Re:Mail-Order CRISPR Kits Allow Anyone to Hack DNA
by craftyguy on Friday November 10, 2017 @05:23PM
(#15673576)
> It's not an injection you take that goes out and edits every cell and you magically change shape
I don't think that's what they were referring to. It seems that the concern is you make an edit, it is unsuccessful in implementing whatever you wanted but also breaks something critical (e.g. proper skull formation), and that gene is passed to your children who then suffer the consequences. That seems feasible to me, but I'm not a bio expert, don't play one on TV, and haven't stayed in a Holiday Inn in years.
Re:Mail-Order CRISPR Kits Allow Anyone to Hack DNA
by colechristensen on Friday November 10, 2017 @06:08PM
(#15673859)
Gene therapies are targeted to specific tissues/organs. The only way you pass on the genes is by using CRISPR/CAS9 to modify an embryo or gamete in IVF.
Re:Mail-Order CRISPR Kits Allow Anyone to Hack DNA
by ben_w on Friday November 10, 2017 @05:37PM
(#15673668)
Your suggestion is much more plausible than mine, especially as it won’t be noticed for at least 9 months after the modification. I was mainly inventing a nicely dramatic failure mode that seemed plausible on the assumption humans are just a bunch of self-replicating chemicals, so you could inject genes that say “send self-destruction signals to nearby cells that have not been modified like me, then grow into the gap they leave in [shape of new structure]”, much like the sexually transmitted genital cancer dogs can get that was in the news a while ago.
But it's also not how CRISPR/CAS9 works either. Gene therapies usually involve a process of extracting stem cells, modifying a small number of them in vitro, growing them, and then either using them to grow tissues out of the body for later implantation, or injecting them into targeted tissues.
It's not an injection you take that goes out and edits every cell and you magically change shape. It makes for good scifi, not so much good science.