Re:IBM Quad9 – A free security solution using DNS to protect...
by toast0 on Thursday November 16, 2017 @12:43PM
(#15714698)
Having the backup in a separate /24 allows the option of steering BGP announcements differently at different peering points (even if they aren't announced differently in the everything is working case).
In both networks, those IP addresses are almost certainly treated identically, virtualized to all hell with multiple physical termination points leading to the same pools of machines. One extra /24 isn't going to help reliability much if at all, especially considering it is part of the same AS.
Perhaps I'm wrong and Google use the /24 somehow for the purposes of internal routing. If that's true, in the same scenario IBM may be content to have just these two /32s in their internal tables where route aggregation could be be made to not apply.