News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Argentina says signals detected, likely from missing subm... by narrator on Saturday November 18, 2017 @09:58PM (#15732014)
If you watched Elon's BFR Mars presentation, you'll notice that a lot of it depends on fully automated docking and piloting of all spacecraft. Manual control is just too dangerous and screw ups are catastrophically expensive in those situations.
Re:Argentina says signals detected, likely from missing subm... by jandrese on Saturday November 18, 2017 @10:46PM (#15732142)
It seems like an area where automated systems should be really good. We already have automated systems that an land planes without human intervention and that's a far more difficult problem.
Re:Argentina says signals detected, likely from missing subm... by lwansbrough on Sunday November 19, 2017 @02:30AM (#15732743)
And yet we don't because humans are immeasurably better at dealing with edge cases than any automated system. That being said, I do expect those systems developed by SpaceX to be automated. But I'd hesitate to call it "an area where automated systems should be really good."
Re:Argentina says signals detected, likely from missing subm... by jandrese on Monday November 20, 2017 @11:40AM (#15741165)
ISS hookups are still done by hand? Otherwise there aren't a lot of opportunities currently to do in-space docking. The lack of a solution could just be due to a lack of demand currently.
Re:Argentina says signals detected, likely from missing subm... by thelittleone on Sunday November 19, 2017 @04:32AM (#15733068)
Would there not be an equal or a greater number of edge cases for self driving cars?
Re:Argentina says signals detected, likely from missing subm... by lwansbrough on Sunday November 19, 2017 @05:47AM (#15733318)
Absolutely. Which is why I'd never trust my car to drive itself -- not for years anyway. Most testing and training I've seen from companies has been done in ideal conditions with "non-ideal" conditions being considered some sort of edge case? Maybe it's because all the self driving startups are operating in sunny California. What a nightmare a self driving car would be on uneven, icy, dark roads. I'm certain it would turn itself off and ask a human to drive then. And that'll be the case for a while. Or in cities in asia where rules of the road are more like suggestions, and driving is completely reactionary.

No, driverless cars today aren't ready for reality.

Re:Argentina says signals detected, likely from missing subm... by cc81 on Sunday November 19, 2017 @07:04AM (#15733542)
I think it will be a gradual change, both to gradually improve the technology and to get users used to it.

I drove the new Volvo V90 for a couple of weeks a while ago and it of course have the adaptive cruise control and those things you are used to these days but it also can drive itself similar to a Tesla autopilot.

At first it was a pretty weird feeling that the car controlled the steering wheel (you still need to hold it otherwise it will beep at you) but gradually I got used to it and started to trust it more and more. At least when driving on the highway and after a while it became a really nice feature to have.

Truly autonomous cars are of course far away and the problems with snow storms etc. also needs to be solved but I do think more and more car manufacturers will keep adding one feature after another until we suddenly are there. And at that point it won't be that big of a leap for us mentally.

Re:Argentina says signals detected, likely from missing subm... by awakeasleep on Saturday November 18, 2017 @10:54PM (#15732163)
I wonder what calculus decided automated systems built by humans are going to be better than humans themselves.

Obviously computers have a lot of advantages, and machines can be precise. But that only applies to certain domains, and I can't imagine anything that provides certainty about which.

Re:Argentina says signals detected, likely from missing subm... by irl_zebra on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:52PM (#15732328)
The same calculus that lets me deploy thousands of servers with terraform and puppet without a mistake. Sure there are problems, but you fix them once (in dev hopefully) and never have to worry about them again. Humans otoh have the potential to make the same mistakes over and over.
Re:Argentina says signals detected, likely from missing subm... by 7952 on Sunday November 19, 2017 @02:58AM (#15732828)
Computers can integrate data from numerous sources and sensors and respond very rapidly. Humans are optimised for a limited set of sensory inputs. When those senses can be utilized a person can be ridiculously effective. But space ships do not readily conform to this.
Re:Argentina says signals detected, likely from missing subm... by bryondowd on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:39PM (#15732293)
I'd imagine computers are more consistent. If the situation is one the automation can handle, it will handle it pretty much every time, assuming it's in good maintenance. Whereas a human's capability varies widely based on a multitude of factors from fatigue to distractions to medical issues to plain old overconfidence.

Ultimately, it's probably easier to quantify the likelihood of an failure in automation than it is to quantify the likelihood of a human error.

Re:Argentina says signals detected, likely from missing subm... by jonsen on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:59PM (#15732344)
There must be considerable unscertainty in calculating the human error rate after eight months of interplanetary travel.