Maybe you’re like an evil hypnotist. “You will stop following your diet. You will stop following your diet. You will stop following your diet.” :-)
Seriously though — I think these two claims are both frequent and harmful:
1. It’s impossible to stay disciplined in the long run.
2. Discipline sucks the joy out of life. On the contrary, I think discipline gives you freedom.
Saying "be disciplined" is roughly in the same category as telling someone to "be happy". It's a great goal, but no help at all for someone who is not already there.
Anyway, I don't see how you shattered anything.
First of all, I never attempted to do GTD exactly because I never saw the value. So I didn't fail at it I simply decided not to do it once I realized what it required.
Second of all that you have used GTD for years doesn't mean you are going to continue using it. Lets talk in 10 years and see.