News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by btilly on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:03PM (#1572285)
The point I consider most important is only alluded to.

In NY people try to maintain monopolies of information. One place that applies to is a very restrictive work for hire doctrine. If you have a job in NYC, by default everything you create belongs to your employer. Even if it was done at home on your equipment. In California that particular right is one that remains yours and cannot be lost (unless what you do relates to your employer's business).

The result is that in California it is common for people to have a day job and work on the side on a startup. You almost never see the side startup in NY. Furthermore if you do see it, those startups can be squashed in an instant when the employer finds out about it. I've seen it happen. Not pretty. (The same thing can happen, and does from time to time, with open source projects. However it happens less often because there are fewer cases where someone wants to leave their day job for their open source project than cases where they want to leave their day job for their startup.)

That nasty little dynamic is a constant hidden drag on NY. Nobody knows how many good ideas got squashed and never saw the light of day...

Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by fragmede on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @04:29PM (#1572637)
Don't forget non-compete agreements - valid in NY, invalid in CA. So not only can you NOT leave your day job for a startup, you typically have to wait 2 (or more) years before being able to freely work on any projects. (If your start up is in a completely different area than your day-job, you may be able to get away with it sooner. But don't think that corporations are lax about enforcing the non-compete you signed.)
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by randomtask on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @09:08PM (#1573350)
"So not only can you NOT leave your day job for a startup, you typically have to wait 2 (or more) years before being able to freely work on any projects."

If this is true then how does moving job generally work in NYC? Presumably people there aren't expected to work for one employer all their life or take years off in between jobs?

Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by gamble on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @01:29AM (#1573735)
These clauses are only enforced when it's an easy win for the litigator - for example, key employees going to a direct rival or a startup with no legal budget.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by randomtask on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @02:06AM (#1573787)
That makes sense.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by philwelch on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @12:48AM (#1573679)
Perhaps they move out of NYC to a state that doesn't enforce non-competes for years, and then possibly move back.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by loewenskind on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:49AM (#1574347)
I call bollocks. I don't doubt that companies make these silly agreements, I don't doubt that companies actually try to enforce them, and I don't doubt that employees cave in thinking they have no options.

What I doubt is that if a company tried to enforce one of these ridiculous agreements that it would hold up in court. Are you trying to tell me that if I work in networking for a new york company I can't get another job for 2 years? That's just not possible.

Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by yummyfajitas on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:29PM (#1572403)
If you have a job in NYC, by default everything you create belongs to your employer.

Only work you've done in the course of your employment is owned by your employer, by default. This can be modified by contract, however.

CA does not enforce some contracts while NY does, but the default is that you own all your after-hours work.

Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by btilly on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @04:13PM (#1572591)
What you said is federal law. But what my lawyer told me when I lived in NY is that "in the course of your employment" has non-intuitive consequences.

What I was told is that there are 3 classes of employee. If you punch in and out on a clock and get paid by the hour, you are hourly. If your work is governed by piecework contracts, you are a contractor. In those cases the scope of your employment is clear. Otherwise you're a professional employee. (Most programmers are professional employees.) For professional employees there are no working hours, and no non-working hours either. Have a good idea in the shower? Your employer has a potential claim on it.

Whether they can claim any given project is more complex, though. The farther away your activity is from your day job, the harder it is for them to enforce a claim. So, for instance, a programmer who writes programs on the side is likely in trouble. But a novel on the side is fine.

In any case the default doesn't matter that much in practice because standard boilerplate contracts reinforce this by making broad claims that anything you do in your own time belongs to your employer. And NY courts are fairly generous to employers in resolving any disputes that arise.

Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by angstrom on Thursday August 05, 2010 @10:37AM (#1578155)
I view it similar to apartments that don't explicitly state 'no pets'. If you're not hoarding pets or using company related IP, odds are good you're in the clear.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by yummyfajitas on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @05:19PM (#1572789)
You could be right if NY has a law more strict than federal law. Do you have information on this?
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by btilly on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @05:35PM (#1572838)
Email sent with what little information I have.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by rjurney on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @09:49PM (#1573419)
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by btilly on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @12:54AM (#1573685)
That link has no bearing on NY state law.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by nycintern on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @04:30PM (#1572640)
As an intern who works in a Web Company in nyc, I can attest to the claim of above comment. My agreement with my employer even for an internship had this clear clause.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by joshwa on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:36PM (#1572442)
Do you have any references for this? (speaking as a NYC-based employee with various side projects)
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by btilly on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @04:25PM (#1572622)
Sorry, I don't have the appropriate statute in front of me. Merely memory from discussions some 8 years ago. If you wish to know more, I strongly recommend talking with a competent lawyer.

Also note that there are a lot of caveats where details of your specific situation could make you fine. (Or not.)

Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by rjurney on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @09:48PM (#1573416)
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by api on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:11PM (#1572318)
If I'm not mistaken, Massachusetts is more like California in that respect. That might be one reason Boston is better than NYC for tech.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by francoisdevlin on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:37PM (#1572446)
Well, MIT & Harvard don't hurt...
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by api on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:52PM (#1572511)
They gather the brains, yes. But a feudal business culture would make that irrelevant. Feudal social contracts in general kill all forms of innovation.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by loewenskind on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:57AM (#1574361)
>Even if it was done at home on your equipment.

Have any examples of this actually being enforced (in court. I'm sure they've scared people with lawyer-ese before)? It's hard to image that the law basically says that the company owns you even if you're not "on the clock".

Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by j2d2 on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @03:59PM (#1572545)
This is garbage. California does this as much as NYC.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by btilly on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @04:17PM (#1572601)
http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=lab... offers significant protection to employees in California. There is nothing in NY law that offers similar protection.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by j2d2 on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @06:18PM (#1572965)
That is actually a great point. When was this law made?

Also, this only protects people who are aware of it and willing to fight for it

Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by btilly on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @07:11PM (#1573080)
I do not know when the law was made. But the text of section 2872 at the bottom of that page suggests it was somewhere around 1980.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by j2d2 on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @09:10PM (#1573352)
Interestingly, I met many people in SF who had signed contracts that disagree with this law.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by zach on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @12:32AM (#1573654)
I was alarmed to discover the same a few times -- the contract had wide claims on IP, and then there was a separate part which said "of course, these are the enforceable limits according to this particular California law."

It seemed like they were pulling a fast one, but basically they were compartmentalizing so they could claim the maximum rights should the law be struck down or repealed (or the business moved outside California, I guess).

Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by rjurney on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @09:50PM (#1573423)
Both Bay Area companies I've worked for include California 2870-2872 with their new employment packs, right behind the NDA.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by j2d2 on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @10:01PM (#1573440)
One anecdote for another. I'll take it.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by btilly on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @11:13PM (#1573541)
That is required by 2872.
Re:New York will always be a tech backwater, I don’t care wh... by btilly on Tuesday August 03, 2010 @11:12PM (#1573539)
That's OK, the law takes priority anyways.