News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to get enough protein without meat by brilee on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:06PM (#15736471)
Did anyone else find it bizarre that they quoted "grams of protein per ounce/cup" of food? America seems to have slowly adopted the metric system, but it's not what I expected to look like...
Re:How to get enough protein without meat by raarts on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:27PM (#15736559)
Per cup is weird, especially to the rest of the world, but what really is maddening to me is the 'serving'. Every food app is riddled with nutrients 'per serving' . Completely ridiculous. Servings differ greatly between brands, packages, countries.
Re:How to get enough protein without meat by geowwy on Sunday November 19, 2017 @08:10PM (#15737041)
> Per cup is weird, especially to the rest of the world

Cups are not weird, just just a pain in the arse because US cups are 240ml and metric cups are 250ml. If you're following a recipe that needs exact measurements it often trips you up.

Re:How to get enough protein without meat by tom_mellior on Monday November 20, 2017 @05:03AM (#15738899)
> Cups are not weird

Yes they are. For example, the article talks about "dark leafy greens (about 5 grams per cup)". Is that cups of dark leafy greens before chopping them up or after? If you specified the amout per weight, it would not make a difference. If you specify them by volume, it does.

Re:How to get enough protein without meat by analog31 on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:17PM (#15736511)
It does seem like an odd unit of measure, but might make sense in the following way: Most people don't know or care what a gram of protein looks like. What they might know is how much they're supposed to eat, in grams. And they know what a cup is. So they can do the mental math and estimate how many cups are needed to make up their daily requirement.

More generally, and anecdotally, I had a health scare that resulted in going through a fairly standardized regimen including exercise and dietary advice. I received many pamphlets and handouts! There seems to be a substantial effort to convey health advice in a way that downplays or minimizes any kind of math. People just freeze up when they see math.

This could give rise to an effort, from a public health perspective, to come up with units of measure that people can use without being put off by math.

Re:How to get enough protein without meat by neutronicus on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:34PM (#15736592)
Nutritional information here is always in grams, but recipes are almost uniformly in (cups / tablespoons / teaspoons).
Re:How to get enough protein without meat by careersuicide on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:18PM (#15736516)
It makes sense to me: when measuring stuff like you would in a lab use metric, when measuring stuff like you would in a kitchen use imperial. I think it only seems weird because we rarely do both in the same sentence.
Re:How to get enough protein without meat by joaomsa on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:18PM (#15736514)
My guess it's a convenience compromise. Nutrition labels list macro nutrient amounts in metric, but packaging still has the product amount more prominently in imperial measurements.
Re:How to get enough protein without meat by HarryHirsch on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:28PM (#15736562)
It's traditional - European cookbooks tend to use measures of weight, American cookbooks have measures of volume instead.

For the non-US-non-cooks: 1 cup = 240 ml ≈ 1/2 US pint

Re:How to get enough protein without meat by throwaway0255 on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:39PM (#15736609)
This drives me crazy. It’s ok if we’re talking about a liquid, I guess, but what is 1 cup of cheese? Or 1 cup of broccoli? 1 cup of walnuts?

Using volume for those, the amount you’re actually using can vary by a factor of 10 depending on how granular it is, how finely chopped or shredded it is, or how it fell that day.

I do everything in grams, but with some recipes and labels it’s just not possible to know how much of something it’s talking about. Which is unfortunate because that’s the entire purpose of a recipe or a label.

Why can’t we stop this?

Re:How to get enough protein without meat by kqr on Monday November 20, 2017 @02:13AM (#15738346)
> but what is 1 cup of cheese? Or 1 cup of broccoli? 1 cup of walnuts? ... depending on how granular it is, how finely chopped or shredded it is

Well, the recipe should give you an indication of granularity, although you won't get an ASTM number. That said, for cooking you're supposed to eyeball it a bit and judge through experience. Rarely does a little too much broccoli kill.

It sucks when it's a new dish or you are inexperienced -- but if you can't afford practise runs where the result is allowed to be sub-par, then it's probably a good idea to switch to a different source of recipes.

Re:How to get enough protein without meat by HarryHirsch on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:59PM (#15736696)
What's the void volume in a packing of spheres again? I seem to remember it's 74 %. You underestimate the weight by at most 25 %.

Broccoli is really an edge case. The traditional measuring cup for the kitchen (looks like this: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Messbecher.jpg) has more typical ingredients: semolina, raisins, flour, pearl barley, pulses & so on.

Re:How to get enough protein without meat by matthewaveryusa on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:25PM (#15736553)
It could be becuase there's a rule of thumb that says you need a gram of protein for every 3 lbs you weigh (or 1g for 2lbs if you're trying to build mass.)
Re:How to get enough protein without meat by walshemj on Sunday November 19, 2017 @07:29PM (#15736842)
grams per ounce is the really weird part
Re:How to get enough protein without meat by jabretti on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:13PM (#15736495)
I don't think it's so bad to mix metric and imperial units; I'm in favour of using whatever units keep the numbers readily comprehensible.

Grams of protein per ounce of food seems like a good example of this.