Re:Depression-era color photos
by biggitybones on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @05:02PM
(#1575878)
I agree - although I view it a bit different. I always feel a disconnect with black and white photos, as if it's something that happened centuries ago or not at all. These photos somehow make it feel more "real".
Oh dear. There are black-and-white photos of my childhood. I didn't think I was that old -- until now!
My dad always took black and white photos, even through the 90s. So I suppose you're not.
Same happened to me when german TV once showed a couple of the few WW2 video recordings in color.
Are they more cheerful for being in colour? The effect on me is to deepen my empathy, so they leave me a bit sadder, actually.
I also look at #9 and thank my stars that I am culturally allowed to do manual work in jeans and boots.
The dirt is definately more noticable -- I am just depressed at how dirty things are in those pictures. Of course, it isn't really any cleaner in rural/industrial settings today...
It did not appear that the man work worked in the carbon plant had the benefit of a respirator -- at least the dirt patterns on his face didn't show any signs of a nose/mouth covering. Imagine how many government regulations this same factory would be in violation of today.
Re:Depression-era color photos
by peterwwillis on Thursday August 05, 2010 @11:17AM
(#1578299)
A lot of those same workers today don't use nose/mouth coverings (save for a bandanna). The rural poor continue to sacrifice for the urban well-off.
My (admittedly nonsensical) reaction to the first photo:
Wait -- you mean they had sunlight during the depression?!
I wonder if our grandchildren will view our still, color photos the same way. Life was so drab and depressing before motion & 3D!