News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by tabeth on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:32PM (#15716835)
I sympthatize with the article and the person writing it, but if they shouldn't be taxed, why should people who pay post tax income for their undergraduate degree?
Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by scott_s on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:42PM (#15716924)
Because funded grad students are paid way, way below what they could get in a "real job" because it's an arrangement that benefits all: the grad student get the education and the degree, and the schools get cheap labor. Undergrads are typically not full-time employees of the school they attend. Funded grad students are. And for PhD students that are no longer taking classes, they are typically a net-positive in terms of cost.

For example, in my last two years of PhD, I was both a teaching assistant and an instructor. When grading finals weeks before graduating, one of the instructors I was a TA for joked that he's surprised they were letting me graduate because I was far too useful.

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by tabeth on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:45PM (#15716957)
The fact that they're paid below a "real job" is irrelevant. Should people working part time while doing their undergrad degree to pay if off also get the same benefit?

Like TAs they too are getting paid less than what they would with a "real job", working full time.

Not to mention getting a graduate degree is a relative privilege to begin with. Either everyone should get the benefit, or they should take loans out and not be required to work like everyone else. Anything else is just hypocrisy.

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by scott_s on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:53PM (#15717024)
The "real job" point is that people willingly are paid very little because of the arrangement. Undergrads are typically not full-time employees of the university, so it doesn't make sense for them to get the waiver. But, if an undergrad had a full scholarship from a university, I would also not want that taxed as income.

It's this arrangement that enables more people to become grad students, not less. As the NYT opinion piece points out, these new rules will make it that only people who are independently wealthy, or can depend on support from wealthier family members, will be able to afford going to grad school.

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by tabeth on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:57PM (#15717054)
> As the NYT opinion piece points out, these new rules will make it that only people who are independently wealthy, or can depend on support from wealthier family members, will be able to afford going to grad school.

Again, the NYT article is fallacious. Such a student could take out loans, just like undergraduate students.

It's nonsensical. There's no reason for admission and payment to be coupled.

Also, the amount being paid is irrelevant. A university could pay graduate students $33k/yr + whatever it costs to attend their institution. The only reason they don't do this is because they'd be taxed. This arrangement is beneficial to the university. Not to mention the student would be taxed more heavily as well.

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by scott_s on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:02PM (#15717089)
> A university could pay graduate students $33k/yr + whatever it costs to attend their institution. The only reason they don't do this is because they'd be taxed.

The reason they don't do it is because for a large population of the grad students, it doesn't cost the university that much for that student to be at their school.

Loans are an extra burden, and grad school is an unbounded process. I spent 7.5 years in grad school. In practice, far, far fewer people will do it, and it will tend to be people who are already much better off financially. This will hinder class and economic upward mobility.

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by tabeth on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:10PM (#15717142)
I'm really not understanding you.

1. Everything you said applies to undergraduate students.

2. Undergraduate students are more in need than graduate students, not to mention that graduate students are better off financially.

So, yeah.

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by scott_s on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:28PM (#15717268)
I don't think undergrad students tend to spend 20 - 40 hours of their week teaching classes for the university they attend.
Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by tabeth on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:30PM (#15718022)
Again, I fail to see the relevance. There are undergraduates who work that much. Not to mention that no one forces you to do graduate school.

Why should graduate students alone get this benefit? For doing work they signed up for? Should university employees also not be taxed? There are tons of low paid researchers. Adjunct professors, etc.

Graduate students can just take loans out like everyone else (not that I like loans) You literally haven't given a reason for their special treatment. I think you're blind to the reality because you happened to go through grad school.

Finally, only top stem programs are funded. Most grad students, even phds, get loans. There's zero reason to discriminate on this.

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by danarlow on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:48PM (#15716984)
The graduate student is only getting paid $33k/yr. The university is paying for/waiving the student's $50k/yr tuition. Why should the student pay taxes on what the university is paying?
Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by tabeth on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:54PM (#15717034)
Except they're not being paid just $33k/yr. The IRS already has a precedent surrounding cash-value equivalents.
Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by thephyber on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:38PM (#15716895)
This seems like apples and oranges.

In exchange for work, grad students usually get a combination of a stipend and free/subsidized tuition. This is described in the second paragraph of TFA.

> why should people who pay post tax income for their undergraduate degree

Are they being paid to get their undergrad degree? Most likely they are paying. And tuition at an accredited educational institution has traditionally been tax deductible, so it's not technically "post-tax income".

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by alistairSH on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:44PM (#15716944)
If your income is at a level where you are paying cash for tuition, you likely do not qualify for education-related tax benefits.

AOTC requires AGI <$80k ($160k married/joint) LLC requires AGI <$65k ($130k married/joint) Tuition deduction requires AGI <$80k ($160k married/joint)

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by jogjayr on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:37PM (#15716890)
You can already take a tax deduction for eligible educational expenses for yourself or dependents. Undergraduate tuition certainly falls under that