News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Beginner´s Guide to Getting Things Done by peruvian on Monday November 13, 2017 @08:08AM (#15686241)
As much as I respect Mr Newport, a lot of books like his could be one long form blog post (or paragraph!) instead of a 200~ page book.
Re:A Beginner´s Guide to Getting Things Done by jrgifford on Monday November 13, 2017 @08:28AM (#15686372)
This is true, however he is trying to explain the idea to multiple people, so he's explaining his ideas in multiple ways.

So no, it could not be a long form blog post.

Re:A Beginner´s Guide to Getting Things Done by freyir on Monday November 13, 2017 @09:17AM (#15686651)
Is the idea that complicated? Can it not clearly and concisely be explained in a way that makes sense to a large audience? We see more complex ideas explained more concisely all the time.

It's not just Cal Newport, it's self-help and productivity authors in general. They have an idea, and then they repeat it over and over again until they have a book.

Maybe the repetition benefits the reader. Maybe it's easier to internalize an idea when it is hammered into your skull. Or maybe books are just more profitable than blog posts.

Re:A Beginner´s Guide to Getting Things Done by ashark on Monday November 13, 2017 @10:56AM (#15687341)
I find this even in well-respected and oft-recommended but relatively light non-fic outside the self help genre. Sagan's A Demon Haunted World and Cialdini's Influence both struck me as being twice as long as they had any reason to be, but they're nigh-classics in certain circles. It makes me reluctant to read non-fic, which tends either to be very specialized and ultra-dense (i.e. beyond my reach with a reasonable time investment) or fluffy trash.

However, better small-scale (paragraph to paragraph) structure of the text and somewhat higher info-density, or simply being more entertainingly-written, can go a long way. See Graeber's Debt for the former and Fussell's Class for the latter.

Re:A Beginner´s Guide to Getting Things Done by AlexCoventry on Monday November 13, 2017 @10:09PM (#15692291)
It's not just exposition, it's rhetoric. Self-help books take a lot of words because they're exhorting you to an ideology, not just explaining things.