Re:Equifax CEO to Congress: Not Sure We Are Encrypting Data
by dredmorbius on Friday November 10, 2017 @06:50PM
(#15674083)
I think we should be having a discussion about the dimensions of that, yes.
A set of questions I've been thinking through are:
What is privacy?
Can it be quantified?
What is identity?
What are the reasons we want to check or confirm identity?
Can some of those reasons be eliminated?
It seems to me that privacy is the ability to define and defend boundaries of information and disclosure. That the question of what is or isn't known, and to who's benefit that information is used (and in particular, to the benefit of the subject of the information, of society as a whole, or some specific third party or parties), matter. That there is a continuum of interests in protecting and revealing relevant information, much of which has to do with the relationship of the subject to society, and that those with great power, or a history of abusing society's trust, have a far smaller claim to relevant privacy. (Balanced, perhaps, with potential consequent risks: the wealthy in parts of the world are subject to stalkers, frauds, kidnapping, and extortion threats, for example.)
Persons in positions of high power, or convicted of crimes, or who've violated public trust, should be faced with greater disclosures. That would include, on at least two counts, Equifax's former CEO.
Much of the reason for seeking information is to establish trust or credit. Should I trust what you say, the capabilities you claim to have, that you own or control or have created specific properties, resources, or communications? Are you the specific subject of a given medical history? Do you owe, or can you claim, a tax debt or a pension credit?
Also part of this question is what risks (or opportunities) disclosure of specific information portends. Do the specifics of a romantic relationship you had 30 years ago matter? Does the fact that you are, or aren't, a politician, a military officer, or gay, matter? Or that the romantic partner was or was not of age of consent? Or that you were or weren't?
When is knowledge power or control? When is it liberating? For how long should it be controlled?
Do rights expire after a fixed set of time? On death? Or are they carried forward according to, say, tribal customs or beliefs? For how long?
A set of questions I've been thinking through are:
What is privacy?
Can it be quantified?
What is identity?
What are the reasons we want to check or confirm identity?
Can some of those reasons be eliminated?
It seems to me that privacy is the ability to define and defend boundaries of information and disclosure. That the question of what is or isn't known, and to who's benefit that information is used (and in particular, to the benefit of the subject of the information, of society as a whole, or some specific third party or parties), matter. That there is a continuum of interests in protecting and revealing relevant information, much of which has to do with the relationship of the subject to society, and that those with great power, or a history of abusing society's trust, have a far smaller claim to relevant privacy. (Balanced, perhaps, with potential consequent risks: the wealthy in parts of the world are subject to stalkers, frauds, kidnapping, and extortion threats, for example.)
Persons in positions of high power, or convicted of crimes, or who've violated public trust, should be faced with greater disclosures. That would include, on at least two counts, Equifax's former CEO.
Much of the reason for seeking information is to establish trust or credit. Should I trust what you say, the capabilities you claim to have, that you own or control or have created specific properties, resources, or communications? Are you the specific subject of a given medical history? Do you owe, or can you claim, a tax debt or a pension credit?
Also part of this question is what risks (or opportunities) disclosure of specific information portends. Do the specifics of a romantic relationship you had 30 years ago matter? Does the fact that you are, or aren't, a politician, a military officer, or gay, matter? Or that the romantic partner was or was not of age of consent? Or that you were or weren't?
When is knowledge power or control? When is it liberating? For how long should it be controlled?
Do rights expire after a fixed set of time? On death? Or are they carried forward according to, say, tribal customs or beliefs? For how long?