News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Equifax CEO to Congress: Not Sure We Are Encrypting Data by bllguo on Friday November 10, 2017 @03:40PM (#15672792)
Honestly, no. Because the flip side of that stance is that all information that has anything to do with me belongs solely to me. That just seems...naive? Unrealistic? I certainly don't find it morally repugnant or dehumanizing that someone can take a picture of me and keep it. And that's probably the mildest counterexample...

IMO it's only a problem if I did not give away that information. Thing is, we give away a lot of data about ourselves.

Re:Equifax CEO to Congress: Not Sure We Are Encrypting Data by kelnos on Friday November 10, 2017 @10:12PM (#15674799)
> IMO it's only a problem if I did not give away that information. Thing is, we give away a lot of data about ourselves.

Sure, and why is it so ridiculous to expect that I might change my mind about certain types of information, when given to a corporation, and want them to delete that information? Why shouldn't I have the right to, say, tell a company with sensitive financial data about me to delete it and terminate my relationship with them? If I can't do that, then I'm at their mercy not to sell that data, be acquired and have the data used in new ways that I did not authorize by the new owner, or be compromised and have that data in the hands of parties that would misuse it.

We're not talking about censoring obviously public information, here, or even allowing people to hide when they've done something newsworthy. We're talking about controlling the flow of, and access to, private, personally-identifying information.

Re:Equifax CEO to Congress: Not Sure We Are Encrypting Data by Silhouette on Saturday November 11, 2017 @03:46PM (#15678096)
Sure, and why is it so ridiculous to expect that I might change my mind about certain types of information, when given to a corporation, and want them to delete that information?

It's not ridiculous, but it does impose a cost on them, and by extension everyone else dealing with them, because you changed your mind. Whether you should automatically be entitled to impose that cost on everyone else and under what circumstances is not an easy question.

Why shouldn't I have the right to, say, tell a company with sensitive financial data about me to delete it and terminate my relationship with them?

Maybe they need that data for their own financial records. Maybe those records are things they are required by law to keep.

Maybe they use that data to protect themselves against fraud or other abuses, and only use it in reasonable ways for those purposes, and allowing fraudsters to require them to delete all traces of their previous interactions would leave them unreasonably vulnerable.

If I can't do that, then I'm at their mercy not to sell that data, be acquired and have the data used in new ways that I did not authorize by the new owner, or be compromised and have that data in the hands of parties that would misuse it.

That's a false dichotomy. Practical data protection is almost always going to be about restricting not just the initial collection of data but also how that data may be used and by whom once it has been collected. An isolationist approach where everything can be kept totally secret is impractical, but it's usually not what we really want anyway, since then you couldn't do anything useful and intentional with the data either. It's more useful to ensure that people who have some data about us for legitimate purposes do not to then repurpose that data or share it with others for less legitimate purposes or without sufficient transparency and additional consent as appropriate.

Re:Equifax CEO to Congress: Not Sure We Are Encrypting Data by kelnos on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @10:23PM (#15701232)
> It's not ridiculous, but it does impose a cost on them, and by extension everyone else dealing with them, because you changed your mind. Whether you should automatically be entitled to impose that cost on everyone else and under what circumstances is not an easy question.

Sure, and that's why we have initiatives like the GDPR that try to answer that question. It's not going to be perfect, but throwing up our hands and giving up isn't an answer either.

> Maybe they need that data for their own financial records. Maybe those records are things they are required by law to keep.

Needing that information to be personally-identifiable is pretty rare, and cases where that information needs to be retained for a long time are even rarer. But in cases where it's necessary, sure, of course, go for it. The point is that the data needs to be collected and kept for a legit business purpose.

> That's a false dichotomy.

No, it's not.

> Practical data protection is almost always going to be about restricting not just the initial collection of data but also how that data may be used and by whom once it has been collected.

That's been shown not to work all that well. Companies lose control of data all the time, whether due to a data breach, or due to unscrupulous practices internally that takes existing data to use in new ways, even if not specifically authorized.

> An isolationist approach where everything can be kept totally secret is impractical, but it's usually not what we really want anyway, since then you couldn't do anything useful and intentional with the data either.

Sure, and nowhere did I suggest that's what I wanted. Please stop putting words in my mouth. I'm totally fine giving out "secret" data if there's a benefit to my doing so. But if there is no benefit to me, then companies should not be entitled to my data.

Re:Equifax CEO to Congress: Not Sure We Are Encrypting Data by Silhouette on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:07PM (#15707805)
Sure, and that's why we have initiatives like the GDPR that try to answer that question. It's not going to be perfect, but throwing up our hands and giving up isn't an answer either.

I would argue that the approach taken by the GDPR is pretty close to just throwing up our hands and giving up, just coming down on the other extreme.

Needing that information to be personally-identifiable is pretty rare, and cases where that information needs to be retained for a long time are even rarer.

Not at all. Just look at the records you are required to keep under EU VAT rules. One of the big criticisms since the changes in 2015 has been that they require an already demanding standard of evidence to be kept for the location of every single customer you sell to (if you're selling something within the scope of the rule change, obviously), you're required to keep that information for years, and your records are subject to audit by any of 28 different national tax authorities.

But in cases where it's necessary, sure, of course, go for it. The point is that the data needs to be collected and kept for a legit business purpose.

And what happens when that data includes, say, an IP address that was subject to geolocation when a customer was charged, thus linking that IP address and everything else in every log or database entry that you ever collected that mentions it with that specific customer? Since you may effectively be forced to keep the IP address associated with the customer to meet mandatory standards for tax record-keeping, must you now purge every related record or log line even from backups, on demand and entirely at your own expense?

What if those backups are stored, as many are, in an encrypted, deduplicating format? Are you now required to go through every backup you've ever taken in the history of your business and systematically obfuscate or delete every mention of that IP address? Do you have to take steps to erase any trace of it from the storage media involved, in case the media are lost and subject to recovery measures after an ordinary deletion? Do you realise how much time and money would be involved in doing that, every time a customer decided they didn't want you storing any personal data about them any more? It's totally impractical. There has to be some measure of being reasonable and proportionate in what is required.

That's been shown not to work all that well.

It doesn't work well when the regulations aren't enforced and there are limited meaningful penalties even for the sort of gross negligence that we've seen in cases like the Equifax leak. The idea that what Equifax did was compliant with the current rules is laughable, yet they've barely taken a slap on the wrist for it, despite both the degree of negligence that led to the breach and the scale and nature of the potential damage.

There's nothing inherently wrong with the principle, though. After all, there are many other things that we could do, but which are illegal and most of us don't, and we penalise those who break those laws. Why should this be any different?

I'm totally fine giving out "secret" data if there's a benefit to my doing so. But if there is no benefit to me, then companies should not be entitled to my data.

But that wasn't the scenario we were talking about. We were talking about a situation where someone legitimately had personal data about you, and you subsequently changed your mind and wanted them to delete that data. From the point of view of someone controlling and processing personal data in legitimate ways, giving you an absolute right to revoke that permission regardless of the practical consequences to anyone else involved is a totally different situation to giving you a right not to be involved in the first place.

Re:Equifax CEO to Congress: Not Sure We Are Encrypting Data by nostrademons on Friday November 10, 2017 @03:57PM (#15672966)
There's an excluded-middle fallacy here somewhere.

I don't really have a problem if I end up in the background of someone's family photo and then they stick it in an album or on a hard disk somewhere. I'd have a pretty big problem if someone snapped a photo of me in a public place and then sold it to a white supremacist magazine as "the face of minorities taking over this country". We'd have an even bigger problem if there was somebody out there who had hacked every security camera in the world and was collecting images to train facial recognition for a fleet of killer drones who would eliminate all his adversaries.

These situations are not the same. Most people have no problem with the first. Most people would be pretty terrified of the last.

Re:Equifax CEO to Congress: Not Sure We Are Encrypting Data by aeorgnoieang on Friday November 10, 2017 @05:12PM (#15673496)
There might be an excluded-middle fallacy here somewhere but you haven't provided any clues as to its location.

But I think I get the gist of the thing you're pointing at, but surely you can understand why are other people would be wary of deciding what exactly is problematic in this regard via legislation, police, courts, etc., particularly as they exist today.