Re:Magic: The Gathering Is Turing Complete (2012)
by literallycancer on Thursday November 16, 2017 @01:40PM
(#15715271)
>"Please indicate what you did, step by ste-COUNTER"
What's the advantage over simply specifying the moment you wanted to react out of the last batch of actions (like a normal person)? If the opponent skips too many steps and gives up some critical information as a result -- his problem.
Re:Magic: The Gathering Is Turing Complete (2012)
by mattnewton on Thursday November 16, 2017 @01:58PM
(#15715416)
Because that leads to bad feels; did you counter X because you know I have Y in my hand now? I always try to explicitly pass priority after spells even in causal settings when I mean to.
Re:Magic: The Gathering Is Turing Complete (2012)
by crankylinuxuser on Thursday November 16, 2017 @02:15PM
(#15715592)
In a way, its an iterated prisoner's dilemma. Sure, I can construct a "infinite beatdown deck" that you lose 99% of the time. And guess what? I'll win.
And that next game, they'll say "ditch that deck or you aren't playing".
These days, I play explicit decks that have a neat theme and good win conditions (I have 2 decks left). They dont use infinite combos (they win, but are unfun), and I play to have a good time. If I lose, it was because I had some good threats and a blast of a game.
If you play Commander or multiplayer, then its usually a heck of a lot less formal. Ive also played some local tournament games where the players were good-natured and we all just had fun.
Then I've played some tournaments locally and at Gencon that were methodical and clockwork style "Please indicate what you did, step by ste-COUNTER". Or you get the priority police up and running, where you have to explicitly pass priority. I hate those games with a passion - it just drains the fun out via rules-lawyering.
I've not played in a few years, primarily because the game was feeling much more like 'loot crates' that I've railed against prior. And with $3.50/pack, I didn't feel like I was getting enjoyment. You either buy buy buy, or get left in the dust and destroyed in games because you didnt buy buy buy.