News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What tech were you convinced would take the world... by starsinspace on Friday November 17, 2017 @03:56PM (#15725884)
Peer-to-peer was killed by the advent of home routers doing NAT, making arbitrary inbound connections impossible. Configuring port forwarding was generally too difficult for "normal users", the web-UIs offered by typical home routers didn't make it easy enough. NAT traversal methods exist, but from my experience they are generally unreliable and/or slow.

I still remember the days when P2P connections over the internet "just worked, always" (the early Napster/Kazaa days), and then it went to "it works sometimes", and finally to "almost never works (except if the service offers some kind of middle-man datacenter to bounce the connections between the two NAT'd peers)".

Try to do a IRC DCC file transfer with anyone these days and see what I mean... long ago, it "just worked".

I blame today's unfortunate centralization of internet services largely on NAT breaking P2P connectivity. Who knows, maybe spread of IPv6 will fix this mess... some day...

Re:Ask HN: What tech were you convinced would take the world... by dabockster on Friday November 17, 2017 @05:10PM (#15726416)
IIRC, consumer wifi routers supposedly support a protocol that allows a computer to request a temporary port forward and release it when its finished using it.

Anyone remember what that protocol is called?

Re:Ask HN: What tech were you convinced would take the world... by thrown_produce on Friday November 17, 2017 @06:34PM (#15726873)
UPnP, Universal Plug and Play.
Re:Ask HN: What tech were you convinced would take the world... by dabockster on Friday November 17, 2017 @09:45PM (#15727518)
Yep, that's it. How useful is it in practice? I haven't ventured into those settings ever since I got my Airport Extreme.
Re:Ask HN: What tech were you convinced would take the world... by lenkite on Sunday November 19, 2017 @03:53PM (#15735884)
Pretty much every torrent software supports UPnP/NAT-PMP today. The problem was UPnP came a bit late - the spec was published only in 2008, and by that time everything was fire-walled off and required more-than-idiot-capability to expose.