News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by PKop on Thursday November 09, 2017 @02:54PM (#15665354)
"So, this is the next attack vector? Bitcoin is not green? The energy put into Proof-of-work is what makes the system immutable. People who complain about bitcoin's energy use, don't seem to grasp what makes the bitcoin Blockchain immutable. In order to change the Database, you have to go back > and do the "work" which becomes practically impossible after approx. 10 blocks. You take that away and you'll make the system Tamper evident, and not Tamper Proof as it is right now. It's the only secure data base ever invented, and thats because of the energy used to secure it.

I don't see these people complaining how much energy Las Vegas wastes. Or Hollywood. What about professional sports? How much energy does going to war cost? All of these are less important than the only sovereign moneys system in the history of man-kind. So, please, stop complaining about the energy use, i left my violin at home."

- daggerhashimoto

In addition, if Bitcoin disrupts the banking industry and a portion of wall street, we'd have to subtract their energy consumption.

It's just logically lazy to not consider if the benefits outweigh the costs, and sound immutable finite hard money out of reach of central authorities brings with it enormous benefits.

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by nerdponx on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:50PM (#15666120)
I don't see these people complaining how much energy Las Vegas wastes. Or Hollywood. What about professional sports? How much energy does going to war cost?

FWIW I complain about these things all the time and I just get weird looks.

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by w-ll on Thursday November 09, 2017 @03:11PM (#15665475)
Exactly.

Energy for gold mines, armourded trucks, petrol moving it all around the world, printing synthetics and chemicals, 24/7 always on ATMS all over the world.

Bitcoin mining allows me to send money to my family halfway across the world, nearly instantly, without a bank.

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by jacobr on Thursday November 09, 2017 @03:21PM (#15665569)
> I don't see these people complaining how much energy Las Vegas wastes. Or Hollywood. What about professional sports? How much energy does going to war cost?

We should, though. War destroys the planet. Energy consumption needs to go down across all areas, including entertainment and other things that we consider fun or useful.

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by Houshalter on Thursday November 09, 2017 @08:47PM (#15667318)
The cost of bitcoin is not even comparable to Hollywood or sports or any of the things you mentioned. Bitcoin is entirely based on energy and those things are not. You buy a $5 movie ticket and most of that money is going to actors, visual effects artists, and all the other names you see on the credits. You buy $5 worth of bitcoin and you have bought almost $5 worth of electricity.

Gwern estimates folding@home kills about 2 people every year just in the direct cost of air pollution (to say nothing of the effects of climate change.) https://www.gwern.net/Charity-is-not-about-helping Bitcoin is orders of magnitude bigger than folding@home. It's a complete massacre.

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by thisisit on Thursday November 09, 2017 @10:20PM (#15667680)
> You buy a $5 movie ticket and most of that money is going to actors, visual effects artists, and all the other names you see on the credits. You buy $5 worth of bitcoin and you have bought almost $5 worth of electricity.

So your defense effectively is if I buy $5 of food and eat it, well it is any lost any way so I should buy $5 of bitcoin instead? I am sorry but it is exactly this kind of flawed reasoning which ensures people don't take bitcoin seriously.

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by Houshalter on Thursday November 09, 2017 @11:20PM (#15667924)
I'm sorry I can't understand your comment. I am arguing against bitcoin. The environmental destruction and human loss of life caused by bitcoin is enormous.
Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by Asdfbla on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:32PM (#15666017)
> In addition, if Bitcoin disrupts the banking industry and a portion of wall street, we'd have to subtract their energy consumption.

Do you seriously think that? The cost of stuff like VISA's server farms or office buildings (and the rest of the financial industry) is probably globally negligible. Not to mention similar institutions would inevitably appear for cryptocurrencies (or already have, like Exchanges, etc.).

What remains is the horrendous cost for a Bitcoin transaction vs. the negligible cost for a 'normal' transaction in most trust-based systems.

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by cwkoss on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:38PM (#15666060)
Gotta count the energy cost of staff food, transport, facilities, etc. for every VISA employee to really make an accurate comparison. Plus power drain of each of millions of POS systems, cost of maintaining redundant secure backups of records...

Bitcoin requires no other infrastructure than computers. VISA needs a lot of various things to keep it's infrastructure working.

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by andrewchambers on Thursday November 09, 2017 @05:35PM (#15666359)
You think people mining bitcoin don't need food too?
Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by baddox on Thursday November 09, 2017 @06:31PM (#15666658)
People generally don’t mine bitcoin. Their computers do. And they don’t even need to sit at the mining rigs for 8 hours a day like most employees do.
Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by cwkoss on Thursday November 09, 2017 @06:34PM (#15666683)
Somebody made a video of manually bitcoin mining on paper once, kind of amusing

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y3dqhixzGVo

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by baddox on Thursday November 09, 2017 @06:42PM (#15666729)
Haha nice. I deliberately hedged with “generally” because I figured it must have been done at least once.
Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by ihuman on Thursday November 09, 2017 @03:13PM (#15665493)
Why did you quote a comment made 10 minutes before yours?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15665273

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by PKop on Thursday November 09, 2017 @03:28PM (#15665616)
Because it was dead when I got here, which I disagreed with but couldn't change.
Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by naveen99 on Thursday November 09, 2017 @03:19PM (#15665548)
> In order to change the Database, you have to go back > and do the "work" which becomes practically impossible after approx. 10 blocks.

I think if some entity devoted 1000x the current mining power, they would catch up in less than a year. Historical hash rates were negligible.

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by michaeltoth on Thursday November 09, 2017 @05:03PM (#15666209)
1000x the current mining power is 10% of global energy consumption. So they'd be spending 10% of global energy consumption for a year. This is infeasible unless done by a consortium of world governments, and to what end?
Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by AgentME on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:15PM (#15665926)
They could also profit extremely by legitimately mining now. Even if you assume they had magnitudes better and cheaper hashing technology, the opportunity cost to them of such an attack would be massive.
Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by tahw on Thursday November 09, 2017 @03:16PM (#15665510)
Why do you have such a persecution complex about this? You make fine points but your attitude is pretty off-putting, man.
Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by PKop on Thursday November 09, 2017 @03:35PM (#15665663)
Most of the quote was someone else's words whose comment was flagged which I thought was odd and I wanted to highlight his main point which I agreed with.

But to your question, I think Bitcoin is and will be persecuted by many powerful entities, wanting to control or kill it.

Money that has a fixed monetary policy is without question a threat to political and banking power in my opinion. Politicians and banks live off of inflationary fiat and debt. Also, fractional reserve banking. [Of course, a nation would benefit collectively from a move off of fiat money, but special interests would suffer]

Both things that Bitcoin is resistant to, which means it protects value these groups are stealing out of the currency (and the economy by 2nd order effects of bad money) and puts it back in the hands of individuals.

I don't think enough people have enough of a persecution complex when it comes to attacks on their money... and the superior alternative that is Bitcoin.

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by rothbardrand on Thursday November 09, 2017 @03:42PM (#15665712)
The control of money is the way society is enslaved. He may not have a complex, but we are all being exploited.
Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by rothbardrand on Thursday November 09, 2017 @03:40PM (#15665705)
Yes. The people who hate bitcoin -- despite all it does for them-- generally are hating it for political reasons.

They may hate sound money, they may worship at the alter of neo-keynsianism and think inflation is necessary (how else will you pay for bombing brown people?)

But they will use the "its anti-environment" claim because that has gotten traction.

We already have a massive global propaganda campaign spreading leftist views of the environment.

When bitcoin defeats these people, I will be very happy.

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by nosuchthing on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:17PM (#15665938)
Bitcoin maximalists are a curious bunch who fail to realize the service Bitcoin offers is functionally identical to other Blockchain coins, and in many cases the newer iterations add improvements and features.. whereas the Bitcoin core team holds the software with ideological constraints prohibiting upgrades to the design, to the detriment of user experience.

Additionally, the majority of Bitcoins were minted prior to 2014 so the incentive is skewed for old users to attempt to psychologically convince new adopters to purchase the "coins" they produced for low capital input by selling for a higher cost.

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by cromwellian on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:22PM (#15665971)
So, people bring up inefficiencies, scalability issues, problems with energy use, and you claim it's politics, but then immediately start attacking Keynesism, the "left", and elsewhere digging up ghost of Ayn Rand. Do you see the irony?
Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by CJefferson on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:11PM (#15665909)
bitcoin is currently inflationary -- what do you think is paying the miners, but new bitcoins created out of nothing?
Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by rtkwe on Thursday November 09, 2017 @04:19PM (#15665952)
It's mostly new BTC but there's also ~1-2 BTC per block of transaction fees now too. Some spikes up to around 4.

https://www.smartbit.com.au/charts/transaction-fees-per-bloc...

Re:Bitcoin's Enormous Energy Costs May Prove to Be Its Bigge... by rrhd on Thursday November 09, 2017 @05:56PM (#15666454)
I actually dislike it mostly because it seems to be full of people like you. The community seems full of people I just don't want to associate with.