarily pro-monopoly.

A large part of the issue is that, through lobbying and franchise agreements, ISPs have locally secured their status. Even if you break them up they only become more local monopolies (which is better but not competition and still requires regulation).

Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality by thinkloop on Thursday November 23, 2017 @03:51AM (#15763805)
It's tiring how the dialogue is still so ideological. Every single person agrees that there should be 1 or more regulation. We are just determining their precise character. I wish public discussion would become more nuanced and specific to the issue at hand.