News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by enjo on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @01:18PM (#1575063)
Teach a man to fish....

I'd MUCH rather that they pledge to donating half of their wealth to economic development. We are in desperate need of investment capital here at home. Wouldn't that $600B be better spent investing in alternative-energy and other high growth fields?

We've given these folks huge tax breaks with the idea that they'd reinvest that money in our economy. The article is somewhat light on details about where this money ultimately ends up, but I firmly believe that it's best spent helping tomorrows billionaires (all over the world) get their start.

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by MartinCron on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @02:06PM (#1575250)
A lot of what modern relief organizations are doing these days is called "capacity building", where instead of just airlifting American doctors into Haiti to bandage up the injured on a short-term basis, they work on creating more and better Haitian doctors.

The Gates Foundation, for example, has a strong focus on education, which is all about "teaching boys and girls to fish" and is really a prerequisite to a strong economy.

There has been some good coverage of this angle from This American Life(PRI) and Planet Money (NPR). Example: http://www.realmedicineblog.com/2010/05/29/haiti-this-americ...

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by electromagnetic on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:18PM (#1576424)
I'd like to see this money used to establish a scholarship program for struggling countries. The first wave of students is brought to the US, Canada, UK, France, Japan, etc. and taught a range of subjects with a mandatory teaching course added on, the only contingency is that they return to their own (or another underdeveloped country) and remain there for a minimum duration of X years so we're not just adding a new migration path. The second wave (in say 5 years) is an in-country scholarship where this new generation can be taught by the first wave (remember 1 student /= 1 teacher, however you don't need 1 teacher to teach 1 student), those that didn't become teachers will likely be establishing businesses or supporting their local economy.

A significant portion of the scholarships should also be going to fund apprenticeships to get people certified as competent electricians, plumbers, brick layers, mechanics, etc. There's no point putting someone through university if there's going to be no one around to help build a university in their country, or their business office, etc.

One of the struggling points of our own economies is that we're vastly short handed in the skilled trades to the point that many countries (Australia) basically hands out citizenships to people with these skills. It would be asinine to play economics and screw up right off the bat. We need to educate in controlled proportions from the top and to the bottom of our own skill ladders.

I know people who are incredibly smart who can't use a hammer. Who would build their house, repair their roof, reside their property, replace their windows, etc. We're talking about regions with a high proportion of natural disasters, and they'd need a good supply of skilled workers to ensure a tragedy like Haiti doesn't happen because buildings aren't constructed to modern codes.

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by muriithi on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:50PM (#1576512)
Here in Kenya there was such a program in the 60's and was known as the "Kennedy Airlift".One of the earliest beneficiaries was Barrack Obama's dad. The other notable beneficiary was the 2004 Nobel Peace Prize winner Prof. Wangari Maathai. The program seems to have petered out after the end of the cold war.

Many of those whose studied under the program came back to Kenya when the country needed them most.

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by sfg on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @01:31PM (#1575108)
"commit to giving the majority of their wealth to the philanthropic causes and charitable organizations of their choice"

Would that not include non-profit research into the areas you outlined?

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by hbt on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @01:50PM (#1575190)
Interesting point.

Is money better spent feeding/clothing a bunch of Africans and preventing aids _or_ on research, bio-engineering, space/ocean exploration, education etc. here at home?

Which one is short term and which one is long term?

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by muriithi on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:40PM (#1576483)
As a Kenyan who falls under the OP's definition of "a bunch of Africans" I do not want American philanthropy to "feed or cloth" Africa.

Most African economies are agricultural and it is therefore alarming that the EU uses 40% of it's budget(about 48B Euros annually) on agricultural subsidies. The US uses about $20B every year on the same.Ending these subsidies would enable Africa to export more, buy more products from the US and Europe as well as form the basis for industrialization.

We need more trade and less aid. Is that asking for too much?

More info;

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agricultural_subsidy

http://www.downsizinggovernment.org/agriculture/subsidies

http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1978963,00.ht...

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by hbt on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @11:52PM (#1577142)
I didn't mean any disrespect.

Although I'm not in a position to give away large sums of money, I don't believe in _just_ investing in people.

Investing in their economy, industry etc. makes more sense in the long term than investing in food/water and short term solutions.

Of course, It is very easy to talk about this sitting on my couch with a full stomach.

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by sesqu on Thursday August 05, 2010 @08:29PM (#1579813)
Farm subsidies are a serious inefficiency, yes. But I can't help feeling that getting rid of them would be worse, because they're there partly for the same reason many other inefficiencies exist: risk mitigation.

Nobody wants to put all their eggs in one basket, especially if it's someone else's basket. And from what I hear of high-yield food production, the good baskets all have problems down the line. Meat has disease and animal rights activists, fish has chemical pollution and overharvesting, fruit has pollination and insecticide issues, grain has crop rotation neglect and nutritional deficiencies.

Add to that the issues global trade is facing, such as rising fuel costs, treat of piracy, troublesome weather, looming threat of magnetosphere and solar interference, and politicians, and you can understand why I'd be reluctant to designate Africa as the world's breadbasket. Perhaps I've just watched too much TV, but food is one of the last things I want outsourced.

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by 1053r on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:54PM (#1576523)
This sounds great in principal, and ending American and European food subsidies would be great for Africa. Additionally, food subsidies distort the market by, for example, making corn syrup cheaper than sugar in the US.

The problem is that many Americans (I don't know as much about Europe) aren't actually that wealthy. Without food subsidies, our food quality would probably increase, but so would our costs. Poor Americans are overweight today because the distorted food costs make it cheaper to eat processed food (that is more expensive to make overall) than to eat basic fruits and veggies and grains. Without subsidies, they would be starving, or at least calorie deficient.

Nixon put in our current system of subsidies because "food should never be an issue in a presidential race". And since then, it hasn't. America may be wealthy, but the wealth is very unevenly distributed. Without social programs, many of our people would be starving as well.

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by muriithi on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:19PM (#1576943)
I respectfully disagree. The same prophesies of doom were advanced when in 1984 New Zealand's Labor government took the dramatic step of ending all farm subsidies.

Productivity and efficiency have increased much faster than when subsidies were in place.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/from_our_own_correspon...

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/02/business/worldbusiness/02f...

http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=3411

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by heresy on Thursday August 05, 2010 @05:46AM (#1577627)
And one result of those subsidies being cut is the US erecting trade barriers to protect US dairy farmers from the now hyper-competitive NZ dairy farmers.
Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by timknauf on Thursday August 05, 2010 @06:05AM (#1577651)
Yes, from my (New Zealand, although not a farmer) point of view I'd say the ending of farm subsidies has been hugely beneficial to NZ's economy.
Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by Ardit20 on Thursday August 05, 2010 @12:10PM (#1578460)
Wouldn't you just export the food from Africa where you probably can buy a banana with 10 pence.
Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by riffraff on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @02:45PM (#1575397)
is a bunch of money better spent investing in US or creating stronger economies that can actually buy what is produced there? The post WWII marshall plan comes to mind.
Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by sandipagr on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @02:34PM (#1575358)
please educate me how is space/ocean exploration better than saving lives, even if its "bunch of Africans"
Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by ericb on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @04:51PM (#1575840)
Ok, I'm not the original poster, but here goes.

The continued existence of the entire human race may depend on space exploration and subsequent colonization. One comet or black-swan type disaster could wipe out humanity as a whole. This is not without precedent (dinosaurs).

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by gridspy on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:58PM (#1577018)
The ongoing space exploration efforts will also serve to inspire up and coming young scientists. Their efforts will help to advance technologies across the board.
Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by tmajor on Thursday August 05, 2010 @06:53PM (#1579604)
In response to this reply: Ok, I'm not the original poster, but here goes. The continued existence of the entire human race may depend on space exploration and subsequent colonization. One comet or black-swan type disaster could wipe out humanity as a whole. This is not without precedent (dinosaurs).

Each time we leave this planet we punch a whole in our ozone layer that can't be repaired! Some things were meant to be left alone. Simple education like teaching man to fish and read (not like our socialist education system here in America) will improve life and decerease deficits on this earth! Socialism is not the answer!

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by ericb on Thursday August 05, 2010 @11:37PM (#1580111)
> Each time we leave this planet we punch a whole in our ozone layer that can't be repaired!

Can you provide a source for the ozone whole claim? Where did I mention socialism?

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by ericb on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:03PM (#1582168)
Since you didn't cite a source, I looked it up. Not true:

http://www.nasa.gov/centers/kennedy/about/information/shuttl...

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by sandipagr on Thursday August 05, 2010 @07:09AM (#1577738)
I am sure you will be happy if Obama spent all tax dollars in making sure world doesn't end in 2012 (after all, it could wipe out humanity as a whole) than fixing health care, education and so forth. I am not against space exploration or anything, I just believe saving lives today is far more worthwhile than worrying about the black-swan type disaster that could happen.
Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by Setsuna on Thursday August 05, 2010 @05:16AM (#1577593)
Sounds straight out of science fiction, I'm not saying that this would never happen but personally I'd rather live in the present rather than be worrying about something that may never happen in the near future.
Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by MikeCapone on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @11:46PM (#1577131)
>Is money better spent feeding/clothing a bunch of Africans and preventing aids _or_ on research, bio-engineering, space/ocean exploration, education etc. here at home?

With that much money you can do both.

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by Setsuna on Thursday August 05, 2010 @05:12AM (#1577587)
>"feeding/clothing a bunch of Africans and preventing aids"

That's very harsh and insensitive. There are millions of people dying of hunger and all you care about is space exploration?

Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by iterationx on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @02:24PM (#1575332)
A lot Gates philanthropy goes to vaccines. http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article17644.html
Re:40 billionaires pledge to donate half their wealth by c1sc0 on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @03:26PM (#1575550)
Good!