This is great. You can make any model say anything you want by tuning the parameters, so we needs researchers to stop forcing their preferred parameters, and let consumers check the robustness of the conclusions against ranges of parameters
> if somebody you loved was killed by a self-driving car, would you be comforted in knowing that the technology was in aggregate saving the lives of other people?
and if somebody you loved was killed by a human-driven car, would you be comforted in knowing that the technology was in aggregate was being held back for further testing?
with a handful of centralized systems responsible for every accident everyone will be permanently panicked and outraged at its purportedly uncaring, greedy overlords.
> if somebody you loved was killed by a human-driven car, would you be comforted in knowing that the technology was in aggregate was being held back for further testing?
counterfactuals need to be near and specific for people to give them much thought, see:
http://www2.psych.ubc.ca/~schaller/Psyc590Readings/Roese1997...
http://www3.canyons.edu/faculty/rafterm/0%200LLI%20LOVEandLO...
See, this is the main reason why AVs are great: accidents are caused by speeders, drunk, tired, inexperienced drivers, morons driving while high on pot or ecstasy, that is, those who are MUCH worse than an average driver used as a yardstick to measure the performance of the autonomous cars.
Replace them by an imperfect machine lacking common sense, and the overall driving skill still goes up.
Not the entire world is America. Oftentimes "want" is replaced by "forced".
We already have analogous situations with things like airbags. Airbags unarguably save lives, and yet they've also unarguably killed kids.
Self-driving cars preform predictably under a set of conditions. The primary problem arises when the car, for whatever reason, doesn't correctly detect that it's in an unfamiliar condition and continues moving as normal. Humans are intelligent enough to notice when something is "off".
For a machine as heavy, large, fast, and close as a car, limited intelligence is not enough.
That being said, RAND released a study this month, targeted at policymakers, that models how many human lives would be saved given the introduction of non-perfect autonomous vehicles, including a little javascript widget to try out various settings: https://www.rand.org/blog/articles/2017/11/why-waiting-for-p...
Crucially, this study models scenarios such as AVs being _half_ as safe as human drivers, yet still resulting in saving more lives over time. I think the question then becomes, who will be responsible for the missing 50% of safety when somebody gets killed by one?
Edit: Another question: if somebody you loved was killed by a self-driving car, would you be comforted in knowing that the technology was in aggregate saving the lives of other people? I have no answers to these questions... it's a hard problem.